Live data from Hacker News

Study mode

openai.com

811–820 of 828 posts

Re: Study mode

#811
post #788

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It hasn't incorrectly answered this question in a very long time. Something tells me you're being dishonest to try to make a point.

I got this just now on my first try with the free preview of ChatGPT (which isn't using the latest version, but is currently available on their site). I was surprised, I expected to have to work harder for it to fail like that.

This triggered me to retest. Let me first apologize for calling you a liar. It's possible that you saw this.

I tried your formulation on the ChatGPT homepage in incognito mode (to rule out personalization for me). It said 2, so it's possible you saw that as well. I tried the same experiment again (new incognito mode, same phrasing) and it said 3.

That made me curious if phrasing made a difference and how often it would go wrong.

I tried 5 times with my own phrasing ("So, how many Rs in strawberry?") and got 5 times 3 as an answer.

I tried 5 times with your phrasing ("How many 'r's are in strawberry?") and also got 5 times 3 as an answer.

So 2 is an answer that can be given, but seems to be rare. At least in my tests.

Re: Study mode

#812

An underrated quality of LLMs as study partner is that you can ask "stupid" questions without fear of embarrassment. Adding in a mode that doesn't just dump an answer but works to take you through the material step-by-step is magical. A tireless, capable, well-versed assistant on call 24/7 is an autodidact's dream. I'm puzzled (but not surprised) by the standard HN resistance & skepticism. Learning something online 5…

> Learning something online 5 years ago often involved trawling incorrect, outdated or hostile content and attempting to piece together mental models without the chance to receive immediate feedback on intuition or ask follow up questions. This is leaps and bounds ahead of that experience. But now, you're wondering if the answer the AI gave you is correct or something it hallucinated. Every time I find myself putting…

The joke is on you, I was raised in Eastern Europe, where most of what history teachers told us was wrong

That being said. as someone who worked in a library and bookstore 90% of workbooks and technical books are identical. NotebookLM's mindmap feature is such a time saver

Re: Study mode

#813
post #782

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What you’re saying is not at all what I understand to be the history of crusading. Its background is in the Islamic Christian conflicts of Spain. Crusading was adopted from the Muslim idea of Jihad, as we things like naming customs (Spanish are the only Christians who name their children “Jesus”, after the Muslim “Muhammad”). The political tensions that lead to the first crusade were between Arab Muslims and Byzantin…

While what you are saying makes a lot of sense, but it seemingly ignores the concerns of a people who, not too long before, had been made aware of the dangerous notion of Muslims having dominion over even an adjacent region to their own. I do know that the Papacy was gaining in power and popularity leading up to the Crusades. As such, and I believe what you say about getting rid of the king to be absolutely true, thi…

I'm familiar with Madden's more political stuff. I also read his book on the Fourth Crusade.

One thing mentions a lot is that our understanding of Crusades is heavily influenced by 19th century colonialism. "Our understanding" being both the modern West and modern Islamic understanding.

It's also completely and totally wrong.

Just because a bunch of Christians and bunch of Muslims fought, does not mean it's a crusade. And just as there were no Crusades in the 19th century (with one teeny-tiny exception) there were no Crusades in the 9th century.

What's most relevant this conversation is that ChatGPT would be opening itself to lots of criticism if it started talking about 9th Century Crusades.

There are simply too many reputable documents saying "the first crusade began in ..." or "the concept of crusading evolved in Spain ..."

I'm reaching into my memory from college, but I recall crusading was mostly a Norman-Franco led thing (plenty of exceptions, of course).

Papal foreign policy was based around one very simple principal: avoid all concentrations of power.

Crusading was useful when it supported that principal, and harmful when it degraded it.

So the ideal papal crusade was one that was poorly managed, unlikely to succeed, but messed up the established political order just enough that all the kingdoms were weakened.

Which is exactly what the crusades looked like.

Re: Study mode

#814

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a floor raiser, not a ceiling raiser. It helps you get up to speed on general conventions and consensus on a topic, less so on going deep on controversial or highly specialized topics

That's the best and succinct description of using ChatGPT for this kind of things: it's a floor raiser, not a ceiling raiser.

If it's of interest, I expanded on this in a blog post: https://elroy.bot/blog/2025/07/29/ai-is-a-floor-raiser-not-a...

Re: Study mode

#815

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're just deferring to another vague term "pattern matching". If I think back to something I was taught in primary school and conclude that 1+1=2 is that pattern matching? Therefore I don't really "know" or "think"? People pretend like LLMs are like some 80s markov chain model or nearest neighbor search, which is just uninformed.

