Live data from Hacker News

Tipping point in Gulf Stream may be reached as early as mid-century

agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com

81–90 of 93 posts

Re: Tipping point in Gulf Stream may be reached as early as mid-century

#81
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They’re probably more unreliable as climate is far more complex than economics and predicting 50 years out with any certainty is a ridiculous notion for both.

https://www.science.org/content/article/even-50-year-old-cli... Most of the high profile climate models have been wrong… but in underestimating the speed of global warming. So things generally are worse than research suggests. I think you underestimate how well the models are doing.

So their models are so bad that they’re good. Lol great.

Re: Tipping point in Gulf Stream may be reached as early as mid-century

#82
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No worried, HN has plenty of cranks who don't have real arguments or references to actual studies. I suppose it's just comforting to pretend it's business as usual.

Or we understand geometry and how the volume of carbon has to geometrically increase by a square per degree and it’s not even possible for us to put that much in the atmosphere.

Yeah feel free to link to a study or summary.

Re: Tipping point in Gulf Stream may be reached as early as mid-century

#83
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No worried, HN has plenty of cranks who don't have real arguments or references to actual studies. I suppose it's just comforting to pretend it's business as usual.

Or we understand geometry and how the volume of carbon has to geometrically increase by a square per degree and it’s not even possible for us to put that much in the atmosphere.

Show your work, please. At this point the burden of proof is on you to disprove it, not the other way around. It hasn't snowed here in years.

Re: Tipping point in Gulf Stream may be reached as early as mid-century

#84
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or we understand geometry and how the volume of carbon has to geometrically increase by a square per degree and it’s not even possible for us to put that much in the atmosphere.

Show your work, please. At this point the burden of proof is on you to disprove it, not the other way around. It hasn't snowed here in years.

The fact you don’t even understand this basic fact and yet are so certain should concern you.

1. Logarithmic effect of CO₂ • The warming effect of carbon dioxide grows logarithmically with concentration, not linearly. • This means the first 100 ppm of CO₂ caused a much larger temperature impact than, say, an increase from 400 → 500 ppm. • Each additional molecule of CO₂ contributes less extra warming because much of the infrared spectrum it absorbs is already saturated.

2. Geometry of “forcing” • Scientists describe this as radiative forcing, measured in watts per square meter. • Roughly, each doubling of CO₂ concentration produces about +3.7 W/m² of forcing, which translates (with climate sensitivity) to ~1.5–4.5°C warming. • So it takes geometrically more CO₂ to achieve each additional degree of warming. For example: • Going from 280 → 400 ppm may give ~1°C warming. • Going from 400 → 560 ppm (another 160 ppm) gives another ~1°C. • Going from 560 → 840 ppm (280 ppm more) gives another ~1°C. • And so on — the increments needed get larger each time.

Re: Tipping point in Gulf Stream may be reached as early as mid-century

#85
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or we understand geometry and how the volume of carbon has to geometrically increase by a square per degree and it’s not even possible for us to put that much in the atmosphere.

Yeah feel free to link to a study or summary.

It’s logarithmic. Just google it or ask any LLM to explain this basic fact to you.

Re: Tipping point in Gulf Stream may be reached as early as mid-century

#86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There were fewer humans around last time. Also there were no 'journalists' around to proclaim it so. If a tree falls in the forest and there is nobody around to hear it, does it make a sound?

Are you suggesting that humans never write about great extinction events that occurred in the past?

I'm unaware of any surviving artifacts of the chronicles of Lemuria. Non-fictional, that is.

Re: Tipping point in Gulf Stream may be reached as early as mid-century

#87
post #54
post #6

I cannot overemphasize how epochal of a crisis this would be for human civilization - the gulf stream is pretty much the only thing keeping northern europe (The UK, Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway, Sweden, Finland, parts of germany, the Netherlands, etc) habitable by current standards. Basically, the gulf stream is a conveyor belt that grabs nice warm water from southern latitudes (carribean, southeast atlantic oce…

"The notion that the Gulf Stream is responsible for keeping Europe anomalously warm turns out to be a myth." https://www.americanscientist.org/article/the-source-of-euro...

Sacrilege! Heresy! Sick Fantasy! Madness! Heathen Hell! Demonic Spell!

Re: Tipping point in Gulf Stream may be reached as early as mid-century

#88

Okay that's maybe dramatic, but on another hand, that would be quite fascinating to experience. Maybe, for those of us living long enough, we are going to witness a net migration not from Africa to Europe, but from Europe to elsewhere, anywhere. There is enough place on Earth for humans to resettle and it's likely that other places will become more hospitable, while other places will become less, as the climate shift…

Europe is currently so hostile to receiving the people who need to move there that they might be surprised how much hostility they're met with if/when the tables turn.

Europe has the technology and experience to solve geo-social problems by turning itself into a cozy castle with high walls. The hostiles will be used as feedstock for alcalic hydrolysis at industrial scale/faster than replacement/birthing rate until the zones have been fully sanitized. Problems turned into fertilizer for nukkular powered greenhouses.

Re: Tipping point in Gulf Stream may be reached as early as mid-century

#89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I believe southern European countries won't be as screwed. The Mediterranean sea has enough thermal mass to keep things Ok. North of the Alps screwed big time. However, the lack of rainfall could be the real killer. As the warm humid air would stops coming it's not clear if the precipitations would be enough to sustain crops in Mediterranean countries. Also, the US east cost and the Caribbean countries would be fucke…

I recommend "The Light Pirate" by Lily Brooks-Dalton that deals with this sort of future.

Yawn. Why not https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_Weather_(Sterling_novel) ?

Re: Tipping point in Gulf Stream may be reached as early as mid-century

#90
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Aren’t most crops watered via irrigation? Why is precipitation necessary

Because irrigation needs fresh water. Fresh water is brought inland by precipitation. No precipitation no rivers to irrigate from after the glaciers that might also feed them run out

Nukkular powered desalination plants at the coasts, pumping it inward via pipelines could be a solution.
Post reply on HN