Live data from Hacker News

A variety of corn has evolved a way to make its own nitrogen (2018)

smithsonianmag.com

81–90 of 91 posts

Re: A variety of corn has evolved a way to make its own nitrogen (2018)

#81
post #80
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not guessing, I'm summarizing my personal experience with anti-GMO people. You're guessing about my experience and motives though. Also there's a lot more to GMO foods than yellow rice, so it seems you're proving my point quite nicely.

I am well aware that there are many other uses. That is the problem. Uses that are beneficial are the rare exception.

They're all beneficial or they wouldn't have gone to this stage.

Maybe you don't think the benefits outweigh the risks, and that's a valid question.

However, the concept obviously has tremendous potential. All the variety of life is after all genetics. Improvements in nitrogen uptake could save tremendous amounts of fertilizer and help the environment, for example.

Re: A variety of corn has evolved a way to make its own nitrogen (2018)

#82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah but where is that nitrogen coming from? It's coming from plants.

Yeah, hence the “Nitrogen Cycle ”.

Yes but they do not actually add nitrogen to the soil

Re: A variety of corn has evolved a way to make its own nitrogen (2018)

#83
post #64
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don't really have any idea where opposition to GMO foods originates. You guess that it is reflexive and unthinking because that is convenient for you to guess. There are strong arguments against, not necessarily GMO as a technology, but practically all existing commercial uses of it. Furthermore, each use of it is potentially an independent problem with its own dangers. Thus far the only beneficial use of it I ha…

golden rice is not available because activists in courts have done everything they can to keep it unavailable. This isn't capitalism, other than capitalism will not throw good money after bad fighting things out in court.

That is of course untrue.

What is true is that there is little profit to be made in distributing seeds that breed true.

Re: A variety of corn has evolved a way to make its own nitrogen (2018)

#84
post #81
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am well aware that there are many other uses. That is the problem. Uses that are beneficial are the rare exception.

They're all beneficial or they wouldn't have gone to this stage. Maybe you don't think the benefits outweigh the risks, and that's a valid question. However, the concept obviously has tremendous potential. All the variety of life is after all genetics. Improvements in nitrogen uptake could save tremendous amounts of fertilizer and help the environment, for example.

Everything is beneficial to somebody. Opium distibution is beneficial to poppy farmers, CIA agents, and, earlier, to the British Empire. Roundup-resistant soybeans are beneficial to Bayer.

Re: A variety of corn has evolved a way to make its own nitrogen (2018)

#85
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Did you originally think we had found a variant of corn that was able to fuse or fission atoms? Haha, that would be something!

The title says it does. If it doesn't, the title is a lie.

Not understanding that things is not supposed to be taken literally is a common trait with autistic people.

Re: A variety of corn has evolved a way to make its own nitrogen (2018)

#86
post #83
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

golden rice is not available because activists in courts have done everything they can to keep it unavailable. This isn't capitalism, other than capitalism will not throw good money after bad fighting things out in court.

That is of course untrue. What is true is that there is little profit to be made in distributing seeds that breed true.

There are plenty of charities willing to do that.

Re: A variety of corn has evolved a way to make its own nitrogen (2018)

#87
post #84
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're all beneficial or they wouldn't have gone to this stage. Maybe you don't think the benefits outweigh the risks, and that's a valid question. However, the concept obviously has tremendous potential. All the variety of life is after all genetics. Improvements in nitrogen uptake could save tremendous amounts of fertilizer and help the environment, for example.

Everything is beneficial to somebody. Opium distibution is beneficial to poppy farmers, CIA agents, and, earlier, to the British Empire. Roundup-resistant soybeans are beneficial to Bayer.

And to the farmers, obviously, or they wouldn't pay extra for it.

Re: A variety of corn has evolved a way to make its own nitrogen (2018)

#88
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The title says it does. If it doesn't, the title is a lie.

Not understanding that things is not supposed to be taken literally is a common trait with autistic people.

"Fix" is both shorter than "make", and correct.

Literality has nothing to do with it. Obviously they meant "fix". It would have been equally easy to say "fix".

Mistaking a riff on nucleosynthesis for not understanding that they were just being sloppy means some other thing.

Re: A variety of corn has evolved a way to make its own nitrogen (2018)

#89
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not so straightforward. Those with financial interests in the matter manipulate opinion and pay for lopsided science. That's why many globally and especially in the US still 'doubt' climate change. The evidence today is overwhelming but 20 years ago was still more muddled as Shell & co were funding biased studies, while experts and environmentalists were screaming for action and simply ignored. And still today t…

it's not self-contradictory to be eager for low-co2 energy and oppose nuclear due to its large-scale damage in case of an incident (and with Fukushima, 3Mile, Tchernobyl and various smaller incidents it's not like this is just theory) It is contradictory if one believes excess CO2 emissions cause global warming which may cause up to a billion people to become climate refugees in 2100 . A Chernobyl every year pales in…

Chernobyl has left millions affected by radiation levels high enough to cause major health issues all around Europe.

Re: A variety of corn has evolved a way to make its own nitrogen (2018)

#90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, hence the “Nitrogen Cycle ”.

Yes but they do not actually add nitrogen to the soil

Sure they do, they add nitrogen back to the soil that the plants extracted from the soil.
Post reply on HN