Live data from Hacker News

Argentine version of Google falls into “wrong” hands

en.mercopress.com

81–90 of 169 posts

Re: Argentine version of Google falls into “wrong” hands

#84
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just like that? A court order $4 dollar refund and have a nice day? That's a bit anticlimatic.

Not everything ends up turning into a Michael Bay movie when being resolved.

an important rule in life.

Re: Argentine version of Google falls into “wrong” hands

#86
post #51

Meanwhile, I can't even figure out how to buy domains with my name in them from people who just buy them and sit on them.

The internet's implementation of name resolving is wrong.

If you type "apple.com" you should get a disambiguation page saying "Did you mean the grocery store, the record company, or the computer company?" and from there you can reach the desired website. Somewhat like how it works in Wikipedia.

Unlike land, names are not a scarcity and can be shared. So why pretend they are like land?

Re: Argentine version of Google falls into “wrong” hands

#87
post #3

> >According to the Open Data Córdoba group (which is dedicated to tracking expired Argentine domains) Google's domain had not expired and, in fact, the expiration date was in July. But the group too was unable to explain what had happened or why. Ouch. I think someone's going to have some explaining to do in the post-mortem.

Yeah, MarkMonitor is not going to have a good time on this one (they're the company Google, and a bunch of other high-profile companies) use for domain management and tracking. They're supposed to prevent this kind of thing from happening.

Re: Argentine version of Google falls into “wrong” hands

#88
post #86
post #51

Meanwhile, I can't even figure out how to buy domains with my name in them from people who just buy them and sit on them.

The internet's implementation of name resolving is wrong. If you type "apple.com" you should get a disambiguation page saying "Did you mean the grocery store, the record company, or the computer company?" and from there you can reach the desired website. Somewhat like how it works in Wikipedia. Unlike land, names are not a scarcity and can be shared. So why pretend they are like land?

Land can be shared just like names, and the reality is there's only so many disambiguations one can learn. Even with that ability, consumers are only going to remember one apple.com.

Re: Argentine version of Google falls into “wrong” hands

#89

I recently sold cryptocomicbook.com and decided to list some additional domains for sale, at the exact time I listed them a handful of ua.(TLDs) got listed for sale including ua.com and whoever listed them must have done it in bulk and given them all the same price ($76). So I bought the ua.com for $76, at that point the seller must have realized what happened and immediately changed the sales price of all the other…

They reversed it because it was an honest mistake and most people like to know that if they make the same mistake it can be undone.

It may be worth noting that in most countries a contract essentially is established by the consensus of wills by the parties involved. An error in objecto ("I didn't mean the thing I accidentally said or listed") is a legitimate excuse and nullifies a contract. (The consensus didn't exist and thus the contract had never been established in the first place).

(This is also a reason why marketplaces, where things "just happen", are, let's say, complicated, as they do not adhere to this legal tradition.)

Post reply on HN