Live data from Hacker News

How the Canadian Tech Scene Encourages Finite Gameplay

alexdanco.com

91–100 of 165 posts

Re: How the Canadian Tech Scene Encourages Finite Gameplay

#91
The Canadian startup bureaucracy is real. I find it kind of funny that the main requirement for IRAP funding is that you don't actually need the money.

It's extremely frustrating when you see a punt like Element AI get 20 million from the government, despite not having any product direction or seemingly any idea what to do with that money. It feels like people are rewarded for navigating the bureaucracy rather than actual startup success.

Re: How the Canadian Tech Scene Encourages Finite Gameplay

#92
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not Canadian companies that are 'keeping salaries' low, it's Valley Companies (and to some extent, American companies) that are paying a lot. Also - the USD varies at 1 to 1.5 CDN that has tremendous comparable effects. The 'reason' is that a vastly disproportionate amount of the surpluses go to the winners. '2cnd place is for chumps' - at least in the context of 'winner takes all' games. Everywhere outside of t…

>Who can blame anyone with 'no ties' to Canada moving on for 2x salary? Does that salary increase make up for the lost gov benefits (free healthcate etc?)

Yes, when you're young, healthy, and unencumbered by family. Like anyone who is mobile enough to make the move.

It's like the old bait-and-switch swindle.

Re: How the Canadian Tech Scene Encourages Finite Gameplay

#93

As someone who has worked in the Canadian tech scene for 25 years, and rode two startups all the way to exit (i.e. acquisition by US companies), in my opinion the problem has nothing to do with exit mindset, good angels, bad angels or SRED. It is all about talent retention. Up until early 2000, Canadian tech salaries at least somewhat kept pace with US salaries, albeit 20-30% lower. After the dot com crash, however,…

>Now that Amazon, Microsoft and Google are setting up shop right here in Canada, the talent drain away from Canadian companies is only accelerating. Maybe. Canada is bringing 400,000+ new immigrants per year until 2023 for permanent residence status, most of which are skilled workers of some kind. Probably a safe bet between that those three are setting up shop here in part because they can bring in international tal…

> Canada is bringing 400,000+ new immigrants per year until 2023 for permanent residence status

Canada is adding > 1% of its population in immigrants every year? I am curious if that is sustainable politically and economically. I suspect this will only drive down tech wages even further and put pressure on local housing markets, utilities, healthcare and social programs.

Re: How the Canadian Tech Scene Encourages Finite Gameplay

#94
post #12

One thing this article seems to miss is that the tech scene in Canada isn't the same as the tech scene in America because Canadian capitalism and ideals are vastly different than Americas. I'm a 6th generation Canadian who left and went to NYC to build tech companies, much to the dismay of my parents who continually asked "why are you so interested in getting above everyone else?". While I agree with a lot of what th…

> Canadians haven't really embraced ruthless capitalism fully.

You write that like it's a bad thing.

Re: How the Canadian Tech Scene Encourages Finite Gameplay

#95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You didn’t go over the possibility that Canadians may prefer to live in Canada compared to the United States. Last time I checked there wasn’t a race war and a group of belligerents storming the capitol in Canada.

The primary difference between Canada and the US was that Canada was small/smart/lucky enough to enact some social nets before the world became too easy to manipulate by media and the internet.

Not really. Our first attempts at universal healthcare involved general strikes from doctors and the government standing its ground. Some of the most important legislation and infrastructure in Canadian history was done under minority governments have to work with other political parties.

I would say it would it comes down to a much healthier government with more churn and not two different flavours of the same political party. I only found out this year that in certain states the ballots contain options "Vote all Democrat" or "Vote all Republican". Enshrining political parties like that into an electoral process reminds of the Soviet Union.

Re: How the Canadian Tech Scene Encourages Finite Gameplay

#96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Now that Amazon, Microsoft and Google are setting up shop right here in Canada, the talent drain away from Canadian companies is only accelerating. Maybe. Canada is bringing 400,000+ new immigrants per year until 2023 for permanent residence status, most of which are skilled workers of some kind. Probably a safe bet between that those three are setting up shop here in part because they can bring in international tal…

> Canada is bringing 400,000+ new immigrants per year until 2023 for permanent residence status Canada is adding > 1% of its population in immigrants every year? I am curious if that is sustainable politically and economically. I suspect this will only drive down tech wages even further and put pressure on local housing markets, utilities, healthcare and social programs.

The number is probably lower but still the bar is high for qualified immigrants (then there's the familiar reunion/refugees/etc)

Too bad Canada treats most of them like they came in a dinghy from some weird 3rd world country and leaves some of them in survival jobs (especially in a certain big eastern province)

Re: How the Canadian Tech Scene Encourages Finite Gameplay

#97
If you wanted to summarize that uncanny Canadian quality about television, movies, and lately startups, it's that they are the artifacts of a mandate, which is usually a condition of some kind of institutional funding, like SREDs, but also a bunch of other vehicles. The finite game is that a lot of capital and incentives come from agencies who have government mandates, which gives everything a certain tint.

So glad to read this. The author wrote a story some months ago about the reason SV angel works is because it's part of the social signalling for wealthy people. You make money, you show you can do it again, and that's what makes you a player. In Toronto, it's different.There are excellent global tech companies in Canada (Ubisoft, EcoBee, Shopify, Pornhub, etc.), but like everywhere, excellence is exceptional.

It's the "why is this weird? Oh, because they had to write around this condition of their granting agency." The US has tons of public funding as well, but much of it is defence driven, which has more general reusable business applicability than say, "culture," driven. Not sure what the solutions are, but something we should put words to as that weirdness has been a ceiling on growth and opportunity here for a couple of decades.

Re: How the Canadian Tech Scene Encourages Finite Gameplay

#98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Now that Amazon, Microsoft and Google are setting up shop right here in Canada, the talent drain away from Canadian companies is only accelerating. Maybe. Canada is bringing 400,000+ new immigrants per year until 2023 for permanent residence status, most of which are skilled workers of some kind. Probably a safe bet between that those three are setting up shop here in part because they can bring in international tal…

> Canada is bringing 400,000+ new immigrants per year until 2023 for permanent residence status Canada is adding > 1% of its population in immigrants every year? I am curious if that is sustainable politically and economically. I suspect this will only drive down tech wages even further and put pressure on local housing markets, utilities, healthcare and social programs.

Canada also adds 1% to its population in babies, who can't work at all, and are fully dependent on others for housing, healthcare, and social programs.

Re: How the Canadian Tech Scene Encourages Finite Gameplay

#99
"In contrast, infinite games are played for the purpose of continuing to play. You do not “win” infinite games; these are activities like learning, culture, community, or any exploration with no defined set of rules nor any pre-agreed-upon conditions for completion. The point of playing is to bring new players into the game, so they can play too. You never “win”, the play just gets more and more rewarding."

Sounds nice...

Re: How the Canadian Tech Scene Encourages Finite Gameplay

#100
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You consider "66% of California pay" low?

Wouldn't you, comparatively? It's not like your quality of work changed, it's solely location-based.

Purchasing Power Parity. The raise could end up entirely going to rent and healthcare
Post reply on HN