Live data from Hacker News

Fighting Infomania: Why 80% of Your Reading Is a Waste of Time (2016)

nateliason.com

81–90 of 106 posts

Re: Fighting Infomania: Why 80% of Your Reading Is a Waste of Time (2016)

#81

I snagged a cheap bench press and squat rack and a huge set of weights on Craigslist. I decided I would get back into a basic lifting routine I did in high school and asked some friends who do that. I quickly was engulfed with endless articles and information. I have decided to eschew any learning and stick with "Me big caveman. lift big rock get stronger" approach and it's working fine. Taking it easy, enjoying it,…

> It's more refreshing to REFUSE information than to consume it.

I did something similar when I was powerlifting. Basics worked very well. I'm also doing the same thing as I learn jiu-jitsu. There's so much crazy stuff on social, but much of it is for show. And, to get good at something takes time. If someone is trying a new move every week they are never really getting good at anything.

Re: Fighting Infomania: Why 80% of Your Reading Is a Waste of Time (2016)

#83

I completely disagree with the article’s core premise. I have read voraciously for my entire life since I was a little kid. Maybe much of it wasted, yet tidbits of knowledge I have gained over the years of reading come up constantly, and give me a bit of a leg up in conversations. HN is a big part of that, I can read about a wide array of technologies and processes and science that I normally would never encounter. A…

The articles point is that this time spent has a horrible roi, which I tend to agree with. You should acknowledge that time spent on Hacker News is entertainment, not education. If you really want to get better at something you should just do it. Only place I disagree is that I think studying one or two good books on a topic can give you a good foundation to start on. Like, if you have no experience with starting a b…

I am a technology consultant with mid sized global consulting services firm. Reading Hacker News is both entertainment and professional research. I get tremendous hands on insight into technology that directly informs my own thinking on various technologies, and have served as a great early warning system of “here there be dragons” in various products.

Re: Fighting Infomania: Why 80% of Your Reading Is a Waste of Time (2016)

#84
post #9

Read “infomania” as insomnia and skimmed the whole damn thing (or 80% if it) before figuring out this didn’t have the cure for insomnia (unless it’s caused by infomania, which is plausible).

Try a bad fiction book. The 'entertain you' category in the article, but a bad one. You'll fall asleep :)

Don't try a good one or you'll fall asleep at 4am when you finish it.

Re: Fighting Infomania: Why 80% of Your Reading Is a Waste of Time (2016)

#86
Now, I'm certain that this article is about frustration at self-improvement/fitness buzz-feed "listicles" and the author may have had a passing glance about Deming's Management Cycle and connected these two ideas. Good for him, it's this kind of creative thinking that I want to talk about.

Though there are several reasons to agree and disagree with the author, the thing that's been left out of the comments so far is that: making connections between ideas is absolutely essential. It's not that I strictly need to know the things I know, but the ability to draw on a variety of mental resources from a variety of fields is what makes me useful and exceptional at my job. Given that the author readily admits to only having interned at a major company once and is now looking to start their own business is the big giveaway that they lack the life experience to be able to apricate the difference between data, information, knowledge, and wisdom. This is not shocking, most young folks are eager to rise up in the world and are sick of school, but, if I could give some unsolicited advice: keep learning. When you stop moving, you'll notice that the world stops moving around you too. It's the ability to draw connections between unrelated ideas that makes creativity and innovation possible. If you only have a few ideas in your head, then you are absolutely impairing your ability to think. Similarly, if you become too fixated on, well, anything... than you're going to miss the big picture. Outsourcing your mind to Teh Internets reduces your mind to only that which can be google'd, and even if that's acceptable to you than you still have to know what to put into that search-box.

Re: Fighting Infomania: Why 80% of Your Reading Is a Waste of Time (2016)

#87
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If every book reads like Malcolm Gladwell (or Harari, et al), you probably are reading the wrong nonfiction books.

Could you give me an example of one that for you is the "right kind" and I'll see if I feel the same way about it? Just as a check for myself.

Something by, say, Stephen Walt. Or autobiographies.

The trouble with nonfiction is that the really informative stuff tends to be radical or dry or otherwise challenging to read, which makes it unpopular compared to the vibes-based stuff that will end up on Obama's and Gates' annual lists.

Re: Fighting Infomania: Why 80% of Your Reading Is a Waste of Time (2016)

#88
post #30

Does reading have to be "productive" in order to be worthwhile? I would argue that reading is an enjoyable activity regardless of whether there are any tangible benefits. Similar to how it's enjoyable to go on a meandering walk. Even though there are more efficient forms of cardio and you could get to where your going faster by driving, that doesn't keep the activity from being enjoyable in and of itself. I've probab…

As a dyslexic person, I can assure you that reading is not a universally enjoyable activity. You should enjoy your gifts, though. I do enjoy a good walk.

Re: Fighting Infomania: Why 80% of Your Reading Is a Waste of Time (2016)

#89
post #84
post #9

Read “infomania” as insomnia and skimmed the whole damn thing (or 80% if it) before figuring out this didn’t have the cure for insomnia (unless it’s caused by infomania, which is plausible).

Try a bad fiction book. The 'entertain you' category in the article, but a bad one. You'll fall asleep :) Don't try a good one or you'll fall asleep at 4am when you finish it.

> Don't try a good one or you'll fall asleep at 4am when you finish it.

You mean 4am two days later, when you finish the whole 12-book series that begin with the book you picked.

Don't ask me how I know.

Re: Fighting Infomania: Why 80% of Your Reading Is a Waste of Time (2016)

#90
One rebuttal I'd add is that "just in case" reading increases the amount of knowledge you can reference when faced with a new problem.

E.g., if you only try to learn things once you know you need them, you miss out on things you didn't know you could know.

Post reply on HN