Live data from Hacker News

TWiT is suing Twitter, alleging breach of contract and copyright infringement

techcrunch.com

81–90 of 93 posts

Re: TWiT is suing Twitter, alleging breach of contract and copyright infringement

#81

Leo must be running into hard times. Usually this sort of move is a play when your main business isn’t thriving.

Seems like a legitimate trademark defence.

Twitter have gone lumbering into Leo's registered trademark class: "IC 041. US 100 101 107. G & S: Entertainment in the nature of visual and audio performances, and musical, variety, news and comedy shows."

What do you think they'd do if he started a microblogging service under the TWiT name?

Re: TWiT is suing Twitter, alleging breach of contract and copyright infringement

#82

How is this any different from patent trolling? Nobody confuses TWiT for Twitter, or vice versa. I don't think TWiT should be in a position to make money off Twitter's entry into video, just like some random patent troll shouldn't be able to monetize ludicrous patents

> Nobody confuses TWiT for Twitter, or vice versa.

It's been a nightmare trying to play TWiT on my Google Home Mini. I tried asking it "Play TWiT Live on iHeartRadio", and it replied "I looked for Twitter Live on iHeartRadio, but it either isn't available or can't be played right now". I get a similar response to "Play TWiT Live on TuneIn", though it usually turns that one into "Tweet Live".

Re: TWiT is suing Twitter, alleging breach of contract and copyright infringement

#83
post #26
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know there's a show called This Week in Tech, but do people actually call it 'twit'?

I’ve always referred to their entire network as TWiT. If memory serves me correctly, all their shows (not just This Week in Tech) used to begin with a bumper that said “Netcasts you love, from people you trust. This.....is TWiT.”

They still do. Here it is at the start of this week's MacBreak Weekly episode (at 24 second mark):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PFSJ2axjbW4&t=24s

Re: TWiT is suing Twitter, alleging breach of contract and copyright infringement

#84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Care to elaborate? I never got too into his shows, but he never seemed particularly uncool to me.

I was a fan of Leo from back in the zdtv days but over the last year I've had enough of him and don't watch anything he does any more. Reasons include his constant use of "funny" indian and russian accents, constant on air sexual "jokes" to and about female guests (he once admitted on air that Kate Botello filed a complaint with HR about him back in the techtv days and Shannon Morse and Sarah Lane have both made a #m…

Wow, yeah, that's pretty uncool. Thanks for filling me in.

Re: TWiT is suing Twitter, alleging breach of contract and copyright infringement

#85
post #78
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I like Security Now. And when Fr. Robert Ballecer is covering for Leo I simply love it. Leo is a little clueless on the hard issues, and Fr. Robert can milk more info out of Steve and go to more in depth discussions. Too bad he's leaving the network...

Exactly right. I stopped listening to SN, because Laporte being on auto-pilot for 90% of each episode does not make for an interesting conversation.

What I hate (and it happened in the most recent SN) is when Steve explains something then Leo asks a question about the thing Steve just talked about. At least try and pay attention.

Re: TWiT is suing Twitter, alleging breach of contract and copyright infringement

#86
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except an agreement isn't really the same thing as a contract. For a contract to be legal, there has to be "consideration". I'm not sure if anything qualifies as consideration in this case.

Allowing use of an existing trademark is a form of consideration AFAICT, although I'm not a lawyer.

Yes, you could be right there. Although a bit sticky since it is only a similarity of names and not actual usage of "TWiT" that Leo allowed them to continue with.

Re: TWiT is suing Twitter, alleging breach of contract and copyright infringement

#87
post #56
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I upvoted because Twitch is a really interesting case. The Levenshtein distance between the trademarks is closer, and Twitch is pretty much entirely focused on video, which makes it encroaching on TWiT's domain of business.

The CEO of twitch presumably didn't have a conversation with Laporte and promise to never get into the video business.

Yeah, I think the thing is though that you have to enforce trademarks early and evenly. You can't enforce for one significant breach and not for another. If you want to allow certain kinds of trademark use then you need to come to a licensing agreement for those specific uses, either by allowing certain forms of use or by allowing specific people to use it. Not a lawyer.

Re: TWiT is suing Twitter, alleging breach of contract and copyright infringement

#88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Care to elaborate? I never got too into his shows, but he never seemed particularly uncool to me.

I was a fan of Leo from back in the zdtv days but over the last year I've had enough of him and don't watch anything he does any more. Reasons include his constant use of "funny" indian and russian accents, constant on air sexual "jokes" to and about female guests (he once admitted on air that Kate Botello filed a complaint with HR about him back in the techtv days and Shannon Morse and Sarah Lane have both made a #m…

I don't mind the rest of it so much but I have to agree about the sexual joking around with his female cohosts. They are clearly uncomfortable, it's palpable. And he KEEPS DOING IT. I would give him a break once, maybe twice, but it is persistent in some cases to the point where it's borderline harrasment - and that's what we can hear on air. Who knows what happens when we are not listening.

It's a good reminder to those of us who assume otherwise that otherwise perfectly intelligent, rational and seemingly polite and reasonable people can be completely blind to this sort of thing.

Re: TWiT is suing Twitter, alleging breach of contract and copyright infringement

#89
Obvious attempt at a cash grab, as nobody is following Leo Laporte's productions. TWiT uploads on YouTube often have a few hundred views after months, nobody would confuse this tiny little podcaster with Twitter the social network.

Re: TWiT is suing Twitter, alleging breach of contract and copyright infringement

#90
post #8

Leo laporte is not a cool guy.

Care to elaborate? I never got too into his shows, but he never seemed particularly uncool to me.

The way he treats his female guests/co-hosts.

Accidentally streaming his private porn habits repeatedly.

Post reply on HN