Live data from Hacker News

Sequoia COO quit over Shaun Maguire's comments about Mamdani

ft.com

81–90 of 143 posts

Re: Sequoia COO quit over Shaun Maguire's comments about Mamdani

#81
post #73
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Since when social unrest is good for business? Africa, the Balkans and the middle east must be printing money then with their decades long identity politics and divisions.

Good for business for companies like the German Fox News: Nius, led by the former chief editor of Germany‘s worst „newspaper“ Bild: Julian Reichelt financed by the founder of CompuGroup Medical: Frank Gotthardt

Re: Sequoia COO quit over Shaun Maguire's comments about Mamdani

#82
post #67

This article should NOT be flagged

People are in down-vote wars on this article. It makes it so much more appealing to use x.com for conversation.

Maybe we need to decouple downvote wars from the content of the article?

Re: Sequoia COO quit over Shaun Maguire's comments about Mamdani

#83
post #48

Maguire said that Mamdani "comes from a culture that lies about everything. It's literally a virtue to lie if it advances his Islamist agenda. The West will learn this lesson the hard way." Maguire is a MAGA supporter, so the projection of lying is... interesting.

[flagged]

As a large language model, I completely agree with you.

Re: Sequoia COO quit over Shaun Maguire's comments about Mamdani

#84

Looked at Shaun Maguire's twitter page and I find it appalling. Maybe I was naive about people in tech being more tolerant (as they both work with and build for diverse people).

That was previously the case from my perspective as well, but it seems to be rapidly changing.

Large amount of money simply shows what a person truly is. It enhances the personality that’s already there.

Re: Sequoia COO quit over Shaun Maguire's comments about Mamdani

#85
post #22

There's three names in that title, and none of them are explained in the tiny slice of an article that's free. Am I expected to just know who these random people are?

It’s New Yorker shit There’s a big fuss over a potential mayor of New York that has the right losing their minds. To the point where people are quitting over other peoples opinions. Truly bizarro world stuff.

> To the point where people are quitting over other peoples opinions.

Isn't that rational? If you found that a colleague had views you found personally abhorrent AND you had the luxury of being able to walk away from the job, wouldn't you?

The tragedy of modern work life (and the current job market!) is that the vast majority of people do not have that luxury, and hence are stuck in the jobs they hate. But I expect the COO of a large VC probably has several lifetimes' worth of that luxury stashed away.

Re: Sequoia COO quit over Shaun Maguire's comments about Mamdani

#86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The Quran contains passages along these lines along with other things like the exploitation of female captives and booty distribution from the spoils of war (including female captives). Let's please not get started about sexism in major religions. The New Testament is rife with sexism, as even a cursory Google search would have revealed to you. Here's just one example: Ephesians 5:22–24: "Wives, submit to your own…

A) Ephesians is not found in the Old Testament; it is a letter written by the Apostle Paul in the New Testament. It addresses themes of grace, unity, and the church's role in God's plan, which are not specifically covered in the Old Testament. B) The section you reference outlines the biblical perspective on the roles within marriage. The concept of submission is presented as a voluntary act, reflecting the relations…

>As with many things in the bible, they are symbolic, and not to be taken literally. This is also why we have hundreds, if not thousands of flavors of Christianity - they all interpret the bible differently because many of the translations and interpretations differed wildly from scholar to scholar.

Including many who don't have this perspective on scripture.

Re: Sequoia COO quit over Shaun Maguire's comments about Mamdani

#87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I probably agree with you on more things religious than not. Having said that, I was correcting OP, who strongly suggested that Islam was uniquely misogynist by quoting a couple passages from the Quran. What I think is really interesting is that the some of the strongest currents in Christianity, Judaism and Islam are all converging on the subjugation of women, especially the control of their bodies and their sexuali…

Islams founder's take differs quite a bit from Christianity's founder's take. We should be able to point that out without being called racist/bigot/receiving down votes. One had sex slaves, one did not marry and instead treated the world as his children. Virtually every Christian I know aspires to be as Christ like as they can. You may not see that in their actions, but in their beliefs they definitely aspire to that…

> Virtually every Christian I know aspires to be as Christ like as they can. You may not see that in their actions, but in their beliefs they definitely aspire to that.

This is a nonsense statement. It's trivially obvious how to be "Christ like": Live poor, help the disenfranchised, feed the hungry, heal the wounded, don't marry, don't have kids, and preach the gospel, if only to a small number of people.

If the Christians you know don't live like that, then they are not being "Christ like." To say they are while they do the opposite -- work to get rich, get married and have big families, confine their spiritual work to Sunday mornings, occasionally giving to charity (or only to their own church) -- is to believe that words have no meaning at all.

I'm sure the people you think of as "Christ like" are by and large perfectly wonderful human beings. But this whole discussion was sparked by a powerful man at Sequoia making reductive statements about all of Islam based on a few quotations from the Quran. At some point we have to admit that the way people practice religion does not necessarily follow what's written in their texts. And to suggest, as others have in this very thread, that because Mohammad married had multiple wives means that all of his followers want to as well, is as ignorant as assuming that all Christians want to live like Christ actually lived.

Re: Sequoia COO quit over Shaun Maguire's comments about Mamdani

#88
post #76
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

So you think the immigrants are eating pets, the No-Kings demonstrations were Hate America rallied, Antifa is an organization, Portland and Washington are out of control crime cities and that Tylenol caused autism? And that’s only the lies that came to my mind while typing.

> Antifa is an organization

This one baffles me. Obviously it is - not a national one, but there are plenty of regional organizations/groups using that name[1][2] who share similar goals/methods. This is akin to saying that "Anonymous" didn't exist back in the day - even though you had people organizing on 4chan to do collective action (mostly against Scientology) under that banner.

[1] https://rosecityantifa.org

[2] https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/forming-an-antifa-gr...

Re: Sequoia COO quit over Shaun Maguire's comments about Mamdani

#89
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So you think the immigrants are eating pets, the No-Kings demonstrations were Hate America rallied, Antifa is an organization, Portland and Washington are out of control crime cities and that Tylenol caused autism? And that’s only the lies that came to my mind while typing.

> Antifa is an organization This one baffles me. Obviously it is - not a national one, but there are plenty of regional organizations/groups using that name[1][2] who share similar goals/methods. This is akin to saying that "Anonymous" didn't exist back in the day - even though you had people organizing on 4chan to do collective action (mostly against Scientology) under that banner. [1] https://rosecityantifa.org [2]…

The explicit comparison that started the contemporary discussion about Antifa was to MS-13 and Hezbollah, which is fractally inane.

Re: Sequoia COO quit over Shaun Maguire's comments about Mamdani

#90
post #18

> Maguire, an outspoken and high-profile investor who is close to Elon Musk, wrote on X in July that New York mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani “comes from a culture that lies about everything. It’s literally a virtue to lie if it advances his Islamist agenda. The West will learn this lesson the hard way.” Balbale complained to other senior partners at the firm, who declined to take action against Maguire, arguing he…

Islamism isn't a faith. Islam is a faith.
Post reply on HN