Live data from Hacker News

Erdoğan’s censorship now targeting media outlets in Europe

turkishminute.com

81–90 of 151 posts

Re: Erdoğan’s censorship now targeting media outlets in Europe

#81
post #69
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They applied in 1999. They were told what criteria to meet. They have not yet met them. This includes freedom and rule of law criteria. EU accession is not going to happen until Turkey is more like a normal European country.

It's hard to believe the process is still going on. I remember on the first day of a class in 2004, the instructor had everyone introduce ourselves. One of the students started with, "Hi, I'm from Turkey. You have probably heard about my country from our lame attempts to join the EU..."

I don't think anyone wants to definitively close the door, because then a whole load of ugly follow-on questions like Cyprus get worse.

Re: Erdoğan’s censorship now targeting media outlets in Europe

#82
I can't reach any Iranian website from NYC. DNS does not resolve.

Is this "targeting media outlets"?

https://www.google.com/url?q=https://www.presstv.com/Detail/...

Google is allowed to look at Iranian [headlines] and they have this teaser:

"US's Treasury Dept. blocks, seizes website of 'Iran ... - PressTV"

"Apr 25, 2020 · Tried before 204.155.146.233 and other addresses that point to PressTV but in the look up translate pointer table it blocks the ip address that ..."

Oh, I love the smell of irony, even in the afternoon..

Re: Erdoğan’s censorship now targeting media outlets in Europe

#83
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't believe HN is the right place to engage in political discussions but I need to clarify couple of points. > Turkey wants a fight. You need to make clear references about what and who you refer to when you say "Turkey". Even with a totally oppressed media and everything else, Erdogan's support in Turkey is in the band of 30-40%. Majority of Turkish citizens are not happy with him. Western world keeps doing the…

Yes, thank you. I am not one to mince words but think people make a huge mistake when they talk about what ${country} wants instead of ${country.leader} or ${party}

Yeah, westerners freely disassociate themselves from their leaders. But they abruptly lose this ability as soon as some other country is involved.

Re: Erdoğan’s censorship now targeting media outlets in Europe

#84
post #3
post #2

Really looking forward to see how the EU respond here with Turkey vs, say, China or Google or FB. It's just interesting to me how values change depending on whom you're talking to.

Politics is the general relativity of human relations. There is no absolute frame of reference.

Religion (with Theology/Philosophy) is the absolute frame of reference of human relations.

Re: Erdoğan’s censorship now targeting media outlets in Europe

#85
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Turk here. i doubt it. Average education level of turkish people is around 8th grade. He controls all the mainstream media, and preachers in the mosques. What remains as a free ground to spread the criticic voice is internet, which has been partially censored up to now and is going to be heavily suppressed as of 2021. And social media will no longer be a safe place for criticizing Erdogan, unless utilizing secure VPN…

> Think about republican voters and how fanatic they have become under Trump's rule in mere four years. Fanatics? Is that how you refer to different political views? If so, we are all fanatics.

Yeah, you're a fanatic.

Re: Erdoğan’s censorship now targeting media outlets in Europe

#86
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>That doesn't imply common heritage. spot the american.

Guilty as charged. So you think australia and indonesia have a common heritage because they are neighbors, but the US and australia don't because we live an ocean away? It's so funny, I was genuinely interested in this topic as my understanding of greece and turkey was one of conqueror and conquered, not "common heritage". I thought maybe there was history/ties/etc I was missing, but apparently it's just some politic…

The American educational system has really failed this one

Re: Erdoğan’s censorship now targeting media outlets in Europe

#87
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Saudi Arabia, UAE, Iran They don't want to, and disregard the human rights of large numbers of people already in the country. > Ethiopia Can't afford to. There is no solution without ending the war, and there's no solution to that without addressing the forces keeping it going. It's like many of the Cold War conflicts, a proxy for wars not being fought with Russia.

> They don't want to, and disregard the human rights of large numbers of people already in the country. I see, thanks. Is there any sanctions, diplomatic pressure that can be applied? I am just trying to put myself into the shoes of the average German who doesn't give a shit about geopolitical state of the world - they see a bunch of refugees with zero skills, language barrier and strong embedded religious fundamenta…

> This feels unfair to Germans and Europeans in general because of some conflict thousands of miles afar

If you were to talk to the refugees themselves, you'd probably find that they thought losing everything they couldn't carry and being stuck in a country where they can't speak the language, have no status, no recognition of qualifications, no right to work, and yet no safe way to return either isn't particularly fair.

> taking over

Could you elaborate on to what extent they are taking over? What political and military offices they hold, what property they own etc?

Re: Erdoğan’s censorship now targeting media outlets in Europe

#88
post #73

This is a very tricky situation. Two things come to mind. 1. Turkey wants a fight. I keep up on reading the western commentary and analysis about the region (Not the mainstream crap), and it's apparent to me that deeply-entrenched forces in Turkey want a fight. Our strategy so far is to do the best we can to ignore/placate them. I'm not sure how long that continues to work. 2. From time-to-time, we talk on HN about t…

I don't believe HN is the right place to engage in political discussions but I need to clarify couple of points. > Turkey wants a fight. You need to make clear references about what and who you refer to when you say "Turkey". Even with a totally oppressed media and everything else, Erdogan's support in Turkey is in the band of 30-40%. Majority of Turkish citizens are not happy with him. Western world keeps doing the…

There is a deeply-religious Islamist section of the Turkish elite, with influence in Anatolia, who helped bring Erdogan to power. Integration with the West promotes secular, urban Istanbul interests relative to them. An East-West engagement, with Turkey in the East, boosts their power.

Re: Erdoğan’s censorship now targeting media outlets in Europe

#89
post #71
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Turk here. i doubt it. Average education level of turkish people is around 8th grade. He controls all the mainstream media, and preachers in the mosques. What remains as a free ground to spread the criticic voice is internet, which has been partially censored up to now and is going to be heavily suppressed as of 2021. And social media will no longer be a safe place for criticizing Erdogan, unless utilizing secure VPN…

Not sure why you got downvoted, it’s very concerning. Before the coup attempt I was hopeful in democracy for Turkey. I believe it was then when most opposition was routed :/

Sad to say, but HN is also targeted by government-sponsored troll factories, at least from Russia and China. I can assume, they have "guidelines" to support "in a phony mode" anti-Western authoritarian and totalitarian regimes, including Iran, Turkey, and North Korea

Re: Erdoğan’s censorship now targeting media outlets in Europe

#90
post #73

This is a very tricky situation. Two things come to mind. 1. Turkey wants a fight. I keep up on reading the western commentary and analysis about the region (Not the mainstream crap), and it's apparent to me that deeply-entrenched forces in Turkey want a fight. Our strategy so far is to do the best we can to ignore/placate them. I'm not sure how long that continues to work. 2. From time-to-time, we talk on HN about t…

I don't believe HN is the right place to engage in political discussions but I need to clarify couple of points. > Turkey wants a fight. You need to make clear references about what and who you refer to when you say "Turkey". Even with a totally oppressed media and everything else, Erdogan's support in Turkey is in the band of 30-40%. Majority of Turkish citizens are not happy with him. Western world keeps doing the…

Support of 30-40% is super high. I don't think most democratically elected leaders have that kind of support among the populace.

I know you're just winging these numbers, but just thought I'd chime in.

Post reply on HN