Live data from Hacker News

Top Hacker News commenters of 2021

whaly.io

81–90 of 138 posts

Re: Top Hacker News commenters of 2021

#81
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’m around the same position as you and was equally surprised - I feel like increasing that count would be more work than I’d want to put in though

Why would you want to increase the count though, right? I appreciate that HN is a kind of a community where people post when they actually have something to say. I mean, I often write a comment and then delete it before posting it if I figure it doesn't really add anything to the discussion. I actually feel like doing it for this comment too.

I’m glad you didn’t, completely on topic for this thread. I’m sure you’re speaking for an awful lot of people on HN, possibly a large majority.

If you would like to contribute more, Caslon has a great post here with advice. It’s more than a game though, we all come here not just for the stories, but for the high quality comments. Contributing high quality comments is a real benefit to others, whether your gamifying it or not. Having the discipline not to comment when you don’t have a real contribution to make is also valuable, you’re being a good member of the community. I commented on this post almost an hour after first reading it. I wanted to be sure I had something I thought was worthwhile to say.

Another way you can contribute is through voting, especially if you vote based not on agreement or disagreement, but on insightful or informative contribution to the debate.

Re: Top Hacker News commenters of 2021

#82
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It could be so. IIRC, pg created HN partly to assess how these applicants laid out thoughtful arguments. You gathering much karma may provide leverage when applying to YC.

Would that be an extra reason why you can't delete your account ? :D

You can, you just have to email the mods.

Re: Top Hacker News commenters of 2021

#83
post #24
post #9

Heh, the fact that (IMO) I don't comment that often but still am in the top 5k (rank 4228, 185 comments) just goes to show how all things considered HN is still a very niche/small community.

It's very difficult in HN to put comment and gain points. Atleast for me. Tried couple of times. Downvoted most of times. So I just visit and read comments. Have been doing same for more than 7 years now. I am sure there are lots of readers like me.

> Downvoted most of times.

Sometimes this can be a signal about the content of your comment, other times it can be a signal about the content of the thread/topic.

There's a fun HN data mining project waiting to be done on voting/flagging trends, including cross-community topic sentiment surveillance within specific time windows.

Re: Top Hacker News commenters of 2021

#85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Name one that's apolitical, anonymous, and personally moderated post by post? Some reddit subs might fit the bill, or some car enthusiast forums or something where wide-ranging conversations are banned. But this is a hard, hard thing to mod. I don't think we have anything else like it these days. That's why I'm actually here.

off the top of my head: metafilter.com, lobste.rs, something awful,

metafilter is anything but apolitical, they literally ban differences of opinion.

Re: Top Hacker News commenters of 2021

#86
I'm number 536, suprising I made it that high :)

Reading over the top few names, even though HN doesn't emphasize usernames at all, I recognized quite a few of them. Quite fascinating and a compliment to their comment quality.

Re: Top Hacker News commenters of 2021

#87
post #24
post #9

Heh, the fact that (IMO) I don't comment that often but still am in the top 5k (rank 4228, 185 comments) just goes to show how all things considered HN is still a very niche/small community.

It's very difficult in HN to put comment and gain points. Atleast for me. Tried couple of times. Downvoted most of times. So I just visit and read comments. Have been doing same for more than 7 years now. I am sure there are lots of readers like me.

> It's very difficult in HN to put comment and gain points

Somehow, I find the opposite to be true. Probably I spend too much time on HN (as evident by the #66 ranking in this list), but most comments are just off-hand thinking/reactions to the submission itself. Some comments do come from being an experienced software developer who never had troubles finding work (which, I guess speaks to something but unclear exactly what, technical capabilities or be-able-to-bullshit? We don't know yet).

The times my posts do gets downvoted, I can mostly understand why, as I made the comment in anger/too emotional place. Maybe your comments are the same? The only time I really get downvoted without really understanding why (exception the emotions of the downvoter) is in various cryptocurrency discussions. HN seems very divided as soon as it comes up.

Re: Top Hacker News commenters of 2021

#89
post #50

Interesting observation: I'm place 3501, I have been reading HN since 2009 and I only recognize 2 handles in the top 10. I guess this is because HN de-emphasises usernames.

> I guess this is because HN de-emphasises usernames.

Not sure I agree, HN makes the username visible right next to the post? What I think (granted, I grew up with mailing lists and forums without images), is that we're so used to associating people online with pictures nowadays, that when there is no picture, why don't pick up the usernames anymore. Because I do recognize a lot of the usernames in the top 100, some even from just one comment I read but had an impact on me, and my memory made of flesh is really crappy most of the time.

Re: Top Hacker News commenters of 2021

#90
If OP is here: Would be really great to see each users top comment for the year as well, so we can get an idea of A) what kind of topics they are passionate/knowledgeable about and B) how much of the score for just one comment related to their overall score of the year
Post reply on HN