Live data from Hacker News

Fidget Spinners: Why Being Interesting Can Do More for You Than Being Useful

betterthansure.com

81–90 of 147 posts

Re: Fidget Spinners: Why Being Interesting Can Do More for You Than Being Useful

#81
post #45
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's another silly fad toy object that you spin in your hand. A very successfully marketed one, that is.

another? what is the other one? the yo-yo?

"another? what is the other one? the yo-yo?"

Lemarchand's Box:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lemarchand%27s_box

Re: Fidget Spinners: Why Being Interesting Can Do More for You Than Being Useful

#82
post #44

Its not really an interesting product. Its a fad. The article really doesn't explain why fads happen. I think humans are just dumb animals at heart who like shiny things and automatically copy what other humans are doing without even realizing it.

I've never handled one or seen one up close, and maybe that's why I'm not that interested in them. I've only heard about them a couple of weeks ago, when by chance, I saw a video about it on my YouTube feed.

And still, I had to ask myself: "what's the big deal?".

Guess I won't know until I actually handle one.

Re: Fidget Spinners: Why Being Interesting Can Do More for You Than Being Useful

#83
post #44

Its not really an interesting product. Its a fad. The article really doesn't explain why fads happen. I think humans are just dumb animals at heart who like shiny things and automatically copy what other humans are doing without even realizing it.

Our ability to copy others is a sign of intelligence, not stupidity.

I'd have gone with the && operator on this one.

Re: Fidget Spinners: Why Being Interesting Can Do More for You Than Being Useful

#84
post #5

My brother in law bought one the moment he saw one. Returned it for a different color. Now he has 9. It's been 4 days. These things are definitely a phenomenon and the eCommerce world is going crazy.

My 45-year-old brother-in-law literally just showed up with a bag of these 5 minutes ago.

Re: Fidget Spinners: Why Being Interesting Can Do More for You Than Being Useful

#85
post #2

Anybody tried a fidget spinner? My wife has adhd and likes the idea but we haven't ordered one. Are these interesting for 5 minutes and then shelved? or do they have some lasting appeal?

I've kept a variety of fidget toys on my desk for decades. These are very simple, and the gyro sensation is nice and interesting.

Re: Fidget Spinners: Why Being Interesting Can Do More for You Than Being Useful

#86

Fidget spinners are genuinely useful though---arguably even more useful than the other items on the list, for their ADHD/anxiety-reducing properties plus portability. The only way you can do noticeably better is direct, hands-free brain stimulation. The fidget cube is also such an object, but it is MUCH more complex and hence vulnerable to be put down due to a competing distraction.

Wait, I thought the cube was just a bunch of interesting things to fiddle with, there's no problem solving element to it is there? And when I say interesting, I really just mean different switches with a satisfying tactile response. I fail to see how it's any more complicated to operate...

Re: Fidget Spinners: Why Being Interesting Can Do More for You Than Being Useful

#87
post #67

Seems like lots of people dismiss spinners as a fad or silly. They are a fad. But I celebrate the fact that they are generally simple mechanical objects that feel good in the hand. Not a doll, not a cheap molded plastic toy (ugh, Shopkins), not an electronic lump of stuff that will eventually leech into a landfill. (Yes, I know there are LED spinners, but that has it's own simple coolness.) I have enjoyed having ball…

I agree, kids don't get as many physical, mechanical toys. They just feel good in your hand, you get them spinning fast and you can balance them on a finger. Angular momentum conveyed physically instead of in some diagram in a book.

Re: Fidget Spinners: Why Being Interesting Can Do More for You Than Being Useful

#88
post #34

This is a great article about fidget spinners: https://geeksdistrict.com/inside-the-fidget-spinner-gold-rus... "Over the last month or so, the spinning toys have gone from an elementary-school fad to a nationwide obsession. Unlike many other toy crazes, fidget spinners offer a wild-wild west for global capitalists looking to cash in on the craze. For one, there are no patents or trademarks to worry about infringing,…

Can confirm. I just received 100 I ordered from Alibaba at $1.60 each. My kids are selling them to friends and people in the neighborhood for $5-7 each. They're going quick.

Hadn't thought about wholesaling to gas stations. Maybe we'll try that.

Re: Fidget Spinners: Why Being Interesting Can Do More for You Than Being Useful

#89
post #2

Anybody tried a fidget spinner? My wife has adhd and likes the idea but we haven't ordered one. Are these interesting for 5 minutes and then shelved? or do they have some lasting appeal?

I think the fidget cube is better than a spinner for actual adhd fidgeting.

Re: Fidget Spinners: Why Being Interesting Can Do More for You Than Being Useful

#90
post #44

Its not really an interesting product. Its a fad. The article really doesn't explain why fads happen. I think humans are just dumb animals at heart who like shiny things and automatically copy what other humans are doing without even realizing it.

Our ability to copy others is a sign of intelligence, not stupidity.

copying others is a sign of intelligence, being unwilling to choose something of value to copy is a sign of a lesser intelligence
Post reply on HN