Live data from Hacker News

Ada, its design, and the language that built the languages

iqiipi.com

81–90 of 242 posts

Re: Ada, its design, and the language that built the languages

#81
post #36

I really don't want this to be AI writing because I enjoyed it, but as other commenters have pointed out, the rate of publishing (according to the linked Twitter account) is very rapid. I'm worried that I can't tell.

does it really matter? If AI can produce an essay of such quality - take my respect and steal my time please

Re: Ada, its design, and the language that built the languages

#82
post #36

I really don't want this to be AI writing because I enjoyed it, but as other commenters have pointed out, the rate of publishing (according to the linked Twitter account) is very rapid. I'm worried that I can't tell.

I try to reserve judgement, but 110 em dashes is... excessive.

I really enjoyed the essay, only checked afterwards when I started reading comments.

I hate that I'm starting to develop a media literacy immune system for blog posts of all things.

Re: Ada, its design, and the language that built the languages

#83

Ada is a language that had a lot of useful features much earlier than any of the languages that are popular today, and some of those features are still missing from the languages easily available today. In the beginning Ada has been criticized mainly for 2 reasons, it was claimed that it is too complex and it was criticized for being too verbose. Today, the criticism about complexity seems naive, because many later l…

> Today, the criticism about complexity seems naive, because many later languages have become much more complex than Ada I don’t think you really understand what you’re saying here. I have worked on an ada compiler for the best part of a decade. It’s one of the most complex languages there is, up there with C++ and C#, and probably rust

what do you mean under Ada's complexity? E.g. C++ is really complex because of a lot of features which badly interoperate between themselves. Is this true for the Ada lang/compiler? Or do you mean the whole complexity of ideas included in Ada - like proof of Poincaré conjecture complex for unprepared person.

Re: Ada, its design, and the language that built the languages

#84
post #15

The Twitter account is from April 2026: https://xcancel.com/Iqiipi_Essays There is no named public author. A truly amazing productivity for such a short time period and generously the author does not take any credit.

No author because its a bot.

There's a lot of autodidact researchers out there that existed before AI, and AI-assisted, their research and output has sped up significantly. To call them a bot is to mildly put, miss the forest for the trees.

Re: Ada, its design, and the language that built the languages

#85

Ada was also ignored because the typical compiler cost tens of thousands of dollars. No open source or free compiler existed during the decades where popular languages could be had for free. I think that is the biggest factor of all.

GNAT has existed since at least the mid-90s, and in that time period plenty of companies used non-OSS compilers.

In that era, the largest blocker for Ada was it ws viewed as having a lot of overhead for things that weren't generally seen as useful (safety guarantees). The reputation was it only mattered if you were working on military stuff, etc.

Re: Ada, its design, and the language that built the languages

#87
post #78

Every time Ada is mentioned here, I start a quest - how to try it for free on Windows. And every time I fail.

In the past you could easily use Ada or anything else from Linux under Cygwin.

Nowadays, you should be able to use anything from Linux under WSL.

In the past using Ada was more painful, because you had to use some old version of gcc, which could clash with the modern gcc used for C/C++/Fortran etc.

However, during the last few years these problems have disappeared. If you build any current gcc version, you must just choose the option of having ada among the available languages and all will work smoothly.

Re: Ada, its design, and the language that built the languages

#90
post #36

I really don't want this to be AI writing because I enjoyed it, but as other commenters have pointed out, the rate of publishing (according to the linked Twitter account) is very rapid. I'm worried that I can't tell.

does it really matter? If AI can produce an essay of such quality - take my respect and steal my time please

I think so. Who writes something and why are important context for what we do with the information. It's an issue with the lack of disclosure, not AI in general.

Most longform readers will assume an author has deep expertise and spent a lot of time organizing their thoughts, which lends their ideas some legitimacy and trust. For a small blog, an 8,000 word essay is a passion project.

But if AI is detected in the phrasing and not disclosed, it begs a lot of questions. Did AI write the whole thing, or just light edits? Are the facts AI generated, too, and not from personal experience? What motivated someone to produce this content if they were going to automate parts of its creation; why would they value the output more than the process?

Post reply on HN