Live data from Hacker News

Open Design: Use Your Coding Agent as a Design Engine

github.com

81–90 of 104 posts

Re: Open Design: Use Your Coding Agent as a Design Engine

#81

The README is unnerving. Do people really see the Claude-salesman style of writing as something normal? On the other hand, I should be thanking Anthropic for making it so easy to spot, they might have done this intentionally.

> That's not "AI tries to design something". That's an AI that has been trained, by the prompt stack, to behave like a senior designer with a working filesystem, a deterministic palette library, and a checklist culture What, you don't want your senior designer to have a working filesystem and checklist culture? No deterministic palettes?

I hate when my palette library is probabilistic.

Re: Open Design: Use Your Coding Agent as a Design Engine

#83
post #26

The inevitable outcome here is that designed materials become so generic and infinitely produceable that they become worthless background noise. We are well on the way to that path. For almost all materials the only value of getting a seriously produced work of design (i.e., the "make me a magazine-style pitch deck for our seed round" this design engine mentions) is a signaling function that some combination of effor…

https://medium.com/luminasticity/art-as-a-tool-for-storing-m...

>The modern world is design rich and art poor. That is to say that with the introduction of mass production it became possible to distribute everywhere items that in previous eras would have been seen as full of Mana, but now, not unique — they have none.

That was in reference to mass produced design, but it seems to apply 10X to AI produced Art.

Re: Open Design: Use Your Coding Agent as a Design Engine

#84

The README is unnerving. Do people really see the Claude-salesman style of writing as something normal? On the other hand, I should be thanking Anthropic for making it so easy to spot, they might have done this intentionally.

No thing-you-don't-want. No second-thing-you-don't want. Just thing-you-want, the-way-you-want-it.

Re: Open Design: Use Your Coding Agent as a Design Engine

#86
post #26

The inevitable outcome here is that designed materials become so generic and infinitely produceable that they become worthless background noise. We are well on the way to that path. For almost all materials the only value of getting a seriously produced work of design (i.e., the "make me a magazine-style pitch deck for our seed round" this design engine mentions) is a signaling function that some combination of effor…

True. But this makes it easier to stand out in a sea of monotony.

Re: Open Design: Use Your Coding Agent as a Design Engine

#87
post #57
post #26

The inevitable outcome here is that designed materials become so generic and infinitely produceable that they become worthless background noise. We are well on the way to that path. For almost all materials the only value of getting a seriously produced work of design (i.e., the "make me a magazine-style pitch deck for our seed round" this design engine mentions) is a signaling function that some combination of effor…

> The inevitable outcome here is that designed materials become so generic and infinitely produceable that they become worthless background noise. Hopefully. The process has taken way too long. Compare to something similar like PowerPoint animations. Fun the first time you see them, and then annoying after that. The best possible side effect of the cost of producing content dropping to zero would be more effort spent…

The medium becomes the message

Re: Open Design: Use Your Coding Agent as a Design Engine

#88
post #48
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How do human artists compete with AI-gen images?

Yes, we're building a dystopia where AIs do the work humans enjoy, and humans get to hold on to drudgery. What's not to like?

Nothing stops humans from doing what they enjoy

Re: Open Design: Use Your Coding Agent as a Design Engine

#89
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, we're building a dystopia where AIs do the work humans enjoy, and humans get to hold on to drudgery. What's not to like?

Nothing stops humans from doing what they enjoy

The amount of shit that I need to deal with so that I can pay the bills has gone up markedly, and promises to continue going up. The things the tech industry are building are making things worse for me. Please stop making my life worse.

Re: Open Design: Use Your Coding Agent as a Design Engine

#90
post #50
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apparently so. Posted 12 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47831621

Makes me wonder if there is a secret HN upvote economy too. Edit: yep, quick search turned up a site to buy upvotes. All these vibe coded slop projects getting to the front page make sense now

When there is a buyer, sellers will show up.

This only exposes human nature.

Post reply on HN