Live data from Hacker News

This Old House: The Rare Home-Improvement Show That Spotlights Skilled Workers

theatlantic.com

91–100 of 132 posts

Re: This Old House: The Rare Home-Improvement Show That Spotlights Skilled Workers

#91
post #65

I absolutely love the sub PBS channel, Create (56.3 in Detroit). It comes in over the air, plays This Old House and all of the other content is soothing, professional and drama free. If you've cut the cord, but sometimes just want to turn on tv again, it might be a good idea to pick up a 5 dollar antenna

I will second create tv. In Boston it’s 44.3 They tend to have a lot of cooking shows, but there is a fair amount of woodworking/this old house.

I love the cooking shows! It's all instructional and not competition. It's really nice to have in the background while working from home, at the volume level I wish my open office was at (a decibel over a whisper)

Re: This Old House: The Rare Home-Improvement Show That Spotlights Skilled Workers

#92
One of the main problems with This Old House, the cost of the homes and projects are for the top 10% of income earners, so generally, they're not examples of rebuilds that can be had by the majority of home owners. I get that real copper gutters are cool and will last two lifetimes, but how many people can afford that? I could think of about a dozen examples like this that regular folk can not afford, slate roofs, stone fireplaces, old growth flooring etc.

Re: This Old House: The Rare Home-Improvement Show That Spotlights Skilled Workers

#93
post #92

One of the main problems with This Old House, the cost of the homes and projects are for the top 10% of income earners, so generally, they're not examples of rebuilds that can be had by the majority of home owners. I get that real copper gutters are cool and will last two lifetimes, but how many people can afford that? I could think of about a dozen examples like this that regular folk can not afford, slate roofs, st…

This is where "Ask This Old House" comes in. It's aimed at more normal person level of material.

Re: This Old House: The Rare Home-Improvement Show That Spotlights Skilled Workers

#94
post #11

The intellectual successor to This Old House's take on the entertainment potential of skilled craftsmanship probably isn't drama-filled reality TV, but rather YouTube channels like that of Paul Sellers. My drama-detesting father-in-law and his grandchildren watch those videos all day long to appreciate the craftsmanship, learning opportunities, and creativity of final products. I don't feel particularly concerned by…

I would add Matt Jackson and his Next Level Carpentry channel on YouTube. He's a true craftsman, and as far from drama as you can imagine. Definitely worth viewing.

[edit to make the channel name obvious]

Re: This Old House: The Rare Home-Improvement Show That Spotlights Skilled Workers

#95
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agree so much with this. Frank Howarth, Abom79, This Old Tony, Welding Tips and Tricks, Jimmy DiResta, Stumpy Nubs, Stefan Gotteswinter - there's so much great content like this on youtube. TV was never a great place for craft because it has to serve a general audience. Youtube has so much niche specific content with pretty great production values.

I used to think it was great, but now I think about a powermatic bandsaw. (AvE was involved. I chose wood shop because he said there weren't any old welders i.e. they don't live long)

ever seen a welder wearing a mask? I really haven't. But, I've seen many welders breathing stick welding fumes through a lit filter cigarette...sigh.

As someone who welds as a hobby, I'd say the bigger danger for anyone welding is probably grinding dust/silicosis, rather than welding fumes. (But, There are obvious qualifications, like don't weld zinc, etc.)

Re: This Old House: The Rare Home-Improvement Show That Spotlights Skilled Workers

#96
In addition to This Old House, I'd also really recommend viewers check out a Canadian show Holmes on Homes (and some of the successor series by the same guys) - That's more how modern construction and repairs should be done right and they also tackle cleaning up after some nightmares left behind by bad contractors.

Re: This Old House: The Rare Home-Improvement Show That Spotlights Skilled Workers

#97
post #19

Then there was that one season (roughly around when Bob Vila left) where they had new carpenter who was missing some fingers. One episode he shows up with a mass of bandages on one hand, gives a lecture on saw safety, and never appeared again.

here in the city, we do sew them back on now, you know..

Re: This Old House: The Rare Home-Improvement Show That Spotlights Skilled Workers

#98
post #15
post #11

The intellectual successor to This Old House's take on the entertainment potential of skilled craftsmanship probably isn't drama-filled reality TV, but rather YouTube channels like that of Paul Sellers. My drama-detesting father-in-law and his grandchildren watch those videos all day long to appreciate the craftsmanship, learning opportunities, and creativity of final products. I don't feel particularly concerned by…

Agree so much with this. Frank Howarth, Abom79, This Old Tony, Welding Tips and Tricks, Jimmy DiResta, Stumpy Nubs, Stefan Gotteswinter - there's so much great content like this on youtube. TV was never a great place for craft because it has to serve a general audience. Youtube has so much niche specific content with pretty great production values.

Somewhat surprised not to see ClickSpring [1] on your list. Though maybe not so much home-improvement (I'd argue Welding Tips and Tricks isn't so much either), Chris' series on making a skeleton clock shows some top notch craftsmanship, and the production values are amazing.

At the other end of the spectrum (low-tech but maybe considered home-improvement) would be Primitive Technology [2] - an Aussie that builds all manner of things from clay, sticks, vines, and fire.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/clickspring

[2] https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCAL3JXZSzSm8AlZyD3nQdBA

Re: This Old House: The Rare Home-Improvement Show That Spotlights Skilled Workers

#99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed that there are some real gems on Youtube. What is more, the various presentations work for different people, so finding someone who can explain the process to you in a way you understand is more manageable. I think the subtext of the article which is that skilled tradespeople are to be admired just as much as skilled professionals (doctors, lawyers, Etc.) is sometimes overlooked. For young people, especially t…

>>What is more, the various presentations work for different people This is such an excellent point, and something that really gives YT an advantage. For instance, AvE certainly has some excellent information in his videos, but I personally have found the presentation style (all the channel-specific jargon & toilet humor) increasingly off-putting; while a channel like this old tony still manages humorous content with…

It's interesting how AvE has become more bombastic as he's gotten more popular. And for Tom Lipton, his videos are significantly better if you speed them up to 1.5.

Re: This Old House: The Rare Home-Improvement Show That Spotlights Skilled Workers

#100
post #90
post #11

The intellectual successor to This Old House's take on the entertainment potential of skilled craftsmanship probably isn't drama-filled reality TV, but rather YouTube channels like that of Paul Sellers. My drama-detesting father-in-law and his grandchildren watch those videos all day long to appreciate the craftsmanship, learning opportunities, and creativity of final products. I don't feel particularly concerned by…

>I don't feel particularly concerned by the espoused narrative that skill is being replaced by drama on TV. This isn't even that new; your post reminds me of Orange County Choppers, supposedly a show about custom-made motorcycles. I tried watching this once or twice, many years ago (10+), when it first came out, thinking I'd get to see some interesting welding and such. No, I just saw a bunch of yelling and arguing.…

I was super bummed to see there is basically zero technical creativity of any kind that goes into those choppers, all have the same geometry and huge v twin engine. Now I get its more a visual work of art but I could care less what kind of flames are painted on the gas tank and can’t imagine who pays 20K for these.
Post reply on HN