Live data from Hacker News

Is Self Hosted Blogging Dead?

robertnealan.com

81–90 of 199 posts

Re: Is Self Hosted Blogging Dead?

#81
post #3

No. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...

In support of betteridge, I still keep a personal blog on a vanity domain, and you can pry it out of my cold dead hands.

I'd be interested to know how you arrived at that phrasing as opposed to "vanity blog on a personal domain." I think it says a lot about why selfhosted blogs are becoming less common!

Re: Is Self Hosted Blogging Dead?

#83
honest question, how did Medium become so dominant for all blog posting so quickly ? The design is no doubt beautiful but there is nothing special. Curious why so many bloggers magically decided to publish there all of a sudden. I see tons of tech posts there now.

Re: Is Self Hosted Blogging Dead?

#84
post #83

honest question, how did Medium become so dominant for all blog posting so quickly ? The design is no doubt beautiful but there is nothing special. Curious why so many bloggers magically decided to publish there all of a sudden. I see tons of tech posts there now.

I've been wondering this, too, and design/ease-of-use aside, the biggest argument I've heard (and observed) is the network effect. Even trivial Medium posts get at least a handful of favorites and 1-2 comments. A built-in audience is likely an easy sell for the majority of folks.

Re: Is Self Hosted Blogging Dead?

#85
post #84
post #83

honest question, how did Medium become so dominant for all blog posting so quickly ? The design is no doubt beautiful but there is nothing special. Curious why so many bloggers magically decided to publish there all of a sudden. I see tons of tech posts there now.

I've been wondering this, too, and design/ease-of-use aside, the biggest argument I've heard (and observed) is the network effect. Even trivial Medium posts get at least a handful of favorites and 1-2 comments. A built-in audience is likely an easy sell for the majority of folks.

I guess that makes sense, but there are certainly other platforms with an "audience", like Tumblr, etc?

Re: Is Self Hosted Blogging Dead?

#86
The intimidating thing for me was always how heavy blogging software was. Never really liked the idea of centralized hosting, but hosting some huge PHP blob with a database never felt like it was worth it. I'm hosting my own site now running Hugo and I love it. I agree that most people have moved to centralized hosting, but I'm seeing a resurgence of self-hosting with static site generators like jekyll, middleman or hugo. Things like static search[1] and static comments[2] are possible with some thought. Really neat and lightweight and with gitolite, I can keep my git repo containing the blog code on the server too, setup commit hook to rebuild the site and I'm maintenence free. I have some npm postcss scripts that build my scss, autoprefix it, etc and dump it into the assets for hugo to build from all in one go.

A lot of this is unncessary, I could just be using css. I like that there's not all this asset-flow magic built out, just simple npm with bash cli. Unix philosophy and very little heavy lifting. I think there's still hope.

Now if we can just teach casual users git...

[0]https://gohugo.io/ [1]http://www.blevesearch.com/news/Site-Search/ [2]https://tlvince.com/static-commenting

Re: Is Self Hosted Blogging Dead?

#87
post #5

My problem with Medium is that it lends this amazing aura of credibility to everything that is published on it. I think they've hit on the design equivalent of the brown note (of South Park fame) which makes readers mentally incontinent vis-a-vis the credibility of the source of the actual text... Or maybe it's just me?

Woah, it was literally your post that just made me realize what medium.com actually is.

I've only ever accessed it via hackernews links and they were all to very substantial and well written articles.

Re: Is Self Hosted Blogging Dead?

#88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Static site generators are not a good answer for non-engineers, especially if customizations are necessary." Could be. Content and templates could be hosted on S3. Unfortunately I haven't found a good admin GUI for a static site generator yet. I use Jekyll myself and as a developer that's great, not something I would recommend to normal users though. Which is a shame because most users (or small businesses) don't re…

I recently launched Static Website Manager ( https://www.staticwebsitemanager.com ) which aims bring static sites to a non-technical market. Would love to chat more if you have questions.

I love it! Reminds me of the work we did with Statamic (http://blog.pixlee.com/how-we-allow-anyone-to-make-and-publi...)

Re: Is Self Hosted Blogging Dead?

#89
post #83

honest question, how did Medium become so dominant for all blog posting so quickly ? The design is no doubt beautiful but there is nothing special. Curious why so many bloggers magically decided to publish there all of a sudden. I see tons of tech posts there now.

Read what 37Signals/Basecamp who has spent 15 years building their (huge) audience on their own site says:

https://m.signalvnoise.com/signal-v-noise-moves-to-medium-c8...

I think the number 1 reason is reach.

Re: Is Self Hosted Blogging Dead?

#90
post #2

I use and highly recommend hexo.io with it's S3 deployment plugin. It's as good as Jekyll but easier to modify and theme if you come from a web dev background as it's written in NodeJS rather than Ruby.

What's the generation speed like with Hexo? I'm using Hugo but I'm not really enjoying Go templates so I'm curious as to how Hexo performs.

Behind the scenes it's just running the usual packages for templates, markdown, minification etc., so for a fresh build it's about as fast as any typical grunt-based setup. But AFAICT it correctly detects when things don't need to be regenerated, so incremental builds are quite fast no matter what, unless you're editing templates.

I recently converted my wordpress blog to hexo and blogged about it, if you're interested:

http://aphall.com/2016/01/migrating-wordpress-to-static/

Post reply on HN