Live data from Hacker News

Crowdsource by Google

crowdsource.google.com

81–90 of 142 posts

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#81

So many comments bemoaning a company benefiting from the free labour of others. Wait until they hear about open source software, they'll do their nut!

Curious as to why this is getting downvoted? It's literally how the economics of open source software works. Vanishingly few companies put back anything like the value they extract from the open source ecosystem and many, many projects are funded overwhelmingly by the free labour and effort of their committers.

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#82

I was expecting to be pessimistic, but Google actually releases the datasets under a permissive license (CC-By 4.0). Awesome! https://research.google/tools/datasets/open-images-extended-... https://github.com/google-research-datasets/hiertext

"Google shares some Crowdsource data via open-sourcing" Looks like the releases will only be partial. This kind of data should be collected bu a nonprofit for the benefit of everyone.

Also, what the crowd gets is “cool badges”

Who even comes up with these things?

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#83

One of the tasks in this app is audio validation: > Audio validation: Listen to a short audio clip and determine if the pronunciation sounds natural in your language. If this is something you're interested in doing, I recommend contributing to Mozilla's Common Voice instead. Common Voice builds freely licensed (CC-0) voice datasets that can be used by anyone, not just Google: https://commonvoice.mozilla.org

Quoted post unavailable.

Because most people have finite time and energy.

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#84

One of the tasks in this app is audio validation: > Audio validation: Listen to a short audio clip and determine if the pronunciation sounds natural in your language. If this is something you're interested in doing, I recommend contributing to Mozilla's Common Voice instead. Common Voice builds freely licensed (CC-0) voice datasets that can be used by anyone, not just Google: https://commonvoice.mozilla.org

Quoted post unavailable.

Probably because while some data has been open-sourced, there isn't any statement on what other data be open-sourced, or a comittment to it by Google. Voice data hasn't been open-sourced.

Mozilla on the other hand is a non-profit which will release the result of your labor under a very permissible license.

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#85
post #58

I was always a huge fan of Google from the late 90s onwards and was employed their from 2011 to 2013. I continue to use their services to this day. Unfortunately no matter how much you like something, when any one entity amasses this much power it's bound to make you a bit uncomfortable. I wish Google did more to anonymize and potentially distribute this kind of tech in a way that enabled anyone to run it. At the sca…

> Ultimately crowdsource leads to UBI powered by Google. It's inevitable.

UBI also provides income when the recipient performs no work at all for whatever reason. Why would a company support that?

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#86
post #64

Because calling it "free labour" just wouldn't attract quite as many people... Perhaps ~2 decades ago I would've been a bit more optimistic, but now that I'm aware of the authoritarian dystopia which Google and the rest of Big Tech are trying to drive society towards, I feel obliged to point out that helping it achieve that goal is a really bad idea.

I don't know what you are ranting about but the term "crowdsourcing" is exactly what this tool is created to do. Don't use it if you don't want to.

It's still funny a company awash in money wouldn't just hire people to do this.

And I'm quite sure people criticizing this won't be using it :)

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#87

I was expecting to be pessimistic, but Google actually releases the datasets under a permissive license (CC-By 4.0). Awesome! https://research.google/tools/datasets/open-images-extended-... https://github.com/google-research-datasets/hiertext

Btw what do those 'data cards' actually do? Can you get sued for going against it? Does it conflict with the permissive license or does that take precedence?

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#88
post #85
post #58

I was always a huge fan of Google from the late 90s onwards and was employed their from 2011 to 2013. I continue to use their services to this day. Unfortunately no matter how much you like something, when any one entity amasses this much power it's bound to make you a bit uncomfortable. I wish Google did more to anonymize and potentially distribute this kind of tech in a way that enabled anyone to run it. At the sca…

> Ultimately crowdsource leads to UBI powered by Google. It's inevitable. UBI also provides income when the recipient performs no work at all for whatever reason. Why would a company support that?

UBI is the "forever ticket" that insures the status quo when UBI is institutued will be the people in power forevermore. UBI is the means in which the 1% seal their and our fates forever, because there is zero incentive to change or improve a system where all power and decisions are performed by ignored automation for a powerless, uneducated and education-incapable 99%, while the 1% in power wallow in excess.

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#89
post #78

As far as I see this, Google want us to do the job...for free. No, thank you very much. Payment for this should be mandatory. Do not work for free for a humongous company.

Not for free! You can get useless badges!

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#90
post #48

Does anyone else hate what corporations have done to the word "delightful"? All the corporate art is so homogeneous too. Also a trillion dollar plus market cap company trying to get free labor? Seriously?

It's giving free services. What about that? And, not just this one company many other trillion $$ market caps give free and paid services and also welcome free feedback. When you comment on Yelp, Google Maps review, YouTube it's same.

"free services"

(...subsidized by the huge amount of ads inserted everywhere)

Post reply on HN