Live data from Hacker News

AWS Outperforms GCP in the 2018 Cloud Report

cockroachlabs.com

91–100 of 104 posts

Re: AWS Outperforms GCP in the 2018 Cloud Report

#91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can't find the the text you quoted in the article. Did they edit it out?

Yes, it looks like the text was edited, but the table is still incorrect.

(editor here) Table was corrected last night, and the text was edited per the comment above and a few keen eyes internally who also caught the confusing sentence.

Re: AWS Outperforms GCP in the 2018 Cloud Report

#92

Developer experience on GCP is vastly superior to AWS. - Pricing on GCP is much easier, no need to purchase reserved instances, figure out all the details and buried AWS billing rules. Run your GCP instances and automatically get discounts. AWS reserved instances requires knowing your instance types, knowing that you can purchase the smallest type of an instance class and combine, knowing that you can only purchase 2…

> The bigger the disk on GCE, the more IOPS

This is true on AWS, too. Common advice for AWS is to just make your disk bigger instead of paying for provisioned IOPS.

Re: AWS Outperforms GCP in the 2018 Cloud Report

#93

Hey all - Seth from Google here. Thank you to the authors who worked on this report. These types of reports help us better understand the ways in which our customers and partners utilize our platform. Our team is reviewing the report and will provide a response as we conduct our own benchmarks. Varying factors impact these types of benchmark analyses, many of which are difficult to isolate and control. As an example,…

Where do you intend to publish your response? GCP blog [1]? I'd like to make sure I won't miss it, and this HN thread may be buried by the time you come up with a response. [1] https://cloud.google.com/blog/

Hi there - sorry for the delayed response. I'm still working on getting an answer here, but I didn't want to give the impression that I was ignoring the question. My suspicion is that we'll either work with the original authors or publish on the GCP blog, but I can't confirm any of those options at this time.

Re: AWS Outperforms GCP in the 2018 Cloud Report

#94

I've also benchmarked GCP vs. AWS [0], and, for the tests that I ran, found that GCP outperformed AWS by a factor of 3:1. Specifically, a GCP instance n1-highcpu-8 with a 256GB pd-ssd disk, clocked in at 11,728 IOPS vs an AWS c4.xlarge with a 256GB gp2 disk, clocking in at 3,634 IOPS. To put that in context of the blog post, it means your setup can drastically affect your results. Using local NVMe disk, for example,…

Yeah I think the instance types are different enough that this doesn't measure anything generally useful. Now comparing something like Lambda vs GCF, or GCS vs S3, that would be at least telling on a platform-wide scale.

Re: AWS Outperforms GCP in the 2018 Cloud Report

#95

Hey all - Seth from Google here. Thank you to the authors who worked on this report. These types of reports help us better understand the ways in which our customers and partners utilize our platform. Our team is reviewing the report and will provide a response as we conduct our own benchmarks. Varying factors impact these types of benchmark analyses, many of which are difficult to isolate and control. As an example,…

If you review the findings and then respond with, "Actually, GCP outperforms AWS," how many pinches of salt should we take your response with?

Yeah, again, all this really shows is that instance types don't translate well across cloud platforms comparison-wise because they are strictly different. See other posts.

Re: AWS Outperforms GCP in the 2018 Cloud Report

#97

Choosing a cloud provider is about more than just performance. For me, I lean towards GCP because of the combination of awesome UX, custom VM configurations (which also means GPUs attached to a custom # CPUs), no-bidding spot instances, and the multi-regional cloud storage offering that replicates data across many regions for much cheaper than AWS. I wrote about this last year if you're curious: https://medium.com/@r…

AWS API gateway is one of the worst UIs I've ever used in my life. Lambda isn't great either. That said I love AWS, but I haven't used GCP much.

Re: AWS Outperforms GCP in the 2018 Cloud Report

#99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

By nature large companies have massive global teams and there is no single provider for anything. Team A could using AWS, while team B cloud be using GCP, and team C is using Azure. Just because team B says they are using GCP doesn't mean the others are lying. Or, that there is anything weird going on.

Actually I meant to say that the news on the grapevine is that the big cloud players (GCP etc.) are potentially outsourcing demand for cloud services in excess of their capacity to AWS...

not a chance.

Re: AWS Outperforms GCP in the 2018 Cloud Report

#100

Hey all - Seth from Google here. Thank you to the authors who worked on this report. These types of reports help us better understand the ways in which our customers and partners utilize our platform. Our team is reviewing the report and will provide a response as we conduct our own benchmarks. Varying factors impact these types of benchmark analyses, many of which are difficult to isolate and control. As an example,…

TIL that Seth Vargo is now working at Google.

Dude, I sure hope they deserve having you on board. I am not at all convinced that they are capable of understanding just how much you bring to the table.

My opinion of them has definitely gone up a few notches.

Post reply on HN