"main" does seem like an objectively better word to use. The definition fits better in almost every use case. May seem like a silly gesture to some, but imagine feeling an emotional trigger every time you had to use a basic tool for your job. That'd piss me off.
counterpoint: I'll be pissed off and emotionally triggered, knowing that they bent over backwards just to be "politically correct" or "progressive".
GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”
81–90 of 280 posts
Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”
#82Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”
#83What bugs me about crap like this is that it ignores world history, makes these people feel good about doing nothing of consequence, and takes attention away from things that will actually help. If you are going to help, actually do something that improves the lives of people. Maybe, you should really put some effort into beefing up the Computer Science programs in black high schools and colleges? You are Microsoft,…
A small symbolic thing is still worth doing, even if it doesn't directly improve the lives of people.
Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”
#84I'm a strong supporter of social justice. I don't really object to people putting in work to change language like that if they think it's important. Especially when the work required is minimal. That said, this is slightly ridiculous. Have customers seriously complained about the term "master"? And my impression was that the usage was more similar to "master copy" than "master of the plantation". Honestly, it's frust…
I don't think it's because people are offended at the use of the word master, in this case. I think, that it's symbolic. By making a point of getting rid of the word master, you're showing that black lives matter.
Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”
#85Nobody cares about the black slave auctions going on in Libya RIGHT NOW. But we are going to remove the word master from our software because it offends people whose ancestors were slaves generations ago.
Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”
#86Earlier quoted context omitted.
I wouldn't be listing your git commits on your CV in the first place.
Please just answer the question. I have a degree called "Master's degree". What should I call it now? If it's serious enough to warrant changing everyone's git workflow, surely a small gesture like updating my CV to remove potential trigger words is needed.
Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”
#87I'm a strong supporter of social justice. I don't really object to people putting in work to change language like that if they think it's important. Especially when the work required is minimal. That said, this is slightly ridiculous. Have customers seriously complained about the term "master"? And my impression was that the usage was more similar to "master copy" than "master of the plantation". Honestly, it's frust…
> That said, this is slightly ridiculous. Which makes it actively harmful: Anything you do which is even somewhat ridiculous can be seized upon by your political enemies and turned into ammunition against you. They can claim your whole movement is about the ridiculous thing, and use it to derail discussions: "Yes, yes, that point is good, but did you know they renamed something in a piece of software just because it…
Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”
#88Earlier quoted context omitted.
I assume this only applies to new repositories.
So... 5 years from now will we have to constantly guess whether old repos are using “master” or “main”?
Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”
#89Earlier quoted context omitted.
If my dad died of Tetanus, should I be against memory safety?
The argument was "if somebody is emotionally triggered by using some term, we should replace that term with something else". I'm not suggesting it's a good point, I'm just pointing out that there's going to be a lot of renaming to do.
I wasn't really trying to make a point there, just wanted to be (arguably) funny.
Re: GitHub is working on renaming default branch from “master”
#90Does/did slavery only affect black people?
It’s really tiresome to see companies and celebrities voice support for equality, freedom, human rights in America while staying quiet (and even telling people to keep politics away from their platform) when it comes to the Hong Kong protests.