Live data from Hacker News

The ‘Network of Web Trees’ in Gaza

globalvoices.org

81–84 of 84 posts

Re: The ‘Network of Web Trees’ in Gaza

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes I think if the walls between Gaza and Israel came down it would be a moment like the taking down of the Berlin wall. Two people, ruled by the same government, finally experiencing the same rights, same freedoms, same status, etc. How to tear down that wall without the extremists trying to kill their "enemies" on each side first, that no one has the answer to

Regardless of your outlook on I/P, I don't think either side agrees that they currently do (or particularly want to) share the same government. (That's not to assert my own view. But to compare it to the Berlin Wall seems faulty.)

They may not agree but the fact on the ground is that the Israeli government does not recognize any Palestinian state, so the people in Palestine are thus under the control of the Israeli state or they are stateless refugees with a right to return (to Israel). Either way, they are the responsibility of Israel the way Israel's government sees it.

What people want is one thing. What governments do is the official thing, that's what I refer to

Re: The ‘Network of Web Trees’ in Gaza

#82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Regardless of your outlook on I/P, I don't think either side agrees that they currently do (or particularly want to) share the same government. (That's not to assert my own view. But to compare it to the Berlin Wall seems faulty.)

They may not agree but the fact on the ground is that the Israeli government does not recognize any Palestinian state, so the people in Palestine are thus under the control of the Israeli state or they are stateless refugees with a right to return (to Israel). Either way, they are the responsibility of Israel the way Israel's government sees it. What people want is one thing. What governments do is the official thing…

I don’t particularly disagree with the bulk of this comment. But I’ll note that it’s substantially different than your original one, which is not about responsibility but about a hypothetical peace that would spontaneously occur if Israel would unilaterally drop its campaign. I don’t think that’s realistic, even though I agree that the side with a functional state bears additional responsibility.

Re: The ‘Network of Web Trees’ in Gaza

#83
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you familiar with the history of how those walls went up? Hint: it has something to do with more than one thousand civilian deaths caused by suicide bombers coming from Gaza in the late 1990s and early 2000s, which almost completely stopped after the walls and checkpoints were installed. Now Hamas uses rockets instead, but those were much less dangerous on average than the bombings that were employed beforehand.

We can play the are you familiar with history game forever. They don't just bomb people because they're crazy barbarians. They do it because they have been forced from their homes and constantly had their villages and homes raided, burned, destroyed, and built on top of by Israeli settlers who the army protects. The entire West Bank is like this, and it's not surprising they turned to whatever tactics they could to s…

[deleted]

Re: The ‘Network of Web Trees’ in Gaza

#84
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The only one blocking aid right now is Egypt in the Rafa crossing. Israel is literally bringing in aid themselves again what other country warns a civilian population before it attacks? Does Russia warn Ukraine civilians?

You couldn't come up with something to blame the children in the refugee bombing huh?

No I got banned
Post reply on HN