Live data from Hacker News

DoorDash removing 1-year cliff for equity grants

blog.doordash.com

81–90 of 283 posts

Re: DoorDash removing 1-year cliff for equity grants

#81
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Eh, I talk to a fair number of undergrads and I think it has been tough this past year.

Something is off then. Are they in big cities? Do they not know where/how to apply? We’ve had a hard time hiring anyone, including entry level.

Have you adjusted your pay for inflation? The rent prices have nearly doubled in ten years, so if you offer 100k today, it's like offering 60k in 2011.

Re: DoorDash removing 1-year cliff for equity grants

#82

Not surprised. I'm probably a fair bit older than the average HN reader (finished undergrad in 1995). This is the hottest job market I've seen since the height of the dotcom bubble (mid 1999 to early 2000), and if it continues along it's current trajectory it will pass that by year end.

Browsing /r/cscareerquestions it looks like entry level folks are having a hard time breaking into the industry. Employers are mostly recruiting senior levels it seems.

I suspect that is no more the case than it has always been. While the overall job market demand might be very high now, I doubt that the proportions of demand for entry-level and senior roles has changed significantly.

Re: DoorDash removing 1-year cliff for equity grants

#83
post #34

It looks like DoorDash just put up a big banner at their front door saying if you want to stay less than a year and still get paid highly apply here. Wouldn't this move incentivize employees seeking short term employment thus diluting stocks given out to existing long term employees?

I think they do this to keep bad hires from sticking around until the cliff. It takes a lot to fire someone legally - oftentimes you have to document ~6 months of poor performance, put them on a PIP, give them a chance to remediate, etc. Combine that with normal long ramp-up times in a tech company, and by the time you know it's not working out and can fire them, they're pretty close or past the 1 year vesting point…

I get the point about unhappy employees sticking around just for their cliff to vest, but what about attracting a new breed of employees looking for short term employment?

Re: DoorDash removing 1-year cliff for equity grants

#85
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think it's common in the industry to see RSU grants shown as say, "$50k" - but that's $50k in stock as of the grant time. Once the grant is finalized, the value of the RSU grant grows with the stock. ie, if the stock is $100, then it's the same as 500 share grant. This Blind post is saying that Instacart/Stripe says you only get $50k no matter the price of stock? How would you even structure that kind of grant? Why…

all of my friends at google say the grant is in dollars and stays in dollars at google. at the end of the quarter you get a variable number of shares based on current stock price. While this reduces upside, it also reduces downside.

Your friends might be getting mixed up with annual refresher grants. Except for some rounding of fractional shares, your initial grant will vest the same # of shares every month for 48 months

Re: DoorDash removing 1-year cliff for equity grants

#86
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think there is a bit of a selection bias going on in that subreddit. I finished undergrad last May and had multiple offers to choose from well before I even graduated. Maybe covid has slowed hiring since, though.

I only had 4 offers to choose from. It's a bimodal distribution between the 200K+ 0YOE folks and everyone else.

4 is a lot

Re: DoorDash removing 1-year cliff for equity grants

#87

Not surprised. I'm probably a fair bit older than the average HN reader (finished undergrad in 1995). This is the hottest job market I've seen since the height of the dotcom bubble (mid 1999 to early 2000), and if it continues along it's current trajectory it will pass that by year end.

Browsing /r/cscareerquestions it looks like entry level folks are having a hard time breaking into the industry. Employers are mostly recruiting senior levels it seems.

I know many new college grads who got offers from multiple tier-1 and tier-2 silicon valley software companies in the same range as what I got as a senior engineer with 8 years of experience a few years ago. I'm talking base salary $160K-$180K, $300K equity grant, 10% annual bonus, sign on bonus, relocation...the works.

Not to say that everyone can simply walk in to these jobs (and they shouldn't!), but if a graduating CS major cannot find any decent software job today I'd be more inclined to suspect their skills than the industry itself.

Re: DoorDash removing 1-year cliff for equity grants

#88
> Because we see equity as part of total compensation, we believe employees should receive equity as it’s earned — every quarter.

This reads to me like someone looked at the data and discovered that almost everybody who stays employed for a quarter goes on to stay for a year. So they decided to try to juice some marketing value out of a policy change that makes no functional difference to anyone.

Why else would they choose to have equity vest quarterly instead of with each pay period? Or monthly, which is already typical after the cliff? If you believe equity is part of total compensation why does it need a different schedule at all?

Re: DoorDash removing 1-year cliff for equity grants

#89
post #81
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Something is off then. Are they in big cities? Do they not know where/how to apply? We’ve had a hard time hiring anyone, including entry level.

Have you adjusted your pay for inflation? The rent prices have nearly doubled in ten years, so if you offer 100k today, it's like offering 60k in 2011.

Starting salaries were around 75-80k ten years ago. Again, there’s a contradiction in the claim that college grads in comp sci can’t find jobs, and the suggestion you are making.

Re: DoorDash removing 1-year cliff for equity grants

#90
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a self taught guy transitioning from chemical engineering, I hope its not too hard. Starting my search in a couple months

Doing something similar, good luck. Can't tell if it's very difficult or very easy.

I don't think it is super easy. I think it is doable though
Post reply on HN