Earlier quoted context omitted.
The following sentence from the essay is what I found very concerning: "If people relied on their stereotypes more or less rationally, they would rely on them to inform judgments when they had little or no definitive information, but ignore them when they had definitive information." The implication seems to be that as a rational person, in the absence of definitive information, you should discriminate against people…
Your finger is too quick on the trigger with the word "should" and therefore attributing malice to the author without justification. Are you sure you're not _stereotyping_ authors that have written about "stereotypes" as being closet racists instructing all of us to discriminate?!? That would be so meta. In any case, in the paragraph immediately before your extracted quote, he wrote: "To deal with the complexity, ...…
Truth in stereotypes
91–93 of 93 posts
Re: Truth in stereotypes
#92Earlier quoted context omitted.
Let's break it down by gender, a woman is an order of magnitude less likely to mug you than a man. The difference between groups (female or male) is MUCH larger than the difference in the groups (white male vs. black male or white female vs. black female)
> white male vs. black male or white female vs. black female These are still groups. I (a male) am much less likely to mug anyone (let's say 1 in a million chance this year) than certain individual women . Within the group of men and within the group of women, the "mugging probability" varies from almost zero to almost one.
Re: Truth in stereotypes
#93Earlier quoted context omitted.
Your finger is too quick on the trigger with the word "should" and therefore attributing malice to the author without justification. Are you sure you're not _stereotyping_ authors that have written about "stereotypes" as being closet racists instructing all of us to discriminate?!? That would be so meta. In any case, in the paragraph immediately before your extracted quote, he wrote: "To deal with the complexity, ...…
You have either misread or misunderstood the section I quoted. No, the author didn't just say that "people make decisions on the basis of stereotypes." He literally said that the rational thing for a person to do in the absence of perfect information, is to make decisions on the basis of stereotypes. If you are going to claim that "the rational thing to do is XYZ," that is certainly crossing the line into an endorsem…