Live data from Hacker News

Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

neowin.net

81–90 of 480 posts

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Firefox haven't caved in so far. Why do u think it might in future?

> Firefox haven't caved in so far. Why do u think it might in future? Because pretty much all their revenue comes from Google.

I think Google will try to annoy Firefox users into using Chrome instead via things like needless captchas.

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#83
Being the maintainer of such a big open-source application as Chrome used to grant dictatorial power: maintaining a fork represented too much work. It only happened in the most awful situations, such as Oracle acquiring OpenOffice.

But that was before LLM-driven development, I think that now the game has changed, and maybe Google hasn't got the leverage it thinks it has.

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#86
post #10

I wonder what will Vivaldi do. They say that their built-in content blocker is "good enough" that you supposedly don't need uBO (I very much disagree) but they also keep MV2 extensions working to this day.

Vivaldi said We will keep Manifest v2 for as long as it’s still available in Chromium.[1] They kept it before now because it was little effort.

[1] https://vivaldi.com/blog/manifest-v3-update-vivaldi-is-futur...

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#87
post #4

Why are people on HN still using Chrome? (or Edge, or Opera…)

I'm a Firefox user for about 20yrs (since Firefox 3); but too often I have to use Chrome, as so many sites only work properly on it; Firefox is really buggy or laggy on those websites; For a time, all those AI chat web pages were just very slow on Firefox even with very little context, whereas Chrome only gets laggy when there is a lot of context.

Are you really sure it’s not because of an add-on? If I remember correctly, Mozilla has said that about 95% of all pages that don’t work aren’t due to Firefox, but to an add-on. I use Firefox exclusively and don’t usually notice that pages don’t work. When that happens, as I said, it’s almost always an add-on that’s to blame. And I dont notice its buggy or laggy. So could be good check your addons next time.

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Was that the year they fired the Rust team to focus on paying their executives?

Let's not exchange crap behaviour. I think google would win hands down. Firefox at least has adblocking.

No it doesn't. Unlike Brave, Firefox needs an extension to block ads just like Chrome.

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#89
post #38

uBo is the only reason I find browsing the web at all tolerable anymore. As a test I turned it off to view this article and almost crashed my browser with a dozen auto play video ads This would mean I would find the energy to get over anything that is holding me on chrome, like saved passwords etc.

Agree. The web is literally unusable without uBlock Origin. It should be a standard browser feature at this point, like popup blockers.

it _is_ a browser feature for e.g. brave, vivaldi and (experimental, afair) firefox.

Popup blockers were also a differentiator, once.

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#90
post #4

Why are people on HN still using Chrome? (or Edge, or Opera…)

I don't, 99.9% of the time.

But when your browser has a 2% market share worldwide, some developers won't bother to test on it. And if your setup is even more obscure (I use Firefox on Linux with an adblocker and third-party cookies blocked and DRM disabled and autoplaying video disabled and so on) making you rare even among that 2%, sometimes sites won't have tested with your specific configuration.

It's useful to have a second browser around, as a fallback when a site is broken. Uploading images when creating a listing on ebay is broken, but I don't have to figure out which element of my setup is breaking it, I can just switch to the other browser.

Post reply on HN