Live data from Hacker News

'Too many employees, but few work': Pichai, Zuckerberg sound the alarm

business-standard.com

891–900 of 1001 posts

Re: 'Too many employees, but few work': Pichai, Zuckerberg sound the alarm

#891

Earlier quoted context omitted.

MSFT is hardly a FAANG

Why? Their stock performs just as well, and they pay better than Amazon, better benefits, all with a reputation for legendary good WLB. Amazon is hardly a FAANG

I always understood FAANGS to be defined by their engineering culture and the innovative approach to problems, not just salary.

Hence the selection of companies.

Re: 'Too many employees, but few work': Pichai, Zuckerberg sound the alarm

#892
As many others have said here: 20% of the people at these big companies are not just doing nothing, they are getting in the way and providing negative value to the 80% who come to work to honestly try and get something done. It is bad for the company and the industry to be paying these people high six figures to be useless. It is unpleasant to work with them (if you even notice they're there) because it makes your work seem pointless.

If you asked the employees who the 20% were, I bet there would be consensus. They could be found and removed easily. It would also include plenty of managers and directors, it's not just leaf nodes who can be useless.

But the big tech companies are absolutely terrified of being seen as talent-hostile by firing low performers. So instead they will "turn up the heat" and hope the problem solves itself. They will complain that their employees aren't working hard enough without giving them any reasons to work harder or removing any obstacles in their way. As leaders they should be ashamed for not owning and fixing this problem.

Re: 'Too many employees, but few work': Pichai, Zuckerberg sound the alarm

#893

I work at one of the two mentioned companies. 20% of the employees do 80% of the work, and another 60% do maybe 50%. the last 20% account for -30%. It's demoralizing how incapable management seems to be at jettisoning the chaf, however it was explained to me once thusly: good engineers are hard to find and also very valuable. An unmotivated/lazy engineer is one step away from being a valuable engineer. It's worthwhil…

I love this framing, those percentages match up 100% with what I saw on the inside of a FAANG company.

Re: 'Too many employees, but few work': Pichai, Zuckerberg sound the alarm

#894
post #198

Quoted post unavailable.

Oh yes, those lazy Indian and Chinese people, they never get anything done

In India, the most significant difference is caused by the caste system. Within this system, the lower caste is considered genetically inferior, lazy, and never completing any hard work. It is perhaps a self-fulfilling prophecy as what is the point in working hard if the hard work will not be recognized. In China, people work extremely hard and are proud of it. This can be attributed to Confucianism and communism. There is a 996 culture in China. That is 9 am to 9 pm 6 days a week. Cultures are very different indeed.

Re: 'Too many employees, but few work': Pichai, Zuckerberg sound the alarm

#895

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Motivation is finite. By the time you get the through red tape to get approvals, permissions, and a million of other things, you have nothing left in the tank to code.

God. Every once in a while I think 'I should go back to a FAANG', and then comments like this remind me of how soul-sucking and toxic it is.

All enterprise is, fam. Everything slows down and bureaucracy and politics take over. Watched it happen in real time at the last acquisition and have decided to only focus on startups for the next decade. There's way more speed, passion, and fulfillment..

Re: 'Too many employees, but few work': Pichai, Zuckerberg sound the alarm

#896

I have been working for about 4.5 years now across 3 big tech companies (Google included). I would consider myself a hardworking and ambitious person who loves computer science. I graduated top of my class at a state school. I've gotten promoted, consistently "exceed expectations", lots of positive feedback, etc. But I have not actually accomplished a damn thing or written a single interesting or useful component in…

> I don't want to waste any more of my life on this merry go round.

And? Don't leave us hanging. Have you figured out a way to get out of this vicious cycle?

Re: 'Too many employees, but few work': Pichai, Zuckerberg sound the alarm

#897

It's frustrating that this thread seems to be focused so heavily on people sitting around resting and vesting. Having been inside Google (and multiple other FAANGs) this is generally untrue, and focusing on this element of the problem misses a much larger productivity problem: Most engineers at Google aren't "sitting around doing nothing", they are very busy shipping projects that do not matter. Their days are filled…

Seriously - the misallocation of resources in areas of Google is insane. And then there are niches of the Google Cloud product that are seemingly woefully understaffed, or just negligent in their maintenance.

I was a gcloud customer for years, happily using the App Engine Flexible for a PHP apo. It wasn't perfect, but it did it's job autoscaling and managing a decent sized consumer app. For years there wasn't much like it in PHP land where you could get away with doing very little sysadmin/cloud arch and get the features they offered.

But then support just _stopped_ around 2 years ago.

The official docker images are still stuck on PHP 7.3 and there has been no updates or support for nearly 18 months in upgrading to 7.4, 8.0 or 8.1.. [1]

AppEngine wasn't some vaporware at gcloud, it was one of the OG products, yet their perfectly fine letting it just rot and officially support a version of PHP that's a year outside of security patches.

I was spending nearly $80k/yr on that product + the rest of the cloud spend that comes from tying yourself to a cloud vendor. But this issue was so bad that I invested the time migrating off appengine and google cloud to another vendor.

There are people internally assigned to this, but either complacency or lazyness or poor focus the details cost them a customer.

1 - https://github.com/GoogleCloudPlatform/php-docker/issues/530

Re: 'Too many employees, but few work': Pichai, Zuckerberg sound the alarm

#898
post #894

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh yes, those lazy Indian and Chinese people, they never get anything done

In India, the most significant difference is caused by the caste system. Within this system, the lower caste is considered genetically inferior, lazy, and never completing any hard work. It is perhaps a self-fulfilling prophecy as what is the point in working hard if the hard work will not be recognized. In China, people work extremely hard and are proud of it. This can be attributed to Confucianism and communism. Th…

It was a joke, the Indian and Chinese engineers working at American tech companies are highly productive

Re: 'Too many employees, but few work': Pichai, Zuckerberg sound the alarm

#899
post #165

By the end of my employment at Google I was not working very hard. Probably a few hours a day, mostly doing whatever I felt like doing. My managers consistently gave me "meets expectations" regardless of how much I achieved or how hard I worked. However, any time there was an emergency related to my function, I had everything required to jump in, fix serious problems, and then get out of the way during the cleanup th…

I have never worked for Google and likely never will. Stories like these make me wonder why we put X-Googlers on such a high pedestal. I don't mean that personally in an offence to anyone. It's just a general observation.

The reputation of ex Googlers was established in the early days when they were tremendously productive, the bar was genuinely very high and turnover was tiny so there were very xooglers to begin with and they were mostly founding startups.

Over time Google grew an enormous amount. Productivity dropped through the floor due to endless headcount expansion, the bar did get lower and "I was at Google for two years" became a much more common thing to hear. But first impressions stick so Google still had done of that early day mystique.

Source: was at Google 8 years, early days, still have friends who work there. Saw the changes with my own eyes.

Re: 'Too many employees, but few work': Pichai, Zuckerberg sound the alarm

#900
post #268

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yea, as an engineer I would not be happy with my CEO swooping in to commit some code then bugger off.

The point isn't that they commit some useful code. It could be something as simple as just fixing a typo. But force them to go through the motions, so they can see the inefficiency in the processes.

Then they would become the inefficiency in the process
Post reply on HN