Do you want to shift the discussion to the definition of a "pattern" or are we going to continue to move the goalpost? I'm trying to respond to your inquiry and instead we're just stuck in minutia. Yes, to make an apple pie from scratch, we need to first invent the universe. Is that productive conversation to fall into or can we just admit that your dismissing any opinion that goes against your purview? >If I think b…

So because I'm pattern matching that means I'm not thinking right? That's the same argument you have for LLMs.

Re: Study mode

#816

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just added a proper playback control component on desktop, allows changing rate, rewinding & persists across pages :)!

Awesome! Will try it soon. What's your GTM plan? You built an amazing app—I hope you are focusing as much on marketing as adding features! I think a lot of people will like this if you get it in front of them.

I have no idea how to market this honestly. Most of my users came from a single discord server, but the feedback is overall pretty positive.

If you have any tips I'd be super grateful (gave you a follow on X).

Re: Study mode

#817

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Awesome! Will try it soon. What's your GTM plan? You built an amazing app—I hope you are focusing as much on marketing as adding features! I think a lot of people will like this if you get it in front of them.

I have no idea how to market this honestly. Most of my users came from a single discord server, but the feedback is overall pretty positive. If you have any tips I'd be super grateful (gave you a follow on X).

Here are some ideas, in no particular order:

- Find relevant subreddits on Reddit and post about the tool in an authentic way (not promotional, but a "here's what I built" style).

- Do a Show HN. Look at other people's successful ones to get an idea of the tone/style that works.

- ProductHunt (read this for suggestions on how to do it well: https://www.lennysnewsletter.com/p/how-to-successfully-launc...)

- Content marketing: do SEO keyword research and create pages/posts that target promising keywords. This product in particular probably has a lot of potential with this strategy, since you can use the tool itself to create interesting content which also shows off the features.

- YouTube: similar to above, but find relevant videos from other creators that are doing well and try to create your own videos in a similar style, looping in the product where it makes sense. Like with reddit and HN, better to be authentic and not promotional.

- Media: reach out to popular blogs and publications that cover learning tools.

If you have any cash available to invest (even a small amount), you can also try:

- Reach out to influencers on YouTube, X, TikTok, etc. either directly or via promotion marketplaces. You'll likely have to pay, but it can be high ROI since you already have a paid plan.

- Similarly, you can try ads on reddit, adwords, facebook, X, etc. and see if any of them offer immediate positive ROI.

Depending on your goals, you could also consider applying to YC. It will give you a significant marketing boost if you get in, but requires thinking in terms of how to build a big business, which isn't for everyone. The product might be good enough to give you a shot, if you're interested in that route, but it would also probably help your chances to try some organic marketing strategies first to prove that you can do it. Also helps if you have a cofounder.

--

On a different note, the new audio playback controls are great! Would be nice to also have them on mobile :) My preferred way to consume these courses would be on mobile, like an audio book or podcast.

Re: Study mode

#818
the product itself seems really useful but I doubt the average student that knows they can either walk through with study mode or just get the answer with normal prompting would choose the one that takes longer, especially with deadlines. As a student I would be 50/50, but its a good feature for sure

Re: Study mode

#819

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have no idea how to market this honestly. Most of my users came from a single discord server, but the feedback is overall pretty positive. If you have any tips I'd be super grateful (gave you a follow on X).

Here are some ideas, in no particular order: - Find relevant subreddits on Reddit and post about the tool in an authentic way (not promotional, but a "here's what I built" style). - Do a Show HN. Look at other people's successful ones to get an idea of the tone/style that works. - ProductHunt (read this for suggestions on how to do it well: https://www.lennysnewsletter.com/p/how-to-successfully-launc... ) - Content m…

Thanks a lot! I did do some of these things (namely Reddit) and that worked well, just the number of places that allow posting is limited and I don't want to get too spammy. Will continue there.

Main conceptual issue I've been having with other marketing (e.g. influencer) is that there isn't a well-defined audience to market this to. Usually edtech targets students/schools and Periplus doesn't fit there too well. Need to find what works I guess.

I'll spend more time on it from now on :). Thanks again.

re: mobile playback controls -> on it

Re: Study mode

#820

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Learning something online 5 years ago often involved trawling incorrect, outdated or hostile content and attempting to piece together mental models without the chance to receive immediate feedback on intuition or ask follow up questions. That trained and sharpened invaluable skills involving critical thinking and grit.

It didn’t. Only frustrated and slowed down students.

Sounds like somebody who disliked implementing QuickSort as a student because what's the point, there is a library for it, you'll never need to do that kind of thing "in the real world".

Maybe someday an LLM will be able to explain to you the pedagogical value of an exercise.

Post reply on HN