Live data from Hacker News

Tesla owner won $10k in court for Tesla's FSD lies. Tesla is still fighting him

electrek.co

81–90 of 152 posts

Re: Tesla owner won $10k in court for Tesla's FSD lies. Tesla is still fighting him

#81

Why just the $10k? Could you get a full refund? If I order a $12 burrito and you give me a $10 sandwich, I would feel owed my $12 back, not the $2 difference in price.

You should have the option of getting the $12 back provided you also return the sandwich. You don't get a free sandwich out of the deal unless the seller cares about good will.

Re: Tesla owner won $10k in court for Tesla's FSD lies. Tesla is still fighting him

#82
post #33
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not sure I agree with your second sentence, at least in the US. I may see "cheese product" or "dairy product" or "cheese flavor" but if it says real cheese, it's real cheese. My favorite example was seeing "onion (then in tiny text 'flavored') rings"

They even banned the term "soy milk" It's now called "non dairy soy beverage" on every carton.

My understanding was that the end result there was entirely the opposite of that: https://arstechnica.com/science/2023/02/almond-milk-can-keep...

Re: Tesla owner won $10k in court for Tesla's FSD lies. Tesla is still fighting him

#83
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tesla FSD is vulnerable to RoadRunner and Wile E. Coyote style tricks.

it's not. that vid was using autopilot, not fsd, and subsequent videos using actual new FSD were fine

> it's not.

"Tesla FSD is invulnerable to tricks" is a pretty strong claim.

Re: Tesla owner won $10k in court for Tesla's FSD lies. Tesla is still fighting him

#84
post #72

The real problem, which I think the article does a poor job of making clear: Tesla sold millions of cars before the current generation Hardware 4 vehicles with $10,000 full self driving packages which never really materialized convincingly ‘full’ self-driving capability. There’s fair arguments for the HW4 vehicles not having FSD either, maybe because it needs to be supervised or isn’t perfect or whatever. But the HW4…

On the recent earnings call they did finally acknowledge they will have to upgrade the hardware in HW3 cars so they can fully self drive.

The flayed the solution of “popup factories” in cities across the US to carry out the upgrade.

Re: Tesla owner won $10k in court for Tesla's FSD lies. Tesla is still fighting him

#85
post #24

The "Full" in "Full Self Driving" was one of the giveaways. It's like packaged food labeled with "Real" ("Real cheese" etc)

Not sure I agree with your second sentence, at least in the US. I may see "cheese product" or "dairy product" or "cheese flavor" but if it says real cheese, it's real cheese. My favorite example was seeing "onion (then in tiny text 'flavored') rings"

It may be real cheese, but the cheese may not be where you expected it to be. A friend of mine was served a snack pack on a flight that had some breadsticks and a cheese dip, and the box said it was made with real cheese.

She read the ingredients list and found that the real cheese was part of the breadsticks. The cheese dip had no cheese.

Re: Tesla owner won $10k in court for Tesla's FSD lies. Tesla is still fighting him

#86
post #31

"court made a judgment in his favor in the amount of $10,672.88, the amount Gawiser paid for FSD, including taxes and court fees." should include interest as well

To be truly fair should also adjust for inflation of US dollar of $10672 at the time he purchased it vs. April 2026. For instance CPI inflation calculator says 10672 in Jan. 2022 is $12,534.44 today.

I'm of the opinion that it'd be fair to treat that money as an investment in Tesla at that time. In my case, the $8K in Dec 2016 would translate to them being on the hook for ~$260K today.

Which is why I think Tesla shouldn't be slow-rolling their doing whatever is necessary to get those of us who pre-bought FSD up to the HW4 level. HW4 won't physically fit in a 2016 Model S? Give us a 2026 Model X (they dropped Model S), and you're still $160K ahead.

I've been surprised that there hasn't been a major class action about the FSD. I've been very happy with the car, but the FSD was outright fraud.

Re: Tesla owner won $10k in court for Tesla's FSD lies. Tesla is still fighting him

#87

I recovered ~$250,000 under beverly song act (California lemon law). (My principal and interest back for multiple vehicles) I repeatedly complained it was activating “emergency lane departure” while driving manually, even after disabling the setting. This had the effect of the vehicles swerving towards cross walks or walls. Clearly a software issue but they played dumb and forced me to book service visits and refused…

I’ve had this type of issue on multiple European car brands. Software issues with driver assistance features, which they keep ignoring. Things like sudden unexplained braking, not showing down due to cars stopped ahead, swerving randomly... I accepted it because getting them to cover anything, even physical things, even under warranty. They just come up with self serving guidelines and excuses. Glad you had success.…

One reason I love my mid-00s Lexus SUV. All the luxury features you want, but clean instrument cluster with no driving assistance tech to break or get in the way. Great visual clarity on the road, 300K miles on original drivetrain without issues, and a beast in the snow/inclement weather. Only downside is mileage, but I legit wouldn't trade it for a new car.

Re: Tesla owner won $10k in court for Tesla's FSD lies. Tesla is still fighting him

#88

From what I've seen on YouTube the cars do drive themselves. This seems more like the type of thing with AI where people change the goal posts of what AI means. Just because a car did not slow down in a school zone, that doesn't mean that the car wasn't driving itself.

>the cars do drive themselves

Those are cars with the "HW4" FSD hardware, which was released in Mar 2023.

There were a lot of cars sold with "HW2" (nVidia-based) and HW3 (Tesla silicon). Those cars, apparently cannot be upgraded to HW4 because of physical size differences between the units. HW2 was able to be upgraded to HW3.

Those videos you are talking about seeing do not represent the FSD experience for all, or possibly even most, Tesla FSD vehicles in the wild.

Re: Tesla owner won $10k in court for Tesla's FSD lies. Tesla is still fighting him

#89
post #45

So I skimmed several articles and the reasons why the Theranos CEO was sentenced to 11 years are 1. The scale of the fraud was too big 2. From emails it seemed she intentionally tricked investors 3. The product, medical equipment, endangered patients. I think this can be applied to Tesla too (though I'm not sure there is enough evidence of 2). Shouldn't someone in charge be sentenced to at least a few years?

I'd say repeatedly forecasting "full self driving next year" every year for a decade qualifies Tesla for #2.

Re: Tesla owner won $10k in court for Tesla's FSD lies. Tesla is still fighting him

#90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At this point I want basically no driver assistance features except maybe an automatic cruise control speed adjustment to vehicle directly in the lane ahead based on forward facing radar data. Many of them seem to be much more troublesome or buggy than they're worth.

I don't have a "modern" vehicle but automated following distance is the only thing I feel like I'm missing out on. Everything else feels like I'm dodging bullets. Unfortunately not upgrading means missing out on improvements to physical safety in the event of a crash.

Auto headlights switching is nice as well. We have it on the Lexus.
Post reply on HN