Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Pay

pay.facebook.com

81–90 of 262 posts

Re: Facebook Pay

#81

This should have happened for a long time. Facebook's properties are the places where my friends naturally ask for money from me to help. Even with all the negativity I see here in other comments, this is the natural way for Facebook to grow, not trying to compete with the Federal Reserve.

In an ideal world I'd love to see social media apps be able to loosely hook in to banking apps. So facebook messenger would handle requests and you would tap "send" in facebook messanger which would open your bank app with something like "Send $10 to facebook user ___ and let facebook confirm transaction success" so facebook never has to hold your money or make transactions, but you can make payment requests in messe…

The US is expecting to release this in 2023. https://www.frbservices.org/financial-services/fednow/about....

Re: Facebook Pay

#83

This should have happened for a long time. Facebook's properties are the places where my friends naturally ask for money from me to help. Even with all the negativity I see here in other comments, this is the natural way for Facebook to grow, not trying to compete with the Federal Reserve.

In an ideal world I'd love to see social media apps be able to loosely hook in to banking apps. So facebook messenger would handle requests and you would tap "send" in facebook messanger which would open your bank app with something like "Send $10 to facebook user ___ and let facebook confirm transaction success" so facebook never has to hold your money or make transactions, but you can make payment requests in messe…

PSDR2 (EU) and Open Banking (UK) regulations have this as a possibility.

I'm not up to speed on how fast implementation of the 'L2' has been, but this is a very real use case. And no need to open your banking app since delegation to your 3rd party app (Facebook in this case).

Re: Facebook Pay

#84

I can’t think of another company I’d want less to know my transaction and purchase history than FB/Meta. What happened to Zuckerberg’s shift to “video” or are they truly throwing anything and everything at the wall now?

fakebook is a worse offender when it comes to data collection

Re: Facebook Pay

#85
post #70

India is not in the list. But whatsapp payments are already available in India. So is Facebook pay something very different from whatsapp pay ? It's confusing since the page says "Facebook Pay is a seamless, secure way to pay on the apps you already use". And whatsapp is listed as one app. Maybe it's entirely different from UPI based Whatsapp pay [] https://pay.facebook.com/availability/

You are right. Upi is something unique to India so WhatsApp pay in India can’t leverage the Fb pay infrastructure.

However, it can elsewhere including the us.

Re: Facebook Pay

#86
post #70

India is not in the list. But whatsapp payments are already available in India. So is Facebook pay something very different from whatsapp pay ? It's confusing since the page says "Facebook Pay is a seamless, secure way to pay on the apps you already use". And whatsapp is listed as one app. Maybe it's entirely different from UPI based Whatsapp pay [] https://pay.facebook.com/availability/

WhatsApp pay is just another UPI app

Re: Facebook Pay

#87

I can’t think of another company I’d want less to know my transaction and purchase history than FB/Meta. What happened to Zuckerberg’s shift to “video” or are they truly throwing anything and everything at the wall now?

fakebook is a worse offender when it comes to data collection

Ignorance is bliss?

Re: Facebook Pay

#88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm confident the UI for their customers works great. Problem is you're not the customer.

> Problem is you're not the customer. What do you mean by this?

Meta Ads Manager has a much higher app review score than the Facebook app ;)

Re: Facebook Pay

#89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Meta has no brand recognition though (outside our narrow geek circles). Google doesn't have an "Alphabet Pay" either.

Seems to be the reason. In Brazil, everyone knows what Facebook is. Very, very, very few people would know what is Meta. How ironic is it that you need to move from a brand name to another because you have bad reputation, but still have to use the old name because even with bad reputation, it's still more trustable to handle money than your no-reputation new brand?

Brazil has WhatsApp pay
Post reply on HN