Live data from Hacker News

US Defense Department will stop providing satellite weather data

text.npr.org

81–90 of 185 posts

Re: US Defense Department will stop providing satellite weather data

#83
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What in the actual fuck. I can’t believe they are actually doing all those little petty things.

Yes as warned and ignored.

Literally had this report for years and literally heard the current president praise and endorse it on a hot mic. The fact that, presumably, educated people, are still acting surprised (or worse, legitimately are ignorant) when the reic-i mean presidency was explicitly planned out, in a commissioned by the wealthy, public to all, report by the most connected conservative think tank in the country.

Re: US Defense Department will stop providing satellite weather data

#84

Here is what will be denied to NOAA, now and going forward Defense Department data also allow hurricane forecasters to see hurricanes as they form, and monitor them in real-time. For example, hurricane experts can see where the center of a newly formed storm is, which allows them to figure out as early as possible what direction it is likely to go, and whether the storm might hit land. That's important for people in…

> it would be ... lots of ways to fill in that part. iterating the words seems worth the effort. Thinking out loud, there are readers with frame of reference, and movements or politics-in-practice that have frames of reference, in the messaging .. So making a 2x2 square and filling it in.. you can write for the readers and refine, you can align with movements or their spokespersons and refine, all combined with you y…

oh this is great "Weather: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver"

Re: US Defense Department will stop providing satellite weather data

#85
post #17
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Accuweather, who also depend on this same USG sensor data for their modeling… I don’t think anybody wins from this. See e.g. https://www.accuweather.com/en/press/accuweather-does-not-su...

It not being publicly published or furnished to NOAA doesn't mean AccuWeather or other private entities won't get this data.

Re: US Defense Department will stop providing satellite weather data

#86
As a non-American who's life has been previously saved by knowing that a typhoon would strike my home this has me wondering how we will be affected. A lot of smaller countries don't have the infrastructure/man power to maintain a space program. To what extent is the rest of the world reliant on this data and what does this mean for us? Will we still have predictions? How does international collaboration on meteorology generally work? Do Europeans/Chinese/Indians/Russians also share data about weather?

Re: US Defense Department will stop providing satellite weather data

#87

Here is what will be denied to NOAA, now and going forward Defense Department data also allow hurricane forecasters to see hurricanes as they form, and monitor them in real-time. For example, hurricane experts can see where the center of a newly formed storm is, which allows them to figure out as early as possible what direction it is likely to go, and whether the storm might hit land. That's important for people in…

> NOAA, which oversees the National Hurricane Center, says the loss of the Defense Department data will not lead to less-accurate hurricane forecasts this year. In a statement, NOAA communications director Kim Doster said, "NOAA's data sources are fully capable of providing a complete suite of cutting-edge data and models that ensure the gold-standard weather forecasting the American people deserve."

I wouldn’t really expect a Trump administration spokesperson to put out a statement critical of the Trump administration’s decision.

Re: US Defense Department will stop providing satellite weather data

#88

My hunch is that the location of the satellites can be deduced from the weather data. These satellites would be a target in a time of war.

Satellites using sun-synchronous orbits can circle the Earth multiple times in a day.Compared with a stationary observer on the ground,they are moving at a relatively fast speed.Therefore,as long as they delay the release of observational data by a random time period,there won't be this issue.Only geostationary satellites would have this problem.

But a bigger problem comes before the above issue:most of the current human meteorological satellites do not have stealth capabilities.You can see them directly.Perhaps your idea will become a practical problem when satellite stealth technology matures.

This is a translation.

Re: US Defense Department will stop providing satellite weather data

#90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The timing is just, it's atrocious. Okay, at this very moment, I say we sit tight and assess.

That's what got us here in the first place, maybe stop doing that.

"Sit tight and assess" as used above is probably a reference to the movie "Don't Look Up" from a few years ago, which (heavy-handedly) parodied administrations like Trump I (and which unortunately seem much less like parody in the Trump II era).
Post reply on HN