Live data from Hacker News

Ever wondered how many open FTP servers there are?

github.com

91–100 of 100 posts

Re: Ever wondered how many open FTP servers there are?

#91
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People do internet-wide scans all the time, for black hat and white hat reasons. I'm not aware of anyone doing this for research purposes ever having seen any legal consequences. But you usually get some angry emails to your abuse address. Of course this doesn't mean that some court somewhere may think this is illegal. But it's a common and widespread practice.

I'm wondering where the legal boundary lies though, port scanning might be a grey area but mostly fine. Connecting to an FTP service (i.e. logging in), even just for 5 or so seconds....I'm not so sure. Especially when big companies with lax security and aggressive lawyers might see this is as a "hacking attempt"

The law (in the US) pretty much defines hacking as accessing a system you don't have authorization to access. Very vague. Even a second of access to something you don't have permission to do is illegal.

Re: Ever wondered how many open FTP servers there are?

#92

Are there any legal implications for doing this? Was going to do something similar with Redis and MongoDB.

If your question is concerning US or German (/EU) law and how it affects scanning, you can drop me an email (minxomat@gmail.com) and I can give you some insights.

[deleted]

Re: Ever wondered how many open FTP servers there are?

#93
post #80
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"capitalizing Internet was still justifiable at the time" Given the Internet is a particular thing, shouldn't it still be used as a proper noun?

That isn't the rule in English; the telephone system is also still a particular thing, as is the ocean, the sky, and the air. What would you think if someone asked you to call them "on the Telephone"?

It is. And it's fairly straightforward:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalization_of_"Internet"

Re: Ever wondered how many open FTP servers there are?

#94

I used to leave a file called README on my public ftp directory, which contained only: cat: README: No such file or directory I'd occasionally get email from frustrated people who had trouble trying to read the README file, so I'd tell them to simply run "emacs README", and emacs would solve all of their problems. I don't know if my passive aggressive emacs evangelism ever worked, because I never heard back from them…

Reminds me of the Abbott and Costello skit "Who's on first" [1]

[1] https://youtu.be/kTcRRaXV-fg?t=63

Re: Ever wondered how many open FTP servers there are?

#95

I used to leave a file called README on my public ftp directory, which contained only: cat: README: No such file or directory I'd occasionally get email from frustrated people who had trouble trying to read the README file, so I'd tell them to simply run "emacs README", and emacs would solve all of their problems. I don't know if my passive aggressive emacs evangelism ever worked, because I never heard back from them…

>emacs

Well there's your problem

Re: Ever wondered how many open FTP servers there are?

#96
post #80
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"capitalizing Internet was still justifiable at the time" Given the Internet is a particular thing, shouldn't it still be used as a proper noun?

That isn't the rule in English; the telephone system is also still a particular thing, as is the ocean, the sky, and the air. What would you think if someone asked you to call them "on the Telephone"?

I think he meant that the name 'Internet' refers to a unique thing, the working global communication network connecting smaller networks of computers. The word 'internet', if it is to be accepted as a word with stable meaning in written language, should then not refer to the unique global network, but to something general, less unique, like the information service the 'Internet' is known to enable. If I saw the name 'Telephone system' with capital T in the middle of a sentence it would be curious, since such a name, in contrast to 'Internet' is extremely uncommon. Nevertheless, if the writer meant a unique system that has this name 'Telephone system', it would be correct to capitalize. However, when somebody asks me "call me on the telephone", they do not refer to unique global telephone system, they just refer to common service, like they would if they said "send it to me by mail" or "you can find it on the internet".

Re: Ever wondered how many open FTP servers there are?

#97

I wonder how many of those are just mirrors of Linux distros and other open-source software, how many have more interesting things (including software), and how many of those were deliberately configured to be open for sharing. There is the somewhat-well-known filesearch.ru if you want to look for things on this non-HTTP part of the Internet. (If I remember correctly, Google used to index FTPs too and you'd get plent…

> I wonder how many of those are just mirrors of Linux distros and other open-source software

Mine are, at least.

Re: Ever wondered how many open FTP servers there are?

#98
post #86
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

200 gigabytes at 57600 bits per second is a bit under 46 weeks. They could usually sustain that bandwidth; the bottleneck was usually the modem.

Ah, I was at 2400 bps until I had a university ethernet connection.

Anybody remember when modems cost $1 per baud?

Re: Ever wondered how many open FTP servers there are?

#100
post #79
post #71

I have a fun story about open FTP servers. When we were undergrad students, a friend and I wondered exactly that same question about FTP servers. So we wrote a script that tested random IPv4 for FTP servers using nmap and then attempted to connect. To our surprise we found quite a few. Most of them were small or not writable, but at least one of them was writable, and it had hundreds of GB of free space. So we connec…

I remember doing something similar except it was with my cable provider, when they first came into town. Since all clients would basically be connected to a LAN, as soon as I found I could port scan random users I started doing it. Of course there were a lot of businesses on the network that apparently used FTP to move files around but were unsecured. I spent the better part of a couple of weeks just going through th…

@Home was wide open around 1999ish. My friend would send random (if you can call goatse.cx random) print jobs to various open SMB printer shares. Ah, to be young again.
Post reply on HN