Live data from Hacker News

People keep flocking to Linux, not just to escape Windows

zdnet.com

81–90 of 214 posts

Re: People keep flocking to Linux, not just to escape Windows

#81
I still want to switch, have been trying for like 8 years. Not yet unfortunately.

Video editing is still pretty sub-par on Linux compared to Windows.

DaVinci Resolve technically works on Linux and it's an amazing piece of software that I'd love to use but on Linux there's no h264 support unless you pay $300. Ok no problem, I'd do that except the studio version doesn't support AAC for audio on Linux.

If you want to record from OBS, you have to re-encode the video for Resolve and then after rendering your video with Resolve you have to re-encode it again with another tool for h264 / AAC. That means you have to record + render + edit + render + render instead of just record + edit + render. A huge time sink and waste of drive space.

Kdenlive is there but its text editing capabilities are really lack luster. If you want to do things like create a text call out with a rectangle behind it and have your text styled up where different words are colored up differently or you want to underline a word or 2 you have to spend 10 minutes fighting its text UI, duplicating layers, fiddling with z-indexes and if you decide to change your text later, you have to re-do everything. That or you have to use an external tool like GIMP but that breaks you out of the flow and takes a lot more time.

On Windows, there's Camtasia. It "just works" and you can make text call outs described above in seconds.

Until I can easily create text call outs in videos on Linux (something I do a few times a week) I will use Windows 10 + WSL 2.

Re: People keep flocking to Linux, not just to escape Windows

#82
post #7

The year of Linux on the desktop, at last. What may make this happen is political risk. The rest of the world outside the US doesn't like the excessive dependency of Microsoft systems on servers in the US, especially when that may mean snooping or disconnection. This used to be just a theoretical objection, but under the Trump administration it's a practical one.

We don't like it here in the US either!

Re: People keep flocking to Linux, not just to escape Windows

#83
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My parents run a Windows PC as, from what I can tell, a home for stray botnets. The main uses are checking email and working on Word documents. (They have a laptop and iPad, respectively, which does most of their work, so it's an infrequently consulted machine.) What Linux build would you recommend that I can fire and forget, that would be compatible with the Windows 10 machine they have running and will likely never…

Kubuntu. KDE is generally considered close to a Windows experience, although, I'm afraid the "start" menu is still affixed to the left hand side and not in the middle of the taskbar (which is weird). It also doesn't bother with too much telemetry and all that stuff. Kubuntu is Ubuntu but with the KDE front end, instead of the Gnome one or whatever it is. Being Ubuntu it supports Secure Boot which ticks a box. It is j…

... I also need to point out that the other suggestions here eg Fedora and Zorin co are also valid choices in my opinion.

You should revel in the fact that you now have choice and not a single option. That does mean you will have to pick one.

All of the options you have been presented with will work fine - there is literally no wrong answer here!

All of them are very well documented and you will not get a "SFC /SCANNOW" type answer if you have a problem.

Re: People keep flocking to Linux, not just to escape Windows

#84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Epic ragebait. > Win11 file picker is years ahead of some random file picker option available on linux First it would be nice to know why you would think this and maybe provide an example, second there are other file pickers. It should also be noted that you don't need one at all, but if you want one, there are so many options, try nemo > HiDPI Wayland > Multi monitor scaling polish What did he mean by that? Wayland…

not an author, but in same league (have to keep dual boot because of photo editing) neither nautilus nor nemo provides you convenient way to navigate, to check free disks space, to check photos in an album view, to see all the file properties and customize table views. if you don't have this usage scenarios, it doesn't mean its a ragebait. and btw, your attitude is one of the reasons people don't want to move to linu…

>to navigate

cd where/you/want/to/navigate

ranger (if you want interactive)

>check free disk space

df -h

> check photos in an album view

nsxiv -t *.{jpeg|png}

> see all the file properties

ls -l

But I guess you are right. If one wants to use a computer like you use it on windows, then linux is a bad choice. The best choice in that case is windows.

Your file manager is not your operating system, use something else to view images.

