Live data from Hacker News

No, I Don’t Want to Subscribe to Your Newsletter

python.sh

91–100 of 221 posts

Re: No, I Don’t Want to Subscribe to Your Newsletter

#91

I usually subscribe postmaster@(domain) to the newsletter as RFC822 requires the account to be active ;)

I doubt it's actually active on most domains even though the RFC asks for it to be so. I would even guess that admin@(domain) might be more effective. Just a guess on my part though.

Re: No, I Don’t Want to Subscribe to Your Newsletter

#92

Publishers should approach everything from the point of view of a person on the street: if it wouldn’t be acceptable in real life, WHY is it acceptable online!? The equivalent of a pop-up newsletter modal is somebody on the street PULLING you aside, standing directly in front of you and preventing you from going any further until you answer their question. All without bothering to observe what you were doing beforeha…

You mean like a bouncer checking IDs at the bar? If I don't want to give my ID to a stranger, then I just don't visit that bar, or find one with more lax security..

Those are different situations, bars have a legal obligation to prevent people under 21 from entering or they have to ID everyone buying alcohol.

Re: No, I Don’t Want to Subscribe to Your Newsletter

#93
post #39

From the perspective of crowdfunding 1. The crowdfunding sites themselves maintain HUGE newsletter lists and use very advanced analytics to determine what to place in those newsletters. 2. For campaigners, the size and activity of your email list is a huge factor in determining your campaign success. Just like this web tool https://www.thunderclap.it/about sending a direct email blast to a good list can mean the diff…

The author isn't opposed to newsletters at all, they're opposed to newsletter popups .

I've implemented these as well, they're not my favorite and it wasn't my decision to add them. However, after a certain point, for those popups which only appear after engaging with the content, there is some validity to the idea of this as a form of progressive signup/engagement.

Second, newsletter popups, with exceptions such as {Pinterest; Quora; Cook's Illustrated} these popups are not a pay-wall.

The better criticism is of the poor interaction design of such systems that don't treat any click outside of the modal as a modal exit command.

Re: No, I Don’t Want to Subscribe to Your Newsletter

#94
post #53

I made a add-on for myself to shun sites that behave in ways I don't like. It removes links to their sites from every page. It effectively removes them from the internet. I think that's a way scarier scenario for a website owner than just getting their ads blocked. If the list were community driven and widely used, I think site owners would start changing their behavior. I know most people just want the content and d…

Can your add-on remove all mentions of the Kardashians, Taylor Swift, Kanye, and Bruce/Caitlin Jenner?

Re: No, I Don’t Want to Subscribe to Your Newsletter

#96
post #72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think the street analogy is accurate; it's more like having someone at the door of every store you go into asking for your phone number as you walk in.

> it's more like having someone at the door of every store you go into asking for your phone number as you walk in. Which is exactly what many stores do, except on the way out (at the register.) They also tend to get pretty annoyed at you when you say "no thanks" to providing a number.

Is that a USA thing? I've never seen such behavior in my life.

Re: No, I Don’t Want to Subscribe to Your Newsletter

#97
How about cookie policy popups/notifications/extra-top -bar? It's getting increasingly annoying to browse the Web. Basically you have to close some signup modal, cookie warning, chat head before you can start reading the content only to get another blocking modal right after scrolling - which will 'kindly' ask you to disable ad blocker... It's getting better and better!

Re: No, I Don’t Want to Subscribe to Your Newsletter

#98
post #39

From the perspective of crowdfunding 1. The crowdfunding sites themselves maintain HUGE newsletter lists and use very advanced analytics to determine what to place in those newsletters. 2. For campaigners, the size and activity of your email list is a huge factor in determining your campaign success. Just like this web tool https://www.thunderclap.it/about sending a direct email blast to a good list can mean the diff…

> Just like this web tool https://www.thunderclap.it/about This is not a "web tool", this is a spam tool. > Sometimes people do want to be notified. No they don't. > Essentially therefore I'm arguing, the ability to gather a quality, targeted email list and generate a recurring newsletter without a 10%+ attrition rate [1] is both difficult and valuable. The web is a beautiful dream. It's being destroyed by people tha…

I'm sorry but calling said tool "spam" is hyperbole to the point of factual incorrectness. Furthermore, this said tool is recommended by Indiegogo's Field Guide, a direct publication of Indiegogo.com, the world's second largest Crowdfunding Platform. I suggest you re-evaluate your fallacious assertion.

Aside: You seem very argumentatively aggressive in your comments. Is that serving you or those you're communicating with?

Re: No, I Don’t Want to Subscribe to Your Newsletter

#99
post #97

How about cookie policy popups/notifications/extra-top -bar? It's getting increasingly annoying to browse the Web. Basically you have to close some signup modal, cookie warning, chat head before you can start reading the content only to get another blocking modal right after scrolling - which will 'kindly' ask you to disable ad blocker... It's getting better and better!

At least with the Brexit, we'll hopefully stop seeing them on UK sites.

Re: No, I Don’t Want to Subscribe to Your Newsletter

#100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

this, people are too worried about the size of their list as opposed to actual engagement. If they don't open your emails they're just costing you money with your ESP. If you have good content people will search hard for a way to get on your email list if necessary, i've done it before.

this is why it's good to require a credit card for a free trial. it will kill the top of your funnel but the bottom will actually get fatter because those who do sign up for the free trial actually want to demo your software.

...and lose all the people who might have been on the fence, but willing to give your product 1/2 a chance.
Post reply on HN