Live data from Hacker News

Adderall Risks: Much More Than You Wanted to Know

slatestarcodex.com

91–100 of 195 posts

Re: Adderall Risks: Much More Than You Wanted to Know

#91

I was high school dropout turned Yale PhD. I was prescribed for either Adderall or Ritalin for about 20 years starting in my second year of University. The two main side effects I had from Adderall were appetite suppression (which has the bonus side effect of intermitent fasting) and hyper focus. With hyper focus I could work like a machine for 14-16 hours, and would have to remind myself to stop and eat, but I could…

That's how I feel about drugs in general, but I think society has this weird split of two extremes: any unprescribed, street drug is super dangerous and evil, and any prescribed drug is just just medicine correcting an "imbalance", and is totally benign and fine and good. Madness both ways.

You mention getting prescribed in college, as a adult. How would you feel if you had been prescribed as a kid?

To me, growing up regularly taking amphetamines seems like it could twist your head pretty badly. Seems very irresponsible to be giving drugs to kids.

(I get the pressure to do it if the kid can't behave or focus and you think that's fucking up their life, but honestly, having gone through school, the fault is much more likely to lie with the school & what we expect of kids than the kids themselves...)

Re: Adderall Risks: Much More Than You Wanted to Know

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The point of a to-do list (or reminder in Google Calendar) is that it's constantly staring at you until you actually complete it. It sounds like you're using one-off calendar entries. I'm not suggesting that "try not having ADD", just suggesting you use mechanisms to remind you to do stuff that are persistent and thus work.

> The point of a to-do list (or reminder in Google Calendar) is that it's constantly staring at you until you actually complete it. It sounds like you're using one-off calendar entries. I'm not suggesting that "try not having ADD", just suggesting you use mechanisms to remind you to do stuff that are persistent and thus work. No offense, but from what you're saying, it's pretty clear you don't understand how ADHD wor…

How does a persistent in-your-face reminder that does not go away until completed fail? I suppose severe procrastination or complete lack of willpower would do it, but are these not different from ADHD?

Re: Adderall Risks: Much More Than You Wanted to Know

#93

A friend of mine who has ADHD takes Vyvanse instead. Does it have similar risks?

(Disclaimer: I've studied pharmacokinetics, though I'm not a pharmacologist)

Vyvanse is a prodrug. That means it metabolizes into the d-enantiomer of amphetamine, whereas Adderall contains a 75-25 mixture of the d- and l-enantiomers. (Enantiomers are like left- and right-handed gloves: they have the same chemical structure, but one is the mirror image of the other. Usually two enantiomers will have similar but slightly different effects; occasionally, they can have incredibly different effects - see thalidomide for an example).

So, without further study, it's hard to know, but it's likely that Vyvanse has a similar long-term profile to Adderall, because the active ingredient (lisdexamfetamine) metabolizes into the active ingredient that makes up about 75% of Adderall.

But, it's possible that the effects described are caused by the l-enantiomer, in which case they won't apply to Vyvanse. It's also possible that lisdexamfetamine itself has its own set of effects which may either cancel out or exacerbate the effects reported by Adderall.

To give you an idea of how prodrugs can have different effects from the drug that they metabolize into: Vyvanse does have a rather nasty feedback loop for some people, because amphetamines suppress the appetite, but lisdexamfetamine is metabolized into the active ingredient using the digestive cycle[0]. For some people, this can cause a really wonky extended release cycle, where they have no appetite mid-day (due to the drug) and can't eat enough to metabolize enough dextroamphetamine to get them through the afternoon, resulting in an afternoon crash. After this wears off and they develop an appetite again (around dinnertime), they'll eat, and then the dosage that was supposed to kick in after lunch finally kicks in after dinner, causing issues sleeping.

[0] This is intentional, and it's why Vyvanse is marketed as an "abuse-resistant" alternative to Adderall, because it's theoretically harder to extract an acute dosage from it.

Re: Adderall Risks: Much More Than You Wanted to Know

#95

Author does a decent job of going through some things, but this statement did not sit well with me. >I don’t think there are good data here, but my intuitions and personal experience is that “addiction” of the sort you get with heroin or tobacco is very rare, at least when responsible people without a personal or family history of addictive behavior take stimulants as prescribed. Most people agree the risk is lower f…

I'll offer an alternate voice here - I take Vyvanse, and went without insurance for a few months two years ago. I tried Adderall and Ritalin, and neither had comparable impact. I ended up spend ~$300 / 30 on Vyvanse and honestly thankful that it was available at that price each time.

With insurance, my prescription is $50 / 30. I typically don't take it on weekends in order to limit tolerance, which further reduces the ongoing costs.

Re: Adderall Risks: Much More Than You Wanted to Know

#96

Author does a decent job of going through some things, but this statement did not sit well with me. >I don’t think there are good data here, but my intuitions and personal experience is that “addiction” of the sort you get with heroin or tobacco is very rare, at least when responsible people without a personal or family history of addictive behavior take stimulants as prescribed. Most people agree the risk is lower f…

If you take the prescribed amount, addiction is not likely. --nothing bonkers about that.