I have all those "usage scenarios", which are in fact absolute basics and thus it's worth remembering 3 commands. The problem arises when one uses a Desktop environment with a dock and all other bloated nonsense. Maybe computing is solved once people reverse the brain damage inflicted by Windows and MacOS.

I'm not sorry for my attitude, because OP is the reason computing sucks and becomes more bloated and telemetry ridden every year. It's pure laziness to learn something new. Linux should be there for everyone, but shouldn't be called "immature" just because someone needs a perfect clone of the windows file picker, or wants his proprietary windows programs to run. Thats all good and fair, but not linux' problem.

Re: People keep flocking to Linux, not just to escape Windows

#85
I don't know who said it, but it fits the current Windows vs Linux moment perfectly. "Most people don’t want control. They want optionally having control."

Windows gives you the worst of both worlds. It restricts the control over the things that matter, and dumps unnecessary knobs on everything else.

Linux flipped that. It stays out of your way, lets you change what you actually care about, and never fights you for ownership of your own computer.

Linux won/is winning because it quietly became the place where your computer feels like yours again.

Re: People keep flocking to Linux, not just to escape Windows

#86

What I want is some hardware that, if Linux stops working on it, it's someone's job to fix that. Which is why I'm strongly considering a Steam Cube.

Even if you run fully Valve hardware you are still going to be subject to the usual finicky-ness when connecting external devices (e.g. if you use multiple monitors, issues with the open source AMD GPU drivers; etc.).

Re: People keep flocking to Linux, not just to escape Windows

#87
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Epic ragebait. > Win11 file picker is years ahead of some random file picker option available on linux First it would be nice to know why you would think this and maybe provide an example, second there are other file pickers. It should also be noted that you don't need one at all, but if you want one, there are so many options, try nemo > HiDPI Wayland > Multi monitor scaling polish What did he mean by that? Wayland…

> Hahahahaha Speaking as a Linux desktop dev, that one's right. We have a lot of homework left to do, and accessibility is an area both Windows and MacOS are more fully-featured and mature in. Part of treating users really well is also being honest about our shortcomings (and fixing them).

I don't think there is anything more accessible than lines of text in a grid. Maybe you don't need to make every button of every GUI program ever accessible.

Re: People keep flocking to Linux, not just to escape Windows

#88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The great thing about open source is that there’s always at least one person who can take on the job of fixing your obscure hardware problem…you. The terrible thing is that you are probably unqualified to do driver surgery without taking on more work than the problem is worth to you to fix.

Yeah, with two small kids, the last thing I want to spend my spare time doing is playing with drivers. I want things that just work.

The last thing anyone would want to spend their spare time is fixing your problems with drivers.

Being able to do it yourself is truly the only liberating thing out there, since paying someone else to do it does not seem to actually work these days (or ever).

Re: People keep flocking to Linux, not just to escape Windows

#89
> DAP gets its raw data from a Google Analytics account.

A lot of adblockers also block GA. See [0], it's basically half of adblockers (by usage).

Technically-savvy users are both more likely to use adblockers, and more likely to switch to Linux, and more likely to alter the default settings of their adblocker to make it block more stuff. Also privacy-aware users, counter-cultural users, etc.

So the data is probably underestimating the amount of Linux sessions because it can't see them.

> By DAP's count, the Linux desktop now has a 5.8% market share.

We can probably up that by another couple of percentage points at least, just from this effect.

At extremes, if we accept the argument that the vast majority of Linux users will be using an ad-blocker that they have configured to block GA, then 5.8% seems incredibly low.

[0] https://www.quantable.com/analytics/whats-blocking-google-an...

Re: People keep flocking to Linux, not just to escape Windows

#90

> DAP gets its raw data from a Google Analytics account. A lot of adblockers also block GA. See [0], it's basically half of adblockers (by usage). Technically-savvy users are both more likely to use adblockers, and more likely to switch to Linux, and more likely to alter the default settings of their adblocker to make it block more stuff. Also privacy-aware users, counter-cultural users, etc. So the data is probably…

This has been true of any tracking. They track but the numbers don’t ever add up and are never the true experience. (MarTech does a better job but still has error rates)

I think you’re right. I think it might even be double.

Post reply on HN