Live data from Hacker News

A pacifist's plan to survive the violent world of prison

themarshallproject.org

81–90 of 136 posts

Re: A pacifist's plan to survive the violent world of prison

#81
post #16
post #11

One horror is the length of sentence - 10 years for a non violent burglary.

I agree, it's crazy to take away ~1/7th of someone's life - during their most productive years - for theft. Are we to believe that it takes 10 years to "fix" someone of their theft problem? Did it take 10 years for them to form it? I expect in most cases the theft problem would go away at the same time as the drug problem the writer explains they had.

The point isn't to fix the problem, in fact they'll probably come out with more problems than they went in with. It's entirely punitive.

The cruelty is the point.

Re: A pacifist's plan to survive the violent world of prison

#83
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you look at California, for example, you can literally verify that many registered sex offenders live just a few blocks away from any given person. The thing with prison mentality is that people forget that most crimes don't carry life sentences and that ex-cons eventually go back to the streets. So the question becomes how do you reconcile the secretly dark desire to wipe undesirables off the face of the earth fo…

That's a whole lot of words to not answer my question. Where would you put unrepentant rapists, if not in a prison?

It does answer your question: you kill them (e.g. law systems that stone them to death) or reintegrate them into society or just keep doing the prison/release/relapse dance indefinitely, burning through tax dollars all the while.

You may put a rapist in a prison but then they serve their sentence and might go on to become your neighbor, regardless of whether they repent or are willing to rape again. Where do you put them then? Who gets to decide who's unrepentant? You see how the question gets uncomfortable?

I get that you're trying to just imply that some criminals should just rot in prison, but that's exactly the blindsidedness that I was talking about when it comes to discussions about prison systems.

Re: A pacifist's plan to survive the violent world of prison

#84
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>10 years for a non violent burglary. There are two common ways to get a crazy prison sentence. Drug and/or gun possession often acts as a multiplier on sentencing guidelines for whatever the underlying crime is. Multiple contacts with the system (three strikes laws and parole/probation violations) tend to have compounding sentences so screwing up on parole or probation can net you an additional sentence than in addi…

> three strikes laws The three-strikes law is pure abomination, I've first learned about it watching "Oz" (the TV series) in the early 2000s, couldn't believe that that was real (I don't live in the States). 15 years have passed and there is still no real conversation about abolishing it.

Not only that, but the US just elected one of the law’s top advocates to the office of President. (And also elected one of its top enforcers as VP.)

Re: A pacifist's plan to survive the violent world of prison

#85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Last sentence is especially valid - decriminalization does absolutely 0 with organized crime earning tens of billions every year from all addictives. The same folks that deal in kidnappings, ransom, contract killing, weapons smuggling and many more. As a bonus health of patients(addicts) is not deteriorating so rapidly due to crap they take along with actual drugs, so bonuses go back to whole society in form of lower…

> Last sentence is especially valid - decriminalization does absolutely 0 with organized crime earning tens of billions every year from all addictives. The same folks that deal in kidnappings, ransom, contract killing, weapons smuggling and many more. Surely decriminalization is an improvement.

Sure, it is definitely an improvement and will improve lives greatly. But that still leaves work to do: It should be treated as a stepping stone instead of the end goal because legalization does so much more.

For this reason, I try to bring it up in conversations about decriminalization.

Re: A pacifist's plan to survive the violent world of prison

#86
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Last sentence is especially valid - decriminalization does absolutely 0 with organized crime earning tens of billions every year from all addictives. The same folks that deal in kidnappings, ransom, contract killing, weapons smuggling and many more. As a bonus health of patients(addicts) is not deteriorating so rapidly due to crap they take along with actual drugs, so bonuses go back to whole society in form of lower…

As long as it is more profitable to sell drugs illegally they will continually be sold and trafficked illegally no matter the letter of the law. Even marijuana is grown and trafficked by the cartel in CA, because of the onerous licensing process and the heavy taxation imposed by the state and local governments make it more profitable to operate on the black market. https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-10-28/…

To a point, sure: Tobacco and alcohol are still sold illegally. But most folks buy it from the stores, and if they aren't, adjustments need to be made. Taxation isn't generally the issue (as alcohol & tobacco are taxed) as long as it is easy to purchase and reasonably priced.

The other issue is that there are conflicts between state and federal law. Not being able to bank easily is a major hurdle, and these sorts of things need fixed.

Re: A pacifist's plan to survive the violent world of prison

#87
post #73
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm a pacifist and a martial artist. My first approach is de-escalation. That has failed, and I've been attacked by people, and still did not want to hurt those people. Nor will I allow people to simply beat me up. I've defended myself by deflecting and avoiding their attacks, using their momentum against them and whatnot; and when necessary, various holds or joint locks. I've also successfully fled situations where…

Serious question but how do you get in so many situations that lead to violence?

Just existing in certain places is plenty. It has been designed that way.

Re: A pacifist's plan to survive the violent world of prison

#88
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm going to guess that most prisoners that are assaulted don't report it. That 20% DO REPORT IT implies a much higher number that are assaulted and don't say anything.

The number is based on third-party surveys ( https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2811042/ ) - those surveys could still be biased, but I don't know that there's any better way to get this information and there's no obvious reason the prisoners would be incentivized to lie. You're definitely right that most assaults aren't reported to the prison authorities, for obvious reasons of retaliation.

They have the incentive to lie or they get their wig split.

Re: A pacifist's plan to survive the violent world of prison

#89
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

True, and our focus should be on correcting the societal failures that lead to people ending up there. Because prisons aren't going to away. But we can all agree that we should help people who need it.

The societal failings like prisons existing in the first place? The police and courts who supply a steady stream of fodder to the prison-industrial complex? The legislators who create innumerable and overbroad laws to give the above carte blanche to abuse vulnerable groups? By all means, let us get rid of all of these things.

By all means, let us get rid of all of these things.

Unfortunately the American people voted otherwise. See what Harris was up to in CA. Expect it to be rolled out nationwide. Biden created the laws that made it possible. They are a right pair.

Re: A pacifist's plan to survive the violent world of prison

#90
Maybe I'm too literal here, and there's a bunch of other stuff that could be addressed, but can I just complain that the article titled "A pacifist's plan to survive the violent world of prison" doesn't have a single word about exactly what kind of pacifist he considered himself to be or what this plan was? All he said was that he was a big dude and he didn't join a gang, which doesn't say all that much.
Post reply on HN