Live data from Hacker News

Judge orders police to stop collecting data from license plate readers

washingtonpost.com

81–82 of 82 posts

Re: Judge orders police to stop collecting data from license plate readers

#81
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think when the guys says random strangers, he's still talking about the police, just that if you leave it to individual police stations then anyone working there can basically wander in, not at every police station obviously, but if they're each doing their own info security, then many of them. One large database that requires a warrant to access can at least be more easily held to higher standards.

On the flip side, 1. the local Sheriff is much easier to get rid of through elections for not keeping himself or his officers from such behavior 2. the local Sheriff can be impeached, meaning there is a higher authority to appeal to when abuse happens. If the highest authority is committing the abuse, what recourse do you have? In general, it is always better to let the lowest possible authority level handle somethin…

This isn't a question of different levels "handling" the issues, it's a case of different levels maintaining their own databases of highly sensitive information, I still think a local sheriff should be running local investigations, but think a local sheriff seriously should fucking not have unfettered access to the exact location of my car at all times without needing a warrant.

Re: Judge orders police to stop collecting data from license plate readers

#82

What a pleasant surprise this ruling is. The DC area (of which Fairfax county is part) is probably one of the most government tracking heavy regions of the US. This is a curve-ball on par with the CA judge that overturned the mag ban recently. I would never have predicted this ruling. >Nine states have passed laws limiting how long the police can maintain the data, ranging from three minutes (New Hampshire) Now that…

What makes NH so special?

NH state motto: "Live Free or Die"
Post reply on HN