Live data from Hacker News

Playing chess is a life lesson in concentration

aeon.co

91–100 of 128 posts

Re: Playing chess is a life lesson in concentration

#91
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So how you do concentrate on things that are not chess and games which you find boring?

Neil Gaiman said that when he doesn't feel like writing, he gives himself two choices, either sit there and do nothing, or write. Then, he'll sit there, and after a few minutes, the boredom of doing nothing gets very strong, and he'll be motivated to write.

I'll have to give that a try. Because right now its write seriously (science), or play with the internet......

Re: Playing chess is a life lesson in concentration

#93
Chess teaches concentration, but also other skills as well. As I wrote in 2002[1], it also teaches things like strategic planning and resource management, ability to persevere despite setbacks, time/focus management, etc. It's certainly not unique in this, but it's a pretty good mix.

[1] http://pl.atyp.us/wordpress/index.php/2002/05/what-chess-has...

Re: Playing chess is a life lesson in concentration

#94
post #77

We nerd types have made this mistake for the last 75 years or so. This mystique about chess has been completely misplaced in my humble opinion. At first the claim was that Smart people played chess, therefore if you made a computer that played chess well it would be Smart. That turned out to be hilariously untrue, but durable: nerds were finally relieved of their arrogance after about 5 decades only when it became cl…

What you are saying is true. You can get life lessons from everything. Nevertheless, in some cases implicitly we talk not about the average or best case but the minimum. A university degree means you meet some minimum requirements. Being a doctor means you meet some minimum requirements. Of course, you can diversify well above the minimum.

Here, also, we are talking about the minimum. Sure, you can do gardening and think deeply about something, or you can feel very tired and the years just flow by.

In chess, if you play a bit, you need patience, you need to imagine next possible moves, you need to manage your time and perhaps also your emotions.

It is this minimum (or perceived minimum) that makes the difference. Not the expected and not the max as in other stories we tell ourselves.

Re: Playing chess is a life lesson in concentration

#95
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So how you do concentrate on things that are not chess and games which you find boring?

Neil Gaiman said that when he doesn't feel like writing, he gives himself two choices, either sit there and do nothing, or write. Then, he'll sit there, and after a few minutes, the boredom of doing nothing gets very strong, and he'll be motivated to write.

Jerry Seinfeld said the same thing for his comedy writing. I've found the advice to be incredibly helpful in my own work.

Re: Playing chess is a life lesson in concentration

#96
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I understand your point. It's a very addictive game. But I feel that the point of the author is that it's a game that requires skills that are useful in life. I kind of agree. Also it's easier to concentrate on something fun, challenging and in the case of blitz or bullet, fast and intense.

But what's the difference between Chess and if they stopped updating League of Legends? Even as an esports fan I find odd how much value people place on a game.

If they stopped updating League of Legends, then in 20 years it would be dead. Chess is here to stay for ages to come.

Re: Playing chess is a life lesson in concentration

#98
post #77

We nerd types have made this mistake for the last 75 years or so. This mystique about chess has been completely misplaced in my humble opinion. At first the claim was that Smart people played chess, therefore if you made a computer that played chess well it would be Smart. That turned out to be hilariously untrue, but durable: nerds were finally relieved of their arrogance after about 5 decades only when it became cl…

75 years? It's had a mystique for over 1000 years (going back to the Islamic golden age).

Re: Playing chess is a life lesson in concentration

#99
post #98
post #77

We nerd types have made this mistake for the last 75 years or so. This mystique about chess has been completely misplaced in my humble opinion. At first the claim was that Smart people played chess, therefore if you made a computer that played chess well it would be Smart. That turned out to be hilariously untrue, but durable: nerds were finally relieved of their arrogance after about 5 decades only when it became cl…

75 years? It's had a mystique for over 1000 years (going back to the Islamic golden age).

I meant in the programming world.

Re: Playing chess is a life lesson in concentration

#100
I suppose the transparency and the basic uniformity is what really separates chess from other mental activities. That is to say, there is no hidden information or any advantage that isn’t equally available to everyone. there are not too many activities that operate on that same sort of classless, egalitarian level, and so I can understand why the author is so passionate about it as a tool for learning the skills of concentration. With that in mind, I am terrible at it, and go makes me look like a drooling idiot... I can’t even understand when a game is over even though I try to practice every day.
Post reply on HN