Live data from Hacker News

Google just launched prizes.org

prizes.org

81–90 of 96 posts

Re: Google just launched prizes.org

#81
post #61
post #14

This is a Google offering that only allows Facebook and Twitter sign-in. That's a bit odd; perhaps it exists for the purpose of getting people to opt their Facebook/Twitter info over to Google? More evidence for this theory: here's what Prizes asks for via Facebook Connect: …name, profile picture, gender, networks, user ID, list of friends, and any other information I've shared with everyone… Prizes may access my dat…

What would Google gain from such practices? Why not just ask you your facebook/twitter username upfront? Propally only a small percentage of their user base is ever going to use prices.org anyway. I think the story here is that it is done by slide, which still acts like it's an independent company.

What would Google gain? More opt-ins. Maybe more people are willing to opt their friends-list into a service called 'Prizes' with no Google branding than Google itself. Or even if not more people, a different set of people, who incrementally add info that would be harder to get otherwise.

The idea this is Slide showing its independence is interesting too, but why no Google/Google+ as even an option?

I think one of the potential problems with Google+ is that it is a "brand extension", too close to the parent brand, which already means something else to people. (To some extent, this was the problem with "Google Video" versus "YouTube", as well.) Maybe Google has empowered Slide to move full-speed ahead on a "Plan B", a network of many social sites unencumbered by Google branding. At the extreme, if all else fails, this could culminate in a new social network service by Google but under a non-Google name.

Re: Google just launched prizes.org

#85
post #80
post #38

That's from Google? Nah. Anybody had a look at the end of the source, they used a copy-paste code for the Analytics but forgot to actually put in their own GA number. >> var _gaq = [['_setAccount', 'UA-XXXXX-X'], ['_trackPageview']];

"Prizes.org is offered by Slide (part of Google Inc., located at 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA, USA)."

Thanks, good info.

And even more funny that they messed up including the GA code and tried to use some "async hack" to paste it.

Re: Google just launched prizes.org

#87
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But if you sign in with your Google account, how will Prizes (and by extension, every other Google service) get your list of Facebook friends?

If G+ wants my list of Facebook friends, all they have to do is ask. I'll gladly hand it over.

Not everybody is you.

Re: Google just launched prizes.org

#88
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This will be interesting to watch as an experiment in intrinsic vs extrinsic motivations. Personally, I think this will become a Mechanical Turk style wasteland full of people charging < $1/hr and churning out dross.

i had to google 'dross'

That is not something to boast about.

Re: Google just launched prizes.org

#89
post #9

This seems fairly exploitable. I post a question, and wait for answers. I create another account and answer it. I pick my own answer as the best answer, and I lose no money. I gain the information that others gave me for free.

I'm mostly concerned about the opposite. I can see an answer having 200 replies and none of them being more deep than an online search.

All the time.

It will be like yahoo answers with money. train wreak waiting to happen.

I assure you the best answers I gave/got at stack overflow and some other content specific forum was not because I/they needed $5 to help somebody else.

Post reply on HN