Live data from Hacker News

Italian police use Lamborghini to transport donor kidney 300 miles in two hours

jalopnik.com

81–90 of 102 posts

Re: Italian police use Lamborghini to transport donor kidney 300 miles in two hours

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wouldn't be so sure, helicopters are insanely expensive. Not just to buy and fuel, but to maintain. They basically need to be completely rebuilt and every part inspected, after a certain number of operating hours. From what I can Google, that number of hours in usually in the low thousands.

why not use a gyrocopter then? It's cheaper, easier to maintain and more safe. Even if they are not that fast you don't have to get stuck in traffic jam, wait on traffic lights in the city and can flight directly with straight line from A to B.

Some countries are toying with the idea of using drones for medical supply delivery. A few are also sending defibrillation drones to heart attack locations. I've not seen anyone use one for organs, but I do not see any technical reason they could not if the failure rate of the drones is lower than human operated equipment. There are probably insurance obstacles to get over. Drones can fly in weather that professional pilots with thousands of hours of IFR experience can not in terms of average failures and the range of said drones is improving exponentially every year.

Re: Italian police use Lamborghini to transport donor kidney 300 miles in two hours

#82
post #17

Definitely this was probably "fun" for the driver. But I do suspect something wasn't above board here. I know it was mentioned in the article, but the choice to not use a helicopter was... putting a lot of people at unnecessary risk. Which is pretty stupid since you're trying to save someone's life. Hopefully someone does this with a copter in the future.

It was probably cheaper on fuel for the Lambo vs. the helicopter?

Re: Italian police use Lamborghini to transport donor kidney 300 miles in two hours

#83
post #17

Definitely this was probably "fun" for the driver. But I do suspect something wasn't above board here. I know it was mentioned in the article, but the choice to not use a helicopter was... putting a lot of people at unnecessary risk. Which is pretty stupid since you're trying to save someone's life. Hopefully someone does this with a copter in the future.

It's a PR stunt. Roads are almost empty due to lockdown, it's the police and everyone in front will move far away, it's a fast highway track. Numbers have clearly been cooked so that both Lamborghini and the Police get media exposure. If they wanted to do it fast they'd have done it at night and without cameras.

> it's the police and everyone in front will move far away

I’ve found in Europe (Germany, France, Croatia and Slovenia), drivers stay to the right unless passing. So the fast lanes will be fairly empty.

Contract that with US/Canada where cars will merge from the on-ramp, switch 3 lanes to the left and camp in the fast lane at the speed limit. All without anything in front of them to warrant such action.

Re: Italian police use Lamborghini to transport donor kidney 300 miles in two hours

#84
post #17

Definitely this was probably "fun" for the driver. But I do suspect something wasn't above board here. I know it was mentioned in the article, but the choice to not use a helicopter was... putting a lot of people at unnecessary risk. Which is pretty stupid since you're trying to save someone's life. Hopefully someone does this with a copter in the future.

It's a PR stunt. Roads are almost empty due to lockdown, it's the police and everyone in front will move far away, it's a fast highway track. Numbers have clearly been cooked so that both Lamborghini and the Police get media exposure. If they wanted to do it fast they'd have done it at night and without cameras.

That's my guess as well. A PR firm was hired and they came up with this idea. It's pretty much an ad for the police and lamborghini. The question is who paid for it.

It's like the jump from the space a few years ago sponsored by redbull. Or the bazillion "dog reacts to returning soldier" videos you see all over social media.

Re: Italian police use Lamborghini to transport donor kidney 300 miles in two hours

#85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On highways in Europe it is illegal to pass on the right, meaning that the fastest-going vehicles are supposed to be in the leftmost lane. On top of that you're supposed to switch back into the right-hand lanes if they're empty. Taken together this means that you can generally go pretty fast in the leftmost lane.

You are wrong. In the U.K., which drives on the left and is in Europe, it is not expressly forbidden to undertake (pass on the left) anywhere, including motorways. This is independent from the legal requirement to remain in the left-most lane if possible. On designated one-way streets, and thus not on motorways, passing on either side is expressly allowed. Of course, reckless undertaking at high relative speed on the…

That is only in the UK. In the rest of the continent it is illegal.

Re: Italian police use Lamborghini to transport donor kidney 300 miles in two hours

#86
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Even if you had lights on, you’d come up on people so quickly they wouldn’t be able to get over fast enough. This isn't the US. People aren't driving on the left lane just because they can.

I wouldn’t exactly hold up Italy as a paragon of courteous good driving.

Exactly, but this proves the point: if you are staying in the leftmost lane and going slow people would be up your a$$ or honking.

Re: Italian police use Lamborghini to transport donor kidney 300 miles in two hours

#87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a PR stunt. Roads are almost empty due to lockdown, it's the police and everyone in front will move far away, it's a fast highway track. Numbers have clearly been cooked so that both Lamborghini and the Police get media exposure. If they wanted to do it fast they'd have done it at night and without cameras.

> it's the police and everyone in front will move far away I’ve found in Europe (Germany, France, Croatia and Slovenia), drivers stay to the right unless passing. So the fast lanes will be fairly empty. Contract that with US/Canada where cars will merge from the on-ramp, switch 3 lanes to the left and camp in the fast lane at the speed limit. All without anything in front of them to warrant such action.

Well, actually in Italy is the opposite. The leftmost lanes are almost always occupied by cars, the rightmost ones by trucks.

Re: Italian police use Lamborghini to transport donor kidney 300 miles in two hours

#88
post #8

How is it possible to maintain an average speed that high on public roads? Even if you had lights on, you’d come up on people so quickly they wouldn’t be able to get over fast enough. And surely they had to stop for fuel at least once unless they have some special gas tanks fitted? Seems difficult

On highways in Europe it is illegal to pass on the right, meaning that the fastest-going vehicles are supposed to be in the leftmost lane. On top of that you're supposed to switch back into the right-hand lanes if they're empty. Taken together this means that you can generally go pretty fast in the leftmost lane.

Illegal ≠ does not happen, and actually from my experience of driving in Italy, passes on the right are almost as common as the one on the left

Re: Italian police use Lamborghini to transport donor kidney 300 miles in two hours

#89
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Even if you had lights on, you’d come up on people so quickly they wouldn’t be able to get over fast enough. This isn't the US. People aren't driving on the left lane just because they can.

From experience driving in Italy, people also watch out for traffic coming up behind them at speed and move over to let them past

Because most of the time, when you're driving already 150 km/h (= 20 km/h over the limit), there will be an asshole that comes at 180 km/h and that will headlight you until you move.

Source: speaking from experience

Re: Italian police use Lamborghini to transport donor kidney 300 miles in two hours

#90
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In italy the highest speed is 130,no other road allows you to go faster than that.

In 90% of the US the highest is 70mph in perfectly fine straight-for-miles interstates. Many are less. In Italy the autostrada legal limit is already higher at 80/130 (and supercar drivers frequently go much over it). And of course this is the police, they can make an exception for themselves :-)

I'm aware, i was just suggesting that there is no highway with no speed limit in Italy
Post reply on HN