Live data from Hacker News

Facebook recommended that a psychiatrist’s patients friend each other

fusion.net

91–100 of 224 posts

Re: Facebook recommended that a psychiatrist’s patients friend each other

#91

TLDR#1: The investigation still didn't reveal exactly how this happened. TLDR#2: The recommendation to "prevent" these issues on the individuals side is, "Lisa’s medical community has started recommending that patients concerned about privacy not log into Facebook or other social media accounts at medical offices, or even leave their phones in their cars during appointments. " This is about as practical as recommendi…

[deleted]

Re: Facebook recommended that a psychiatrist’s patients friend each other

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Aren't they? How common do you imagine it to be, among Facebook employees, not to have a Facebook account?

"Aren't they?" No they are not. For example, it is now common knowledge that Mark Z bought off all nearby houses in every direction to get more privacy. [1] Do you and I have similar access to resources? Suppose your identity is stolen and you find yourself penniless because someone hacked into Facebook which also affected your friend who works at Facebook. Who is more likely to be in great financial distress the nex…

I don't know that Mark Zuckerberg's access to resources typifies that of Facebook employees in general, but I see what you're saying, and you make good points here which I'll have to consider at leisure.

Re: Facebook recommended that a psychiatrist’s patients friend each other

#93
post #84
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So basically don't install Facebook or Whatsapp try to use the Facebook website if you can or better yet don't use Facebook at all on your phone if you value your privacy. It's sad that we are at this stage but it's mostly our fault for being so complacent with companies doing these kinds of things. If people stopped using their service when they did these kinds of things they would change their behaviour really quic…

An individual's data sharing with Facebook is less of the issue, here, though. You personally not using it doesn't prevent you from becoming the common thread that ties others together. Just because I'm not on Facebook (I'm not), anyone that's allowed Facebook to see their own contacts, in their phone or email, has shown that they are or are not connected to me in some way. Without me actually ever even having an acc…

I think we're in for a slow painful transition until people (in aggregate) intuitively "get" exactly how invasive and unfriendly data-correlation can be when you expose yourself -- and your friends -- to when you share seemingly-innocuous facts with our welcomed-digital-overlords.

Re: Facebook recommended that a psychiatrist’s patients friend each other

#95
post #21

TLDR#1: The investigation still didn't reveal exactly how this happened. TLDR#2: The recommendation to "prevent" these issues on the individuals side is, "Lisa’s medical community has started recommending that patients concerned about privacy not log into Facebook or other social media accounts at medical offices, or even leave their phones in their cars during appointments. " This is about as practical as recommendi…

So basically don't install Facebook or Whatsapp try to use the Facebook website if you can or better yet don't use Facebook at all on your phone if you value your privacy. It's sad that we are at this stage but it's mostly our fault for being so complacent with companies doing these kinds of things. If people stopped using their service when they did these kinds of things they would change their behaviour really quic…

don't use Facebook at all on your phone if you value your privacy.

This has been my strategy for years, since the first time my entire contacts list got snarfed in.

Re: Facebook recommended that a psychiatrist’s patients friend each other

#96

> Facebook and the other companies in the Facebook family also may use information from us to improve your experiences within their services such as making product suggestions (for example, of friends or connections, or of interesting content) and showing relevant offers and ads. [whatsaap privacy policy] Many possibilities here: 1 - whatsapp connection with messages exchanged 2 - contact list loaded by whatsapp 3 -…

Or 10 people checked psychiatrist’s facebook profile, facebook found common interest, saw that none of these people are fb friends and suggested to become friends, because hey, you all have something in common, you are all interested in this person.

Re: Facebook recommended that a psychiatrist’s patients friend each other

#97

There should be a way to turn off "Peole you may know". I actually hate this feature.

If it has a consistent ID, you could add a custom stylesheet to your browser (or use an element hiding ad blocker) to hide it.

Re: Facebook recommended that a psychiatrist’s patients friend each other

#98
post #21

TLDR#1: The investigation still didn't reveal exactly how this happened. TLDR#2: The recommendation to "prevent" these issues on the individuals side is, "Lisa’s medical community has started recommending that patients concerned about privacy not log into Facebook or other social media accounts at medical offices, or even leave their phones in their cars during appointments. " This is about as practical as recommendi…

So basically don't install Facebook or Whatsapp try to use the Facebook website if you can or better yet don't use Facebook at all on your phone if you value your privacy. It's sad that we are at this stage but it's mostly our fault for being so complacent with companies doing these kinds of things. If people stopped using their service when they did these kinds of things they would change their behaviour really quic…

>So basically don't install Facebook or Whatsapp try to use the Facebook website if you can or better yet don't use Facebook at all on your phone if you value your privacy. It's sad that we are at this stage but it's mostly our fault for being so complacent with companies doing these kinds of things.

Exactly: it's our fault. None of this privacy-invading stuff is secret, it's all over the news. At this point, if you get burned by Facebook, it's your own fault for using it.

Re: Facebook recommended that a psychiatrist’s patients friend each other

#99

She lives in a small town, she specializes in treating a small subset of that population. It is quite possible the patients were recommended as friends as coincidence, not having anything to do with her.

"Most of her patients are senior citizens or people with serious health or developmental issues, but she has one outlier: a 30-something snowboarder. Usually, Facebook would recommend he friend people his own age, who snowboard and jump out of planes. But Lisa told me that he had started seeing older and infirm people, such as a 70-year-old gentleman with a walker and someone with cerebral palsy."

Re: Facebook recommended that a psychiatrist’s patients friend each other

#100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> ...it's mostly our fault for being so complacent with companies doing these kinds of things. > ...most people don't know or care that this is happening. You seem to contradict yourself.

Only if "our" is taken to include "most people". If we, the people who are aware of the situation, were less complacent, we would inform more of the general population (who don't read HN) and potentially convince others they should care too.

Yes. Hello. It's not a simple problem, at least not if you want to reach people instead of merely haranguing them.
Post reply on HN