Live data from Hacker News

Firefox Is Finally (Re)Adding Support for Web Apps

omgubuntu.co.uk

81–90 of 97 posts

Re: Firefox Is Finally (Re)Adding Support for Web Apps

#82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I will mourn the lack of a non-Chrome browser engine with enough market share to prevent Chrome from unilaterally changing the web.

Safari / WebKit. It's unironically better than Chrome in nearly every way, except dev tools.

And being proprietary, and only running on one family of operating systems.

Re: Firefox Is Finally (Re)Adding Support for Web Apps

#86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What if you want to copy and share the page?

I'd be fine with a 2~3 click operation to get the URL. Which is basically how it works in Chrome in PWA mode: a few basic actions (get the URL, print, cast, adjust zoom etc) in a menu, and an option to punt it to the full chrome if needed.

That’s a fine idea.

Re: Firefox Is Finally (Re)Adding Support for Web Apps

#87

Why would I want to use a pwa that hides the things that allow me to control what the browser does? I actively use websites over apps solely because I have more control over the interaction.

Perhaps because you've chosen to install a PWA instead of continuing to use the website? The experience is different, if you want a browser like environment, just use the browser.

Re: Firefox Is Finally (Re)Adding Support for Web Apps

#88
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1. if 90% of the people don't want a toolbar in a PWA (I'm being generous about 10% wanting it), it makes sense to not have it 2. It is not harder to implement a button to show the toolbar menu In all case, it should be (it already is by the spec!) a developer option, not something enforced by the browser.

I have learned a long time ago not to make claims about how hard it is to implement something in other people's projects - I get it wrong often enough about my own. (Also, I don't think there's a single "PWA spec".)

It's definitely doable to make the bar disappear with a tiny bit of CSS. Did it myself in the past and the Firefox team does it partially for their vertical tabs feature

Re: Firefox Is Finally (Re)Adding Support for Web Apps

#90

I have been installing some PWAs lately at work and... I love them. They have been replacing the need for electron and they also feel integrated with the OS. In chrome, there is always a button to "bring back" the app from pwa into a browser tab (really nice). There is the option to open links directly in the pwa, you can access your extension from a small icon. I read that on the specs there might be an option to ke…

Thank you very much, Excalidraw is the best PWA implementation I have seen so far.
Post reply on HN