Live data from Hacker News

Hiring Developers: You're Doing It Wrong

devinterviews.pen.io

81–90 of 230 posts

Re: Hiring Developers: You're Doing It Wrong

#81
post #6

Why not just pair with the interviewee for half a day or a day? You will learn how they think and work and if you like them. It's a riddle to me. I've never heard from anyone actually trying it and not being happy with the insight won.

Because with a large codebase, you're not going to be particularly productive on the first day? I mean, it's better for web projects with a framework and set of conventions, but for, say, sizeable C++ applications it can be a serious hurdle.

Re: Hiring Developers: You're Doing It Wrong

#82
post #78
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That "opportunity" is not worth having no company-provided health insurance, nor is it worth paying both halves of the FICA tax, except for the desperate.

Because it's impossible to pay someone at a higher hourly rate than they would be paid as a full-time employee?

It's not the easiest thing in the world to explain, no, which is why I bet most people who do the temp-to-perm thing don't bother, and just pay the contractor according to their yearly salary. After all, if they don't know enough not to take the term-to-perm offer, why complicate things? ;)

Re: Hiring Developers: You're Doing It Wrong

#83
post #68
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why would the competent developers migrate to the company that is more hostile, in a purely objective sense, than the alternatives?

It's like they're almost trying to winnow the pool down to developers whose programming ability outperforms their career experience and business sense. They certainly exist: I had the business sense of wet paint as recently as two years ago (which might explain why I willingly worked as a salaryman despite having perfect knowledge of the hours and salary).

Or winnowing it to people who have experienced the results of conventional hiring practices and want a place that is more rigorous about it.

I spent many years hiring and working for companies that did it the way most people do it. The results speak for themselves: most companies suck to work for and most of them suck because of a few (or not so few) bozos and the environment they create.

Re: Hiring Developers: You're Doing It Wrong

#84

My last interview process was intense: 1. A write-a-document test. I was given a fairly simple (contrived) scenario over the phone and was asked to write specs and a deployment plan with a deadline of an hour. 2. A programming test. Again, a description given over the phone and someone available to answer questions if I had them. After delivery, there was a followup programming task to extend it from a client app to…

I hope they made sure to get you to sign a copyright transfer for the work.

Re: Hiring Developers: You're Doing It Wrong

#85
>But how did the candidates we selected measure up? The truth is, we got very mixed results. Many of them were average, very few were excellent, and some were absolutely awful fits for their positions. So at best, the interview had no actual effect on the quality of people we were selecting, and I'm afraid that at worst, we may have skewed the scale in favor of the bad ones.

This doesn't follow at all! Consider, as is surely the case, that only a small fraction of the applicants would have turned out to be average to excellent. The interview process can filter out the vast majority of the sub-average applicants and still leave you with a significant fraction of sub-average employees.

Re: Hiring Developers: You're Doing It Wrong

#87
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am getting down votes for this?! WTF? Look at the domain name and understand the original post, before downvoting! Think and then act!

Yeah, keep downvoting me and don't even have the curtesy to write a comment as to why!

I upvoted all your comments because it caused me to learn that the .io tld indicates "British Indian Ocean Territory", apparently meaning the US military base at Diego Garcia. I found this interesting for reasons I can not disclose at this time. I also thought your original post about this was quite harmless and if anyone had an objection to it they should have ignored the post rather than call great attention to it with what appears to be a gigantic downvoting and huffy post circlejerk that serves no beneficial purpose to the world at large. It is they who are the ones making response posts which contribute little helpful or interesting to this thread, while taking up extremely valuable and irreplaceable screen photons. Don't pay them any heed.

Re: Hiring Developers: You're Doing It Wrong

#88
post #82
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because it's impossible to pay someone at a higher hourly rate than they would be paid as a full-time employee?

It's not the easiest thing in the world to explain, no, which is why I bet most people who do the temp-to-perm thing don't bother, and just pay the contractor according to their yearly salary. After all, if they don't know enough not to take the term-to-perm offer, why complicate things? ;)

That may be. I have no interest in what other companies do, really.

I'm happy to pay higher hourly during the contract to compensate for the lack of benefits.

I'm happy to pay a (naive) employee more than they asked for because I know what the position is worth and have no interest in tricking them.

This isn't generosity, it's just good long-term business IMHO.

Re: Hiring Developers: You're Doing It Wrong

#89
welcome our store,we have the best service and good price,you can find what you want in our online store. http://www.monster-beatss.com/sennheiser-c-2.html http://www.monster-beatss.com/bose-headpones-c-3.html http://www.monster-beatss.com/lady-gaga-headphones-c-4.html http://www.mbt-scarpe.net/mbt-baridi-shoes-c-2.htmlhttp://ww... http://www.ghd-midnight-uk.com/ghd-midnight-deluxe-collectio... http://www.ghd-midnight-uk.com/ghd-midnight-collection-gift-... http://www.ghd-midnight-uk.com/ghd-nobler-diamonds-gift-sets... http://www.ghd-midnight-uk.com/ghd-pink-limited-edition-c-3.... http://www.ghd-midnight-uk.com/ghd-iv-styler-green-c-5.html

Re: Hiring Developers: You're Doing It Wrong

#90
Here's my 2c's on this as a 12 yrs Software Eng and a startup founder:

1) Software development is a TEAM work, so asking one questions like "how did you design this or that" is just pointless. We did design that on that specific period of time...Our motivation was ... 2) Good Developers Copy, Great Developers Steal (altered from P.Picasso), so we all use Google, HN, GitHub, wikipedia and alike to innovate our solution, so if you ask me B-Tree algos, I'm sorry, but I've to look at wikipedia... 3) Hiring process is just a scumbag for both parties, you impose big, the other party imposes big. So what? You're not Google, and he's not Kevin Mitnick... 4) I think, companies should try to get the personality, not the KLOCs of applicants. If you gonna ask programming puzzles, please be authentic and ask something related to you. Not just copy a Googlr interview question because you liked it.

Post reply on HN