Live data from Hacker News

Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

about.nike.com

81–90 of 129 posts

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#81
post #55

> This makes it easier for everyday athletes to walk or run more often, for longer amounts of time, while having more fun — adding movement to their lives, extending their walking commute, or helping them to enjoy the run for another mile or two. The people I know who run all do it for the exercise, not because they like the running. Why would you want to extend it?

I run for exercise, but I also genuinely enjoy it as an activity

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#82

For those of you who don’t “see the point” of a device like this, what you are failing to see is your own personal use case. The use cases I can see for others are “anyone who might find this useful or fun”. To me, that means 1) people with medically compromised joints who would like to engage in experiences that their bodies don’t currently allow. 2) people who want to challenge themselves by making these joint addi…

If it was a medical company I'd agree a bit more. But it's Nike. They'll sell that to any person who thinks walking is too hard even though it's not in his best medical interest.

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Other than ego, what's forcing people recovering from surgery to ride with the A-group?

Friendship and other social connections?

What value is a friendship or connection that can not withstand a few months of "for the next months I will ride with some slower group" or "I may join you for the beginning but I can not go all the way"?

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Have you tried rowing and you found that more boring? I feel like rowing with added bonus of training more muscles would seem most fun?

Yeah tried it and I personally found it less fun.

The tension on the hands feels very good though. And I do wonder if it also trains muscles around ankles that will help prevent shin splints.

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#85
post #55

> This makes it easier for everyday athletes to walk or run more often, for longer amounts of time, while having more fun — adding movement to their lives, extending their walking commute, or helping them to enjoy the run for another mile or two. The people I know who run all do it for the exercise, not because they like the running. Why would you want to extend it?

I run for exercise, but I also genuinely enjoy it as an activity

I understand what you're saying on an intellectual level.

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#86

A lot of comments are casting doubt on why “athletes” would be interested in this product. In the bike world, electric pedal assist bikes have become very popular. I have some family members who are avid cyclists. They do 100+ miles a week. As they have gotten older (60+) they were losing the ability to engage in social rides with their bike friends, but e-bikes have solved that issue by giving them just a small boos…

Yeah, stuff like this is great for people who want to be outside and get some exercise, but aren't doing it for the purpose of competing with anyone.

I personally love hiking. I love going into nature, seeing new places, and being away from people. But there are times where I go for a slightly easier course instead of the one I actually want to do, because that few extra hours would absolutely wreck my body, especially since I'm often hiking in different places for several days. A little boost would be nice.

And with e-bikes, they're great for commuters and people just riding around their neighborhood. Lots of people ride them in my town for doing shopping trips. More affordable than a car, better for the environment, better for your health, and people who otherwise would take a car because they can't deal with pedaling uphill or long distances have a great alternative. I imagine powered shoes will be the same. People who feel like they're too old/out of shape to walk long distances often opt for cars, but if powered shoes give them the confidence to walk, it's far better to take an electronically assisted walk than to sit in a vehicle.

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Friendship and other social connections?

What value is a friendship or connection that can not withstand a few months of "for the next months I will ride with some slower group" or "I may join you for the beginning but I can not go all the way"?

What does "can not" even mean in this context? You could refuse to use an e-bike just like you could refuse to use an expensive bicycle.

Perhaps more interesting, a lot of people I know do train but don't push themselves to the limit. There is always something left in the tank. If their goal is to train to improve it's very [lets say] expensive. They invest a lot for small returns.

Now what if you could keep going if you would otherwise feel the need to quit?

I cycle for a good while then have to guess if ill still be able make it back home. Usually I bet on the safe side. When I bet to low I could add a few laps around the block but this requires an odd kind of discipline that I seem to lack.

Rather than grow it turns into a maintenance routine. If I wanted to do maintenance I would do much less and less frequent.

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#88
post #55

> This makes it easier for everyday athletes to walk or run more often, for longer amounts of time, while having more fun — adding movement to their lives, extending their walking commute, or helping them to enjoy the run for another mile or two. The people I know who run all do it for the exercise, not because they like the running. Why would you want to extend it?

> The people I know who run all do it for the exercise, not because they like the running.

That sounds like torture. Why would you voluntarily practice a form of exercise that you actively dislike, when there are basically infinite options to get the same benefits in different ways?

Believe it or not, many people who stick with running do it because they enjoy it.

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#89

A lot of comments are casting doubt on why “athletes” would be interested in this product. In the bike world, electric pedal assist bikes have become very popular. I have some family members who are avid cyclists. They do 100+ miles a week. As they have gotten older (60+) they were losing the ability to engage in social rides with their bike friends, but e-bikes have solved that issue by giving them just a small boos…

The linked article says this at the end: > * If you have a body, you are an athlete.

Pedantic, but the definition of an athlete is someone proficient in a physical activity. Quite some people barely use their bodies, unless we count moving in and out of a car.

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#90
post #55

> This makes it easier for everyday athletes to walk or run more often, for longer amounts of time, while having more fun — adding movement to their lives, extending their walking commute, or helping them to enjoy the run for another mile or two. The people I know who run all do it for the exercise, not because they like the running. Why would you want to extend it?

> The people I know who run all do it for the exercise, not because they like the running. That sounds like torture. Why would you voluntarily practice a form of exercise that you actively dislike, when there are basically infinite options to get the same benefits in different ways? Believe it or not, many people who stick with running do it because they enjoy it.

>Why would you voluntarily practice a form of exercise that you actively dislike, when there are basically infinite options to get the same benefits in different ways?

If there are other, more enjoyable, ways to get a similarly cardo-intensive workout that are equally convenient I'd love to hear them.

I like cycling. But in practice it is difficult to get my heart rate as high in a sustained way - at least, where I live. A similar level of workout takes a lot longer.

So yeah, hit me with some of these infinite possibilities please.

Post reply on HN