Live data from Hacker News

Cornel West Releases Resignation Letter from Harvard

npr.org

81–90 of 108 posts

Re: Cornel West Releases Resignation Letter from Harvard

#81
post #14
post #8

Harvard still has a divinity school? That's retro.

Do you think the Department of Philosophy is retro as well? Theology has shaped humanity, wouldn't it be weird for a school as prestigious as Harvard to not have a school for it?

Yes, philosophy was rendered irrelevant by the scientific method.

Re: Cornel West Releases Resignation Letter from Harvard

#82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know about that. He's someone I disagree with on many points, but he still speaks in a way that I understand. I may still disagree, but I find myself thinking that many of his points are interesting and/or at least somewhat valid.

Yeah I was over the top there. He’s smart and prolific. Public intellectuals are important, it just feels like he’s in that class that cares about spectacle over substance.

There is a growing number of academics who might argue that the spectacle can be part of the substance. For quite a long time, spectacle (or even advocacy) has been regarded as problematic in academia, particularly in the sciences. I see a lot of what West does as making “good trouble” that gets really important philosophical issues added to the general discourse

Re: Cornel West Releases Resignation Letter from Harvard

#83
June 30th, 2021

I hope and pray you and your family are well! This summer is a scorcher! Here is my brief and candid letter of resignation: "How sad it is to see our beloved Harvard Divinity School in such decline and decay. The disarray of a scattered curriculum, the disenchantment of talented yet deferential faculty, and the disorientation of precious students loom large. When I arrived four years ago - with a salary less than what I received 15 years earlier and with no tenure status after being a University Professor at Harvard and Princeton - I oped and prayed I could still end my career with some semblance of intellectual intensity and personal respect. How wrong I was! With a few glorious and glaring exceptions, the shadow of Jim Crow was cast in its new glittering form expressed in the language of superficial diversity: all my courses were subsumed under Afro-American Religious Studies, including those on Existentialism, American Democracy, and the Conduct of Life, no possible summer salary alongside the lowest increase possible every year. Yet I delivered two convocation addresses and one commencement speech in four years. I was promised a year sabbatical but could only take one semester in practice. And to witness a faculty enthusiastically support a candidate for tenure then timidly defer to a rejection based on the Harvard administration's hostility to the Palestinian cause was disgusting. We all new the mendacious reasons given had nothing to do with academic standards. When my committee recommended a tenure review - also rejected by the Harvard administration - I knew my academic achievements and student teaching meant far less than their political prejudices. Even my good friends in the Afro-American and African Studies Department were paralyzed, given their close relations to the administration. And after teaching extra courses, including five courses in one year, this silence continued. When the announcement of the death of my beloved Mother appeared in the regular newsletter, I received two public replies (just as that of my colleague Dr. Jacqueline Olga Cooke-Rivers who received none when her blessed Mother died). Any ordinary announcement about a lecture, award or professional advancement received about twenty replies! This kind of narcissistic academic professionalism, cowardly deference to the anti-Palestinian prejudices of the Harvard administration, and indifference to my Mother's death constitute an intellectual and spiritual bankruptcy of deep depths. In my case, a serious commitment to Veritas requires resignation - with precious memories but absolutely no regrets!"

Cornel West

Re: Cornel West Releases Resignation Letter from Harvard

#84
post #81
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you think the Department of Philosophy is retro as well? Theology has shaped humanity, wouldn't it be weird for a school as prestigious as Harvard to not have a school for it?

Yes, philosophy was rendered irrelevant by the scientific method.

I'm hoping this is sarcasm

Re: Cornel West Releases Resignation Letter from Harvard

#85
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, philosophy was rendered irrelevant by the scientific method.

I'm hoping this is sarcasm

I presume it must be, here is a post from them philosophizing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27789493

Re: Cornel West Releases Resignation Letter from Harvard

#87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Especially for a Divinity School, his point is that it marks a fundamental departure from the spirituality and community that made the school special at some point.

What does it mean to send condolences to a colleague when you don't know much about their mother? That carries the intimacy of sending someone a life event message because FB told you so. I really don't see that as "spiritually bankrupt".

It means “I recognize your humanity, and we all feel bad at times. It’s ok to grieve. I hope you feel better soon.” That’s what I hope it means when I send condolences to coworkers.

Re: Cornel West Releases Resignation Letter from Harvard

#88
post #83

June 30th, 2021 I hope and pray you and your family are well! This summer is a scorcher! Here is my brief and candid letter of resignation: "How sad it is to see our beloved Harvard Divinity School in such decline and decay. The disarray of a scattered curriculum, the disenchantment of talented yet deferential faculty, and the disorientation of precious students loom large. When I arrived four years ago - with a sala…

Does anyone here have any insight into what these “anti-Palestinian prejudices” are, other than the recognition of Israel’s right to exist that is shared by almost all Americans?

Re: Cornel West Releases Resignation Letter from Harvard

#89
post #54

I'm not a fan of West's politics (look up my comment history, because it's pretty clear what my politics are), but the comments here making light of West's objections seem completely off the mark. Reading the letter I see a few extremely salient complaints: 1. His first complaint is that he was a token diversity hire. Instead of his courses being placed in the general coursework section, his courses were put under 'A…

> No one would dare dream put a history class taught by a white professor under the 'European American studies' ... that's because no one would dare dream to have a 'European American studies' program in the first place.

There are "Whiteness Studies" that exist to disparage white people because colonialism. Actual positive in-depth looks at European culture, yeah, no, nobody's loony enough to do that in the current shitfest of an environment.

Re: Cornel West Releases Resignation Letter from Harvard

#90

I think Harvard has wrapped itself in an echo chamber and views itself as, well, invincible. Nothing can hurt Harvard. Nothing can tarnish its reputation. It doesn’t need anyone, with the money it has in the bank, and I think all of those billions has fulfilled the adage that power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely.

Their endowment is was $39 billion (yes, b, not m) back in 2018 according to WSJ.
Post reply on HN