Re: Adderall Risks: Much More Than You Wanted to Know

#97
post #39

Anyone here had luck with some kind of alternative treatment?

I was diagnosed with moderate ADHD, inattentive type, as a teenager and prescribed adderall. I was also quite depressed, but I hid that from my psychiatrist.

The adderall certainly helped me to focus, but the side effects were awful and I stopped taking it regularly. I’ve since been diagnosed with depression and started on sertraline (an SSRI), and very soon after noticed an improvement to my attention, ambition, and ability to complete tasks.

It’s not surprising, I guess, but near-constant thoughts of worthlessness/desire to die can make it quite difficult to focus on tasks and generally function.

Re: Adderall Risks: Much More Than You Wanted to Know

#98

"We could still have a principled definition of ADHD. It would be something like “People below the 5th percentile in ability to concentrate, as measured by this test.” Instead, we use the DSM, which advises us to diagnose people with ADHD if they say they have at least five symptoms from a list. " I'm in Germany and I've been diagnosed with ADHD-PI lately (I am in my 30s) after seeing a private specialist about this…

I am also from Germany, but moved to the US for work. I am 29. Recently someone suggested to me I might have ADHD. After learning more about it, I had a feeling that many adults with ADHD have: I suddenly felt like my life story made sense.

People below the 5th percentile in ability to concentrate, as measured by this test.

My health insurance made me take a CPT test and it indicated that I don't have ADHD. This means that they refuse to diagnose me despite that I have ALL of the inattentive symptoms. I did a lot of research on ADHD after that. Those tests have a 40-50% false negative rate. Luckily I am changing insurance next year. I already made an appointment with another doctor who is an expert in adult ADHD.

I don't know false positive rates off-hand, but they are properly much higher. Pretty much any mental or psychical illness causes inattention. There is no reliable test for ADHD. ADHD is not primarily about inability to concentrate, but executive function.

Instead, we use the DSM, which advises us to diagnose people with ADHD if they say they have at least five symptoms from a list.

This not true.

1. You need to have them "often" (approx. 5th percentile in the population)

2. You need to have them since childhood.

3. They may not be better explained by other disorders.

4. Need to have significant impairment in work, school or personal life.

Those criteria are based on decades of scientific research. They are the best way to diagnose ADHD. There has been promising research in computer tests, genetic tests and brain imaging, but none of those are reliable. A good doctor should spend significant time talking to the patient. Ideally they should also talk to other people who know them and review documents such as grade cards from school.

Re: Adderall Risks: Much More Than You Wanted to Know

#99
Adderall is amphetamine salts. It's f*king SPEED. Laboratory-grade SPEED. (yea, yea methamphetmine is delivered in higher concentrations when being abused, but I don't care Adderall is still goddamn SPEED -- and people give this shit to their kids!) It's not that far off from "meth minus the battery acid." Why on Earth anyone would want to give that shit to their own kids is beyond me, especially since it's often offered as a remedy to one of the MOST over- and mis-diagnosed conditions there is.

Re: Adderall Risks: Much More Than You Wanted to Know

#100

If anyone here reading this needs the motivation or gentle reminder: you might not need Adderall anymore. I've used it to get ahead in software for the past ~8 years. I recently gave it up, but it was hard to realize that it was time. It might be time for you, too. The thing holding me back was fear. Fear I wasn't enough, that I couldn't be efficient. That I would get fired from my high position. Or even if I could m…

I really relate with this. It took extraordinary measures for me to get where I can work efficiently without Adderall. Adderall turned me into such a different person that my wife started to be scared of me. Just interrupting me from work was a landmine, I was so mean. The doctor just said “be nicer” when I asked him about Adderall and anger issues. I’m a fun and easygoing person and it was like that part of me would get snuffed out and I’d become a robot on Adderall. I feel like it let me become a programmer. I locked myself in a home office for three months 10 hours a day learning to program, working on a demo project, and got my first professional position. The Adderall definitely enabled this singlemindedness.

To reorient myself in a way that I can concentrate on work without Adderall, I sold my TV, my VR, and my $700 graphics card. I unsubscribed from Netflix, deleted Facebook, and got rid of Twitter. I don’t listen to music as background noise, or in the car. I’ve gone on a ketogenic diet with no MSG (so no cheap meats like sausages). I try to sit without looking at my phone when I’m waiting for five or ten minutes somewhere. The whole idea was to “reset” my brain to a lower level of overall stimuli, and largely it has worked. I feel better and can work harder than I did on Adderall, because I can work in the evenings without having a total breakdown, because taking Adderall after 5pm was always a disaster, I wouldn’t be able to sleep and I’d have really weird thoughts as I went to sleep.

I’m really glad I did all this as it made me realize what’s really important in my life, family and to a smaller extent friends, and the time with them is much more meaningful now. I can actually concentrate on what someone is saying to me. Maybe moreso, I actually care.

Post reply on HN