Live data from Hacker News

The Obama Administration Has Embraced Legal Theories Broader Than John Yoo's

justsecurity.org

91–92 of 92 posts

Re: The Obama Administration Has Embraced Legal Theories Broader Than John Yoo's

#91
post #87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> At the same time, one of the motivating reasons for creating the Constitution as a whole was to create a powerful executive with broad authority to react to military threats, both external and internal. Why is it more faithful to the Constitution to give more weight to the 4th amendment and less weight to the President's broad powers as to national security? The justification for warrantless dragnet surveillance is…

People do not think that accidental deaths are comparable to intentional killings. We have elaborate mechanisms to distinguish the two because our fundamental outlook is that one is much more serious than the other. Besides that, it's almost certainly the case that terrorism has resulted in more deaths than has warrantless dragnet surveillance of cross-border traffic.

Intention is irrelevant to the argument I presented. The example I presented merely illustrates the level of risk, which is ridiculously low, and certainly doesn't justify military involvement.

> Besides that, it's almost certainly the case that terrorism has resulted in more deaths than has warrantless dragnet surveillance of cross-border traffic.

I don't see how that's relevant one whit. We don't control terrorist actions, we do control our own government's actions, and the latter's actions are restricted by the constitution.

Re: The Obama Administration Has Embraced Legal Theories Broader Than John Yoo's

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can't speak for the OP, but he may not be talking about the actual law or it's basis, but the execution of it, which has been a fiasco. We're 3 years into it, and insurance agents and "qualified" healthcare navigators still don't know what they're doing because it's so complicated. Never mind the security issues and complete lack of usability that is the healthcare.gov marketplace.

> complete lack of usability that is the healthcare.gov marketplace Oh come now. This is ridiculous hyperbole, and even the underlying idea is pretty weak at this point. I used the marketplace last June and it presented information clearly and effectively, and I had no problems going from zero to well-informed and insured in no time at all. The launch may have been a fiasco, but it's a pretty good site today.

If you have any sort of edge case when it comes to getting insurance, it's still has issues.
Post reply on HN