Live data from Hacker News

Plants “panic” when it rains

phys.org

91–92 of 92 posts

Re: Plants “panic” when it rains

#91
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Panic is not the same as fear. Panic (insert here mythological reference to god Pan) is a kind of fear that causes uncontrolled, irrational and often counterproductive behaviour. Is that the case?

'uncontrolled and irrational' is only a bad thing in the context of human rationality and self control. plants obviously do not have such a thing--all their actions are primal and unmoderated. So panic for a plant would probably mean something like an immediate response to adverse stimuli, with an immediate and short-term goal of self-preservation.

"panic" means to react in a counterproductive way because fear overwhelms.

It's different from a mere adrenal response that has short term gain at long term risk.

Adrenaline makes you jump higher. Panic makes you jump off a cliff.

Re: Plants “panic” when it rains

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree. The word "panic" to me implies a certain mental state. Something plants lack.

Given plants utilize electrical signals I don’t see how you could argue they don’t have “mental states”?

CPU's and other electronic devices utilize electrical signals. Do you think they have mental states ?
Post reply on HN