Live data from Hacker News

Why ‘Ok’ Buttons in Dialog Boxes Work Best on the Right

uxmovement.com

81–83 of 83 posts

Re: Why ‘Ok’ Buttons in Dialog Boxes Work Best on the Right

#81
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To me, this seems like a great example of unnecessary optimization. Yes, the number of "visual fixations" is slightly less but in the grand scheme of a person's day, we're talking about a difference of milliseconds, if that. Aren't there far more egregious examples of UI design to spend time agonizing over?

Well, to steal a riff from Steve Jobs, milliseconds per day * days over years of use * tens/hundreds of millions of users (if you're designing the conventions for a big platform) = years or lifetimes. I'm just not convinced by the reasoning.

Yes, I've heard that reasoning over and over again and it just doesn't hold water at all for me. "Time-saving" just doesn't work at that level of minutiae.

Again, it's simply optimization where none is needed.

Re: Why ‘Ok’ Buttons in Dialog Boxes Work Best on the Right

#82

"...if you’re a knowledgeable and experienced designer ... then you can solve this problem through design analysis [as opposed to user testing]" But if you're an empirical scientist you will use user testing to confirm or deny your hypothesis rather than assuming your rationalisations hold in the real world.

Exactly. Most of the article was based on some sort of unjustified "innate" knowledge of how users behave. He dismisses platform consistency as being unscientific and then goes on to present his own equally unscientific arguments for ignoring the convention. In the face of these two alternatives, I'd choose platform consistency every single time.

Ditto. Especially since the OS UI standards are usually based upon empirical studies conducted by MS or Apple.

Re: Why ‘Ok’ Buttons in Dialog Boxes Work Best on the Right

#83

Never take GUI advice from a web site that hardcodes the width of its paragraphs to 600px. Seriously, who does this in 2012?

People who understand, that there is such a thing as optimal line length, and that line running across 24" monitor does not have it?

While this is theoretically correct, it goes against the principle of the web.

Write the content, provide some structural guidance (paragraphs, item lists, etc...) and let readers decide how to render it.

Post reply on HN