Live data from Hacker News

X CEO Says Platform Should Turn Profit in 2024

wsj.com

81–90 of 105 posts

Re: X CEO Says Platform Should Turn Profit in 2024

#81

I’m not surprised the comments here are universally skeptical so far, but I’ll chime in that I think it’s plausible. The largest expense by far was compensation and with 10% the previous workforce it dropped dramatically. The question is how much revenue would have fallen. In the HN bubble X is basically over and everyone has moved to Mastodon, but there has been little change in the folks I follow. Are journalists a…

In the end, journalists are dependent on social media to get eyeballs on their content. Twitter / X still is a highly effective tool for that. There won't be a lot of people that can afford to opt out of that.

Elon Musk probably rubbed a lot of people the wrong way with his antics but I don't think he was fundamentally that wrong with his core analysis of the issues facing Twitter when he bought it:

- High staffing cost relative and some revenue challenges.

- Content moderation that was simultaneously controversial, expensive, and biased. And also not that effective.

- The Twitter API was getting abused a lot by people with all sorts of agendas. Including some state actors like Russia.

- R&D stagnation. The site barely changed in the years before he bought it.

So, he took a wrecking ball to the whole thing and upset a lot of people doing so. But, if he gets it back to being profitable next year, that will be a big milestone for them.

I've been using it less and less over the years. But that already started before the takeover. I kind of like Mastodon currently but part of the attraction is that it is relatively free from the noisy crowd that makes Twitter less interesting than it used to be.

Re: X CEO Says Platform Should Turn Profit in 2024

#83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Lying to users about performance is covered under free speech. It's securities fraud if Musk is knowingly lying to those with an interest in X, even if a private company. Necessary components are standing ("I own a piece of X"), appetite to litigate, and evidence the statement was knowingly untrue. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Securities_Exchange_Act_of_193... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_Securities_Litigat…

Perhaps she is merely a figurehead, but this was the CEO, not Musk, making these statements. "X Corp. Chief Executive Linda Yaccarino said on Wednesday..."

Is she an officer of the company?

Re: X CEO Says Platform Should Turn Profit in 2024

#84
post #2

I don't get how it is allowed that C-Suits just are allowed to blatantly lie to their investors/board/users they have the data and they know it won't happen. Exactly how Musks knows FSD won't happen this year...

> I don't get how it is allowed that C-Suits just are allowed to blatantly lie to their investors/board/users they have the data and they know it won't happen

This is _why_ many jurisdictions, including the US, have some concept of 'qualified/accredited' investor, and investment in private companies is somewhat restricted to people who are presumed to know what they're doing. CEOs of _public_ companies absolutely cannot lie about financials, but it's murkier for private companies.

Re: X CEO Says Platform Should Turn Profit in 2024

#85
post #25

> X CEO Says Platform Should Turn Profit in 2024 If you believe it, it's not a lie!

Musk's Cybertruck will self-drive over to the X-branded office to pick up the bags of cash.

All the cyber-monkeys will come back to life and cheer!

Re: X CEO Says Platform Should Turn Profit in 2024

#86

> X CEO Says Platform Should Turn Profit in 2024 If you believe it, it's not a lie!

> If you believe it, it's not a lie! Is this supposed to be some kind of “gotcha?” Of course saying something you believe is true is not a lie. Of course. Why would you even bring up the possibility of it being a lie? Nevermind a prediction cannot be a lie. Misleading perhaps, but not a lie.

I tend to not believe narrators who have a track record of bullshiting.

Re: X CEO Says Platform Should Turn Profit in 2024

#87

> X CEO Says Platform Should Turn Profit in 2024 If you believe it, it's not a lie!

How can you classify a prediction as a lie? You could say it's unrealistic or delusional based solely on your guesses without having seen any financial data, but it's not a lie.

The classification is based on the reliability of the narrator, itself based on its track record on delivering on its huge promises who will be delivered "Next years, second quarter"

Re: X CEO Says Platform Should Turn Profit in 2024

#88
post #15

If Musk says something, take the opposite stance. Bet on the demise of X in 2024.

Except Elon didn't say this. He's not the CEO. "X Corp. Chief Executive Linda Yaccarino said on Wednesday..."

Our CEO has a hand up his arse from the parent org's CEO.

In this case, parent ego.

Re: X CEO Says Platform Should Turn Profit in 2024

#89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The key there is "knowingly." For those who want to litigate, proving that he's lying is incredibly difficult. You would need some kind of internal message from Musk directly saying that "X will not be profitable in 2024" right before he posted. I doubt anyone will actually sue him over this.

Isn't that redundant? You can't unknowingly lie. To lie is to say something that you know isn't true.

> To lie is to say something that you know isn't true.

There's lying by omission; no falsehoods, but important bits left out.

Post reply on HN