Live data from Hacker News

GLP-1 drugs: An economic disruptor? (2024)

wildfirelabs.substack.com

81–90 of 553 posts

Re: GLP-1 drugs: An economic disruptor? (2024)

#81
>- Movie theaters becoming "social experience centers"

>- Retail spaces becoming venues to "try before you subscribe"

>- Restaurants becoming "social nutrition centers"

>- Shopping malls converting to "wellness districts"

Except for resturants, all of these have had problems for a long time. People have been talking about the death of shopping malls since the 90s.

Feels like other factors are in play here.

Re: GLP-1 drugs: An economic disruptor? (2024)

#82

Jevons paradox applied to healthy people vs unhealthy. Healthy people create more demand not less. You order out you just order healthier. Healthier food is more expensive than junk food. You buy an expensive bike. More clothes. Healthcare is still expensive because people get older and older people need more care.

I don't think Jevon's Paradox applies here. People won't buy healthier food, they'll buy less food.

Re: GLP-1 drugs: An economic disruptor? (2024)

#83

Is there a term for this style of writing? It's like a longform linkedin post. I don't mean this as a criticism, it just seems like written language is evolving to better capture our diminishing attention spans.

It gives me serious TED talk vibes. I guess it could be called that. Or maybe it's the twitter thread style?

A lot of catchy one liner hook sentences ("they're literally removing concession stands from NFL stadiums!") that sort of add up to make the author's point.

I'm pretty sure fact checking line by line will make the whole thing less impressive.

Re: GLP-1 drugs: An economic disruptor? (2024)

#84

The author is assuming that everyone will proactively start taking this drug. But I don't understand why? If Jerry is not obese, why would Jerry randomly start taking an anti-obesity drug?

It's not an "anti-obesity drug" it's a "set your hunger level to whatever you want drug"

If Jerry is a body builder he can get to whatever body fat % he wants.

If Jerry wants to save money or doesn't want to wake up early hungry he can do that too.

If Jerry has religious beliefs about impulses coming from shaitan, he can get rid of them.

Besides, 75% of Americans are overweight/obese that's pretty much everyone.

Re: GLP-1 drugs: An economic disruptor? (2024)

#85

I would feel like an absolute failure if I need medicine to help create willpower. EDIT: under the assumption of an average person who is not under any medical condition that may result in lack of willpower

How would you feel if you were born with an unusual and detrimental somatic condition that could be fixed with medicine?

Re: GLP-1 drugs: An economic disruptor? (2024)

#86
post #56

The author is assuming that everyone will proactively start taking this drug. But I don't understand why? If Jerry is not obese, why would Jerry randomly start taking an anti-obesity drug?

Because the author assumes that the drugs are not only anti-obesity drugs but impulse controlling

Correctly assumes*

Re: GLP-1 drugs: An economic disruptor? (2024)

#88
The article posits that 80% of the top income quintile will be on this medication.

I have to ask, why? (I'm not in the US, I should add). Like, sure, is the average American overweight? Yes. Are 80% of the top 20% of earners? Seems pretty doubtful, plenty of the rich look to be in reasonable shape.

That statistic suggests that 80% of successful people have such poor impulse control that they end up seriously overweight or obese. And I say that as someone who likes a treat every couple of days, but exercises enough to maintain a fairly healthy weight.

Admittedly if there were a GLP1 for procrastination, I'd be on that stuff like a shot...

Re: GLP-1 drugs: An economic disruptor? (2024)

#89
post #14

> When companies like Google see their healthcare costs drop by $12,000 per employee annually and productivity increase by 25%, we observe a restructuring of corporate America that makes remote work a minor adjustment. In my entire office, there's one overweight person that I know. Out of thousands of employees. There could be more, and other cities might be different, but you get the idea. The author intentionally o…

40% of Americans are obese and way more are merely overweight. Either your office is small, a huge fluke, weirdly selected or you're not observant enough.

6th option: They are overweight, but do not know, so they don't recognize what overweight looks like. But also, it's pretty easy to not look overweight if you're not obese. 30 pounds can be as little as a few waist sizes. I can gain and lose 15 pounds without looking like I changed at all.

Re: GLP-1 drugs: An economic disruptor? (2024)

#90
post #51

Is GLP-1 really changing general impulse control? But I do buy the argument. If impulse controlling drugs are going to be effective, the economic impact is basically not quantifiable... not only the economic impact but it would change society as a whole in extremely fundamental ways (e.g. dating)

So this drug would mess with my head – am I understanding it right?

Everything messes with your head, this adjusts the mess levels.
Post reply on HN