Live data from Hacker News

Lost languages discovered in the oldest continuously run libraries (2017)

smithsonianmag.com

81–82 of 82 posts

Re: Lost languages discovered in the oldest continuously run libraries (2017)

#81
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Regarding writing systems for English, have you seen this one? We had to learn about it when growing up in Utah: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deseret_alphabet

As a Utah native, I'm curious what decade you were taught this. I've never seen it before, but it looks pretty similar to one I created as a kid to pass secret messages back and forth with a friend.

It would most likely have been in a state history section some time in the 1990s.

Re: Lost languages discovered in the oldest continuously run libraries (2017)

#82
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Until Chinese romanizes it will never be a lingua franca. Simply far too hard to learn the written word, Simplified or not.

It doesn't matter how difficult a language is to master to gain the status of a lingua franca. Have you tried learning Russian? Or Latin? Or ancient Greek? I mean English has such a bizarro spelling system it may as well use pictograms. You might as well say "English will never be a lingua franca unless the English speakers overhaul their spelling". English is where it is because of the double historical whammy of th…

It definitely does matter how difficult a language is to gain the status of a lingua franca. The written word of Chinese is beyond exceptionally difficult to learn. Saying English has such a bizzaro spelling system it might as well be pictograms just indicates to me you’ve never seriously given learning written Chinese a fair shake.

What does a learner of English need to be able to learn to write a word? 26 * 2 symbols, and a fair understanding of the most basic spelling rules to give any word a basic attempt at spelling. If you didn’t know the spelling of president, you could very reasonably guess your way through it (begins with a ‘p’, ‘z’s are pretty rare and I’d know if it had one, etc.) Contrast this with the modern state of China where actual teenagers have difficulties writing Chinese without the use of a computer because the written word is THAT vast.

I don’t see what your other examples have to do with anything…those are all languages that use an alphabet?

Post reply on HN