Live data from Hacker News

The Fight

dcurt.is

81–90 of 140 posts

Re: The Fight

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, he clearly lives near me because I saw him the other day. Looked a bit frail.

Actually it wasn't clear at all that you saw him near your house.

I don't believe that wasn't a shot at dmix so much as a "Well, I didn't know this previously, but evidently he lives near me because I saw him the other day".

Re: The Fight

#82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a field where a surprising amount of progress is being made. People still tend to assume that CPR is mostly a token effort so bystanders feel like they're doing something. In reality, high quality CPR + rapid access to an AED can give just about any heart a fighting chance at beating again (assuming the underlying problem is transient or easily treatable... if your LAD cardiac artery is 100% occluded and half…

Does editing time out after a while? I'd never noticed that before.. Anyway... s/cardiac artery/coronary artery/

Yes, you have two hours and then you can't edit anymore. Also you can't downvote comments that are older than one day.

Re: The Fight

#84
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unfortunately, it may cost you quite a bit of time and money to convince said court that what you did was not grossly negligent should someone press the issue.

No one in their right mind would press the issue, lest it causes a chilling effect on bystanders attempting to help someone in need.

Lawsuits and "right mind" seldom are within shouting distance of one another.

http://suite101.com/article/good-samaritan-risks-lawsuit---s...

And just for a twist:

http://abovethelaw.com/2011/08/lawsuit-of-the-day-good-samar...

Re: The Fight

#85
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So do you practice what you preach and carry one of these with you where ever you go, or in your vehicle? If not then why do you feel the government should impose that on a business? Why not make a law that says every business has to have a trained EMT on site during business hours. I'm sure that would save even more lives...

We have that. In germany the Berufsgenossenschaft mandates that every company with more than 2 and up to 20 employees has at least 1 person trained in first aid on site. Companies larger than that need 5% - 10% of the personal trained, depending on what work is done. http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unfallverh%C3%BCtungsvorschrift...

What is the consequence if 3 co-founders start a company, and only find out about this requirement a year later?

See item 7 of http://www.paulgraham.com/america.html to know why I asked it.

Re: The Fight

#86
My grandfather is 96, he's been on dialysis for nearly 2 years now. He has zero kidney function and a tumor that has literally taken the place of one of the kidneys. His mind is sharp and he's totally lucid.

He won't let us sell his cars. He believes that he's going to get better. He talks about it all the time. "As soon as I get better, we'll..."

It doesn't matter if one lives 20 years or until the heat death of the universe, everyone has the same experience. Death is unexpected and unwelcome. And completely inevitable.

Re: The Fight

#87

My grandfather is 96, he's been on dialysis for nearly 2 years now. He has zero kidney function and a tumor that has literally taken the place of one of the kidneys. His mind is sharp and he's totally lucid. He won't let us sell his cars. He believes that he's going to get better. He talks about it all the time. "As soon as I get better, we'll..." It doesn't matter if one lives 20 years or until the heat death of the…

> Death is unexpected and unwelcome. And completely inevitable.

DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT.

Re: The Fight

#88

Some time ago I came across an elderly man in some difficulty lying in the street in London. While waiting for an ambulance he 'died' (no heart beat, no respiration, no signs of life at all, blue lips and gums) and I immediately did CPR on him until the ambulance arrived. Months later I learnt that he survived. Any brush with death makes you seriously think about your own mortality. I know that watching this stranger…

How was it life-changing?

Re: The Fight

#89
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We have that. In germany the Berufsgenossenschaft mandates that every company with more than 2 and up to 20 employees has at least 1 person trained in first aid on site. Companies larger than that need 5% - 10% of the personal trained, depending on what work is done. http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unfallverh%C3%BCtungsvorschrift...

Right, and that is probably a negligible cost as you can get first aid training for free in a lot of places. The point is the op is advocating that businesses be required to buy expensive equipment that they themselves probably wouldn't be willing to spend the money on.

In a normal office you wouldn't need more than one AED per 50+ employees. That's an insignificant cost.

Re: The Fight

#90
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What are the legalities involved here? If you attempt to help are you opening yourself up to potential blame and legal action? What about DNR wishes the person may or may not have, or religious beliefs?

Nobody wants to live in a world where people find a dying person laying on the floor and let him die because they're afraid of legal issues. The law protects you from such nonsense. Even if it didn't, in my opinion, no person worth a damn would allow that consideration to color their response.

I heard from a guy (not Chinese national but married to one) who lives in China saying that in China, don't help anyone having accident on the street. He said there are many cases where when you help, you end up paying the bills because the person (or his/her family) would tell hospital that you cause the accident. Simply because they don't have money.

EDIT: He added that if you do want to help, make sure you have witnesses that you're trying to help.

Post reply on HN