Live data from Hacker News

Trump fires NSF's oversight board

science.org

81–90 of 383 posts

Re: Trump fires NSF's oversight board

#82
post #34
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Those protestors are out there because they love America. They love it enough to try to make it better.

Serious question: What exactly do they love America for? I just don’t get it. Seems like in every way that matters to the common people, the US is at best mediocre.

Could it be that they secretly subscribe to a different version of the same mythical exceptionalism as the president they despise?

Re: Trump fires NSF's oversight board

#83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You will not live forever. Would applying the same logic again suit you? Timing matters. Where current resources go matters. Having a plan matters. The current system is not perfect but it’s far better than no system at all.

> The current system is not perfect but it’s far better than no system at all. you should question this assertion. your assertion is dependent on the assumption that science is a strictly positive sum game (with respect to funding). i am saying it is not, and i have provided the mechanistic explanation of why it's not. all i ask people to think about is: bad science is worth negative.

imagine trying to insinuate with a straight face that firing everyone on a funding oversight body because they queried the executive branch bypassing the oversight is somehow going to reduce fraudulent research and grift in state sponsored science...

Re: Trump fires NSF's oversight board

#87
There’s a lot of political commentary in these threads about how dumb the admin is this and that, sarcasm, etc. but is anyone able to share why this is such a truly beneficial org to our country? I’m just out of the loop on this and I’m genuinely asking, I have never really heard of them. But by the reactions in the comments they’re like the most blessed org of our country and accelerate innovation and advancement of the USA. It’s just a foundation? Please just let me know, I’m not trying to be weird and I’d appreciate being civil about it.

Re: Trump fires NSF's oversight board

#88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've entirely lost track what people are complaining about wrt DEI; why not just say what you mean?

[flagged]

Do you think a commitment to inclusion is some kind of activism?

Re: Trump fires NSF's oversight board

#89

So is this a 2400% reduction in the number of NSF board members?

This is a reference to RJK Jr's pronouncement that Trump has a "different way of calculating percentages". Seems apt to me in this context.

Very much another "Emperor's New Clothes" situation.

If the pathology was entirely within his own privately-owned company that'd be one thing, but Americans are going to continue to get hurt because of it.

Re: Trump fires NSF's oversight board

#90

What are the equivalent institutions in China? Do they do open houses?

Why do you ask? Do you assume those fired NSF workers want to go work in China now? Or that China manages its domestic variant of the NSF better and accepts people critical of the CCP ideology?

Our entire economy is built on scientific advancement and advantage. The dismantling of everything to maximize executive power in order to maximize grift and corruption will have effects for decades.

This is the American version of the cultural revolution. We’re pushing people to be plumbers instead of scientists.

Post reply on HN