Live data from Hacker News

LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

engadget.com

81–90 of 177 posts

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#81

- Replaceable battery is always good - Proper camera handle and better DAC too, but not as mutually exclusive modules What I want is: - A robust and replaceable bumper that integrates with the design (i.e. isn't ugly). The phone should not be designed as if the user isn't going to slap an ugly case on it. - A hole for a wrist strap so I don't worry I'm gonna drop my phone. All cameras have one, but now that phones ar…

There should be a case out there with a wrist strap on it...

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#82
post #5

It appears that LG is the only company to dare offer real innovation on its flagship models. I don't know how well this model will do but it seems it's not just a faster rehash of last year's model.

The LG phones have been great so far, I still have my G2 years later, everyone in my house has had them.

I have an LG Nexus 5 : common fault is that microphone stops working and power/volume buttons gets stuck (in my case due to case breaking near buttons from being in pocket). I have given Moto G phones to parents and friends - they seem more reliable.

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#83
post #5

It appears that LG is the only company to dare offer real innovation on its flagship models. I don't know how well this model will do but it seems it's not just a faster rehash of last year's model.

The LG phones have been great so far, I still have my G2 years later, everyone in my house has had them.

I have an LG Nexus 5 : common fault is that microphone stops working and power/volume buttons gets stuck (in my case due to case breaking near buttons from being in pocket). I have given Moto G phones to parents and friends - they seem more reliable.

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Those are excellent points. Old small flip phones sometimes had a small place for a strap loop so you can fish it out of a bag by the strap, and of course also to hold on to it. Phone straps are popular in Japan, and I've seen some that connect to the headphone jack, but it doesn't really work well, so the sturdier ones connect to a bumper. A bumper-design (maybe a groove to hold a bumper) is a good idea too. One can…

All agreed. I'd add that the market is slowing down, so bumpers could end up bringing more profits. First, customers would be more willing to invest in higher margin products if the device was more robust and likely to last. And manufacturers could sell official bumpers with advanced shock-proofing, a nice metal finish, perfect fit to the case, many different colors, ...

Good point about market maturity. If people are holding on to phones longer, sell them more accessories that people replace periodically, and make the base unit more also high margin (if they accomodate the official bumpers). But it's the consumer's choice -- they don't need to buy new bumpers if they are content with what they have. It's a variant of the razor & blades model.

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#85
post #23

Rant. It really bugs me when consumers ask for more features regardless of their feasibility, here we have a great phone with changebale batteries and yet we ask for it to be still on while we swap the batteries! Hasn't it occurred to us that maybe it's technically difficult to add in a supercap. Just be thankful. This is like constentaly asking for phones with more RAM and processing power, I am really glad Moore's…

Is it that hard to make a phone that works when it's plugged into a charger without a battery?

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#86
post #64

Interesting phone, horrible article. Typical of the modern Engadget, the article is light on facts and heavy on superlatives. For instance, I had to head over to some random Android website (androidHeadlines) to find out that yes, it does have Micro SD card support, and that it has 32GB of built-in storage (pathetic, Engadget). I do really like the idea of extensive expandability, but I wish it could be standardized…

The specs can be found anywhere and will be the same everywhere - or alternatively they might not be set in stone for every region or SKUs for different carriers not commented on. What someone on the ground in Barcelona offers readers isn't a spec list (though the specs would have been covered in the liveblog) but hands-on commentary - superlatives and cautions both. Calling the article "horrible" and "pathetic" and Engadget not "respectable" seems kind of blustery!

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#87
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree. I wish it had wireless charging like Qi, but metal cases apparently makes it more difficult to implement

In the past, I had a phone with wireless charging, but mostly found it a pain. Putting it down slightly in the wrong position often caused the phone to not charge overnight, and the charging was just too damn slow in the morning when I realized that it hadn't charged overnight.

I had a very similar experience with the Nexus 4, but that was a known bad implementation and I wouldn't go for a phone without wireless charging like my Nexus 5 and my LG G4 with a sticker that enables wireless charging.

My Nexus 7 also has wireless charging which has been great because the USB port is broken, so I have no other way of charging. The lack of moving parts in wireless charging does mean less chance of breaking.

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#89

My "is it worth even thinking about a particular device" litmus test is "can it run CM". Unfortunately that's impossible to tell for future devices, most of the time.

LG's older LG G4 still only runs CM on two variants. The international one (H815), and the T-mobile (H811) models as these are the only ones easily unlockable bootloaders.

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#90
post #2

I'm so glad LG are sticking with a switchable battery - it's a must have feature for me. Lots of people have forgotten what it's like to grab a wall-charged battery, slip it in and run out the door with 100% power in a few seconds. Tethering your phone to the wall sucks. Clunky portable battery packs are the worst. I hope this phone sells well, it has my support.

Honestly that sounds rubbish compared to just having a phone with a decent battery life in the first place. I used to think it was impossible (I had a Nexus 4) but my Z3C has an impressively good battery life - so much so that I rarely think about it. I don't even bother plugging it in for satnav duties. Also it charges at a pretty decent rate - probably takes an hour to fully charge from 0%.

Battery swapping is a workaround for flawed phones.

Post reply on HN