Live data from Hacker News

The cartel that controls the US meat industry

statecraft.beehiiv.com

81–90 of 171 posts

Re: The cartel that controls the US meat industry

#81
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Same. This is about meat, although since a lot of our land is used to grow feed for livestock, subsidies for plant agriculture are indirectly subsidizing inefficient animal agriculture.

Calling meat agriculture inefficient makes no sense, when meat is a vital, and necessary food. Most of the world grazes meat animals, no crop feeding, and do so on land utterly unusable for crops. If you want to dive into weirdo anti-meat statements, at least be sensible. We could just eat raw vitamins and eat bacteria paste too, instead of "inefficient" fertilizer driven crops.

> meat is a vital, and necessary food

And you talk about "weird" statements?

Re: The cartel that controls the US meat industry

#82

Food system is a technical term and is distinctly different than the meat industry, which it encompasses. These companies certainly do not "control the food system"

That's debatable. If they're able to influence UN FAO and IPCC (among many others I'm sure), and they are, they kinda do.

https://qz.com/ipcc-report-on-climate-change-meat-industry-1...

The meat industry blocked the IPCC’s attempt to recommend a plant-based diet

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/352100490_Emissions...

FAO's work on emissions from animal agriculture may be influenced by the meat industry's interests, potentially affecting their recommendations on reducing meat consumption for environmental reasons.

https://www.pcrm.org/news/blog/meat-and-dairy-subsidies-make...

Meat and Dairy Subsidies Make America Sick

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2022/dec/09/academy-nutr...

Revealed: group shaping US nutrition receives millions from big food industry

https://www.salon.com/2022/11/11/the-meat-industry-is-borrow...

The meat industry is borrowing tactics from Big Oil to obfuscate the truth about climate change

https://www.americanprogress.org/article/why-the-farm-bill-m...

Why the Farm Bill May Be the Highest-Stakes Climate Fight Flying Below the Radar

Re: The cartel that controls the US meat industry

#84

The word "monopoly" implies one dominant company ("mono-" meaning one), but industries with 2 or 3 companies are still unhealthy for a few reasons. First, it's pretty easy for 2 or 3 companies to price fix, which is against anti-trust laws. Second, a healthy market requires that it be easy for new companies to enter the market and compete, and if there's only a few dominant companies, then clearly new competitors are…

“Oligopoly” is the word you are looking for, carried out by oligarch.

Re: The cartel that controls the US meat industry

#85
post #35

RFK put out a video explaining how this consolidation occurred in the pork industry: https://twitter.com/RobertKennedyJr/status/16865387973102428... It was basically a case of a politician, Wendell Murphy, who helped pass 28 laws making it illegal to sue a factory farm, then left office and went into partnership with Smithfield Foods, a Chinese-owned company (which according to Wikipedia was "the largest Chinese acqu…

> It was basically a case of a politician, Wendell Murphy, who helped pass 28 laws making it illegal to sue a factory farm, then left office and went into partnership with Smithfield Foods, a Chinese-owned company

Said politician was in office (NC House/Senate) in the 80s, and his company was bought in 1999 by Smithfield Foods. Smithfield was bought by WH Group, a Chinese company, in 2013.

> They now control 80% of pork US production

This appears to be fiction. The closest I can find is that 6 large companies control 80% of the wholesale market, Smithfield being one of them.

Re: The cartel that controls the US meat industry

#86
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is correct. Food companies cannot hike prices just because, especially when they are monopolies. If suddenly eggs cost $20/dozen, customers will ask why and if there are no good explanations, there will be a lot of noise. And politicians and regulators who are otherwise not willing to act on monopolies, do not like noise because it threatens their jobs. They will act, and that will not be great for the food comp…

Or, ya know, they can’t raise prices that high because people will just stop buying eggs and they will stop making money. Eggs are very much an elastic good. Does no one understand basic economics anymore?

Eggs are a fungible product (well, sort of).

In a working market there are a lot of sellers and buyers and I'd find the lowest ask price and buy it.

In a failed market, the price is locked.

You’re actually advocating for anti-competition and anti-capitalism.

Re: The cartel that controls the US meat industry

#87

A reminder that Tyson is abusing the legal system to force people in the American south into working in their chicken plants for free: https://revealnews.org/article/they-thought-they-were-going-... I don't know every brand that uses Tyson products, but when I discover something is coming from a Tyson factory I stop purchasing it.

This is pretty awful. I can almost guarantee that if you look into the campaign donors for these judges the chicken farms will there. It reminds me of the judge that used to send kids to prison because he was getting a kick back.

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/judges-sent-children-pr...

Sometimes those we trust to enforce justice are the biggest criminals of all and we give them essentially unlimited power.

Abuse of power to this extent and the ruining of so many lives should be a death penalty offence.

Re: The cartel that controls the US meat industry

#88

A reminder that Tyson is abusing the legal system to force people in the American south into working in their chicken plants for free: https://revealnews.org/article/they-thought-they-were-going-... I don't know every brand that uses Tyson products, but when I discover something is coming from a Tyson factory I stop purchasing it.

I find it more shocking that, despite the terrible reported conditions at the plant, most people stayed there because it was preferable to prison. If that is preferable to their prisons...

I'd rather go to prison. Take the gamble, at least prison has time off for good behavior and over crowding. This program looks like its designed to drain you of everything for as long as possible.

Re: The cartel that controls the US meat industry

#89
post #65

A reminder that Tyson is abusing the legal system to force people in the American south into working in their chicken plants for free: https://revealnews.org/article/they-thought-they-were-going-... I don't know every brand that uses Tyson products, but when I discover something is coming from a Tyson factory I stop purchasing it.

The taste is enough reason to never eat a Tyson chicken.

you don't like chicken that smells like gym socks? i thought i was the only one

Re: The cartel that controls the US meat industry

#90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> In general, I don’t know if they answer properly if profits increased because of inflation or if inflation increased because of inflation. Since the cartel existed before the shift, I would like to know what they think made companies suddenly get greedier. That's my big question too with all this "greed driving inflation" discourse. I don't doubt it at all, in fact, from everything I see it seems like the likeliest…

The price of inputs is going up, but so are interest rates (and expected future interest rates). So where money was cheap, it's going to become more expensive. I suspect it's understandable a business would want to increase its margins given the expectation of higher rates -- as opposed to the personified "greed" narrative.

> The price of inputs is going up

Except it didn't. That's like, the first thing in the article.

Post reply on